What do you think?
Rate this book
Hearts of Faith #2
The Doctor's Lady
This is the Hearts of Faith trilogy by Jody Hedlund. The titles included The Preacher's Bride; The Doctor's Lady; and Rebellious Heart
378 pages, Paperback
Published September 1, 2011
285 people are currently reading
4202 people want to read
About the author
Jody Hedlund
87 books4,751 followersJody Hedlund is the best-selling author of over fifty books and is the winner of numerous awards. She writes sweet historical romances with plenty of sizzle. Find out more at jodyhedlund.com.
Jody lives in central Michigan with her husband, five busy children, and five spoiled cats. When she’s not penning another of her page-turning stories, she loves to spend her time reading, especially when it also involves consuming coffee and chocolate.
Jody lives in central Michigan with her husband, five busy children, and five spoiled cats. When she’s not penning another of her page-turning stories, she loves to spend her time reading, especially when it also involves consuming coffee and chocolate.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 426 reviews
September 10, 2011
As a rule, I'm not overly fond of wagon train stories, but I could not read this one fast enough! It's not often that I have an opportunity to practically fly through a book as good as this one, but in 24 hours time, I read this book every moment I could spare. Thankfully, my husband was very understanding as we went through an evening with me cooking no dinner, folding no laundry, and watching no tv. And yes...he survived. ;o)
Jody Hedlund has created a masterpiece in The Doctor's Lady. She had me smiling at the teasing nature of Priscilla and Eli's early relationship, and conversely, she had me in tears during a moment that no mother every wants to experience. If that wasn't enough, she created romantic tension so thick, I could cut it with a knife.
And this was not your typical marriage of convenience story, either. Priscilla and Eli's marriage was quickly thrust into the dangers of what would become the Oregon Trail as they dealt with rapid rivers, dishonest guides, and fatal diseases. Not only did they butt heads occasionally with their traveling companions, they also struggled to share their true thoughts with one another which created unnecessary, yet believable, emotional turmoil.
For those who are fans of Laura Frantz or Deeanne Gist, I guarantee The Doctor's Lady is a story that you will love in its entirety. As I said before, wagon train stories are not my thing as there are usually several portions that lag and I find my attention drifting. That is definitely not the case with this one! The action is continuous, the hardships believable, and the romance new and exciting. I have already carved out a place on my keeper shelf for this gem of a novel, and you better believe that it's there to stay. :o)
Jody Hedlund has created a masterpiece in The Doctor's Lady. She had me smiling at the teasing nature of Priscilla and Eli's early relationship, and conversely, she had me in tears during a moment that no mother every wants to experience. If that wasn't enough, she created romantic tension so thick, I could cut it with a knife.
And this was not your typical marriage of convenience story, either. Priscilla and Eli's marriage was quickly thrust into the dangers of what would become the Oregon Trail as they dealt with rapid rivers, dishonest guides, and fatal diseases. Not only did they butt heads occasionally with their traveling companