32 books
—
2 voters
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Lady Tasting Tea: How Statistics Revolutionized Science in the Twentieth Century” as Want to Read:
The Lady Tasting Tea: How Statistics Revolutionized Science in the Twentieth Century
by
An insightful, revealing history of the magical mathematics that transformed our world.
At a summer tea party in Cambridge, England, a guest states that tea poured into milk tastes different from milk poured into tea. Her notion is shouted down by the scientific minds of the group. But one man, Ronald Fisher, proposes to scientifically test the hypothesis. There is no bett ...more
At a summer tea party in Cambridge, England, a guest states that tea poured into milk tastes different from milk poured into tea. Her notion is shouted down by the scientific minds of the group. But one man, Ronald Fisher, proposes to scientifically test the hypothesis. There is no bett ...more
Get A Copy
Paperback, 352 pages
Published
May 1st 2002
by Holt Paperbacks
(first published April 1st 2001)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Reader Q&A
To ask other readers questions about
The Lady Tasting Tea,
please sign up.
Be the first to ask a question about The Lady Tasting Tea
Community Reviews
Showing 1-30
Start your review of The Lady Tasting Tea: How Statistics Revolutionized Science in the Twentieth Century
First, my old review from reading it back in 2007 before my MS in Statistics. Below that, my newer review from re-reading it in 2013 before my PhD.
~~~2007~~~
I loved the overviews of fascinating philosophical problems surrounding the use of statistics. (For example, hypothesis testing is used pretty much everywhere but even the mathematicians who came up with it had doubts about its validity and usefulness in most situations... What does a 95% confidence interval REALLY mean, in terms of real lif ...more
~~~2007~~~
I loved the overviews of fascinating philosophical problems surrounding the use of statistics. (For example, hypothesis testing is used pretty much everywhere but even the mathematicians who came up with it had doubts about its validity and usefulness in most situations... What does a 95% confidence interval REALLY mean, in terms of real lif ...more
I think this should be required reading for every young statistician. All the other majors seem to have some sort of History of [insert program name here], but I don't remember one from when I was working on my major (in statistics). I felt this book was exactly what it claimed to be--a description of how statistics revolutionized science in the 20th century. Some people seem to think that this book is supposed to describe statistical methods like an introductory textbook. If you want that, you
...more
I really wanted to like this book. I love science history books, and while I am not a technical person, I appreciate the "Physics for Poets" level description that are a feature of many science history books. My problem with this book, and ultimately why I gave up is precisely due to the author's inability to handle the technical details. He says that he wife reminded him not to be too detailed, and ultimately he wasn't detailed enough. He described major changes in statistics, but it was hard t
...more
This was so interesting! It was so cool to hear about the actual people behind all of the names my stats training taught me - Pearson, Fisher, Tukey, Box, Cox, and more. It also served to show how young this field of statistics is in some ways, but how classic it is in others.
This book does suffer from the law of misonomy that Salisbury mentions often - “the lady tasting tea” is in about three lines. I’m not sure what the reasoning was there, and it threw me for a bit early on.
The author claims ...more
This book does suffer from the law of misonomy that Salisbury mentions often - “the lady tasting tea” is in about three lines. I’m not sure what the reasoning was there, and it threw me for a bit early on.
The author claims ...more
The first three chapters were the best. He started out with some really good stuff that was both biographically interesting and statistically informative. But is seemed like he lost steam. That said, there were still some good chapters and interesting anecdotes, and I generally enjoyed the book. I had to read about two-thirds for a class, and I finished the rest of it after the class was over, so that says something.
It's a book about statistics... but it doesn't actually talk about how to do stats. Instead, it's about the evolution of the practice of statistics told by someone who was in the front lines of its evolultion. Each chapter is dedicated to a person or development so that we see the field evolve over time. It's really a fantastic meditation on what we can do -- and should do -- with stats and what we can't.
My favorite part relates to the lowly p-vale. Where on earth did this thing come from? Sals ...more
My favorite part relates to the lowly p-vale. Where on earth did this thing come from? Sals ...more
The most popular image of Statistics we have is from Mark Twain’s re-tweet of the quote attributed to Benjamin Disraeli, "There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics.". With the advent of computers and vast amount of storage, ever more data is available for crunching by scientists. Consequently, we have ever more conclusions based on data, not all of them unbiased. Politicians, environmentalists, businesses and scientists have all been guilty of selectively choosing data to
...more
The full title here is The Lady Tasting Tea: How Statistics Revolutionized Science in the Twentieth Century. This book by David Salsburg is pretty much what the title suggests: part history of the rise of statistical methods in scientific research and part biography about the people responsible for it. This probably isn't a book for anyone not already versed in inferential statistics and related subjects. It won't, for example, teach you much about statistics, so you'll be pretty lost or at best
...more
I truly appreciate what the author of this book set out to do as it is not an easy thing. Collecting all the works and achievements of vastly different authors of many backgrounds and summarize their contribution to the Statistical Revolution in a cohesive narrative? Not easy.
But in a weird way, he managed.
Prior to purchasing this book I was made aware that this book might not be for everyone. As a statistics graduate, I enjoyed it because I could understand what he was saying (even though the ...more
But in a weird way, he managed.
Prior to purchasing this book I was made aware that this book might not be for everyone. As a statistics graduate, I enjoyed it because I could understand what he was saying (even though the ...more
I saw the book as divided into the early chapters where he covers the formative history of modern statistics, focusing on Karl Pearson and Fischer, the middle chapters, in which he gives a series of biographical sketches of important contributors to statistics and finally the last chapter in which he discusses the philosophical implications and problems of statistics. I enjoyed the first and last part of the book, but I really wonder whether the short biographical sketches would interest anyone ...more
I love what David Salsburg attempts to do here: explain the basic concepts of statistics by guiding the reader through the history of its development as a discipline. Too often we learn concepts and methods that are popular today without understanding why we use them or how they developed. But however much I appreciate Salsburg's approach, I cannot recommend his book. It is inconsistently paced, lacking in any real explanations of the statistics, and peppered with "when I met [so-and-so famous p
...more
Very interesting book! The first book on statistics I read in Chinese (translation), and the translation is almost flawless. Totally changed my view on statistics as a whole. Should have read it much earlier. The author gives a very thorough and yet reader-friendly account of the general development of statistics in the 20th century and how its fundamental ideas and philosophy revolutionised nearly every branch of science.
The first half of the book, the more exiting part, centres on a couple of ...more
The first half of the book, the more exiting part, centres on a couple of ...more
Statistics humanized and triumphant
The title refers to the story about the English lady who believed she could tell by tasting whether the milk had been added to the tea or the tea added to the milk. We find out here that apparently she could. At least in the small sample of cases recorded, she "identified every single one of the cups correctly." (p. 8)
The question--and this is the question that statisticians are forever trying to answer--is, was the result significant? Or how much faith should ...more
The title refers to the story about the English lady who believed she could tell by tasting whether the milk had been added to the tea or the tea added to the milk. We find out here that apparently she could. At least in the small sample of cases recorded, she "identified every single one of the cups correctly." (p. 8)
The question--and this is the question that statisticians are forever trying to answer--is, was the result significant? Or how much faith should ...more
Okay, you have to have an unusual interest in statistics to enjoy this book, and it wouldn't hurt to have taken a course or two in the subject. I learned that nearly all of statistical analysis was developed in the 20th century, with much of work done by math genius R.A. Fisher in England. Fisher published an obscure handbook of formulas in the thirties, but figuring out just what Fisher had done and making it general knowledge continued into the 60s. The great bulk of modern science depends upo
...more
I thoroughly enjoyed "The Lady Tasting Tea: How Statistics Revolutionized Science in the Twentieth Century" by David Salsburg. It was very entertaining and educational at the same time. The book recants the relatively short history of statistics highlighting many of the influential and colorful figures. I enjoyed learning about how key discoveries, such as the Student's T test, were made and under what circumstances. This book made me realize how much I take for granted the modern data-driven mi
...more
Jul 25, 2007
Abe Kazemzadeh
rated it
it was amazing
Recommends it for:
people who want to get interested into statistics
Shelves:
read-nonfiction
This book is good to get a broad overview of 20th century statistics. I think I learn good when I know the people behind the ideas, so this book is a very good intro to the people of statistics. It makes statistics a lot more interesting than just reading equations. Also, it gives a better idea of the problems that statistics aims to solve. Stigler's book, Statistics on the Table, is a book I read after this one. It's more detailed and has a different writing style... I like both.
I really enjoyed this book. Even though I knew nothing about stats going in, I was able to understand (albeit at a very basic level) the concepts introduced. Throughout I started having little epiphanies about how statistics influences my (and most people's) every day lives.
I also feel a little more prepared for my stats class this semester in that I have a real sense of why statistics is important, and how it makes data meaningful for decision-making.
I also feel a little more prepared for my stats class this semester in that I have a real sense of why statistics is important, and how it makes data meaningful for decision-making.
Odd, not that great. Problem is, Salsburg can't decide whether he's writing a history, a collection of biographies, anecdotes, or explaining modern statistics (early, frequentist, and Bayesian) to a layman, and so it winds up being nothing in particular.
If you want statistics history, I'm sure there are better starting points (McGrayne's _Theory That Would Not Die_ being one that comes to mind).
If you want statistics history, I'm sure there are better starting points (McGrayne's _Theory That Would Not Die_ being one that comes to mind).
I absolutely enjoyed reading this book. I highly recommend this book for all who teach stats as well as for all who have an interest in stats. It was interesting to learn about the personal lives of many statisticians in addition to their major contributions to the field. The reading was extremely accessible and engaging. Wish I would have read this much sooner. I'll be able to share more interesting information when teaching stats in the future.
This is a flawed book, poorly structured and struggling to explain concepts that underlie the statistical revolution in science. It would be better if there were a few equations or at least graphs to help with understanding. However, book is easy to read and full of interesting biographical anecdotes about men and women who created modern statistics. It can be recommended to those who know the discipline well and want to learn more about its founders.
This was not a book I had envisioned as being something that I would read, let alone grow to love. My experience with statistics had been limited to some courses I took in graduate school and then exposed to when I was on my first job, we were all exposed to statistical process control (SPC) and six sigma. My background in statistics only went so far as knowing some of the SPC tools. As I grew more mature I began to appreciate the usefulness of statistics but I had a hard time connecting the SPC
...more
I know this book since the junior year of college when my PhD roommate carries this book around as a way to take a break from intense research. The title looks interesting to me and one day, I ask him what good about this book. He answers with big smile: “This book is all about gossip in statistics”. I know back that time he is also taking a statistics course in sociology.
Four years after that conversation, this book never appears in my life again. However, for no reason, his comment about this ...more
Four years after that conversation, this book never appears in my life again. However, for no reason, his comment about this ...more
In a way, a peculiar mix. Philosophy of statistics meets biographies of numerous statisticians. I really enjoyed the philosophical part, where the limitations of statistics approach are described, and many concepts and what we know about them are challenged.
What I did not enjoy are all those biographies of statisticians who did great careers as statisticians in 19th century USA, but did not really re-think too many, if any statistical concepts. The part that described all those enthusiastic pro ...more
What I did not enjoy are all those biographies of statisticians who did great careers as statisticians in 19th century USA, but did not really re-think too many, if any statistical concepts. The part that described all those enthusiastic pro ...more
topics | posts | views | last activity | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Tango_Stat_Ed Boo...: Lady Tasting Tea | 1 | 3 | May 19, 2017 08:43PM |
News & Interviews
You know the saying: There's no time like the present...unless you're looking for a distraction from the current moment. In that case, we can't...
50 likes · 20 comments
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Probit analysis provides a mathematical foundation for the doctrine first established by the sixteenth-century physician Paracelsus: “Only the dose makes a thing not a poison.” Under the Paracelsus doctrine, all things are potential poisons if given in a high enough dose, and all things are nonpoisonous if given in a low enough dose. To this doctrine, Bliss added the uncertainty associated with individual results. One reason why many foolish users of street drugs die or become very sick on cocaine or heroin or speed is that they see others using the drugs without being killed. They are like Bliss’s insects. They look around and see some of their fellow insects still alive. However, knowing that some individuals are still living provides no assurance that a given individual will survive. There is no way of predicting the response of a single individual.”
—
3 likes
“In high school algebra, someone had already worked out the formulas. The teacher knew them or could find them in the teacher’s manual for the textbook. Imagine a word problem where nobody knows how to turn it into a formula, where some of the information is redundant and should not be used, where crucial information is often missing, and where there is no similar example worked out earlier in the textbook. This is what happens when one tries to apply statistical models to real-life problems.”
—
2 likes
More quotes…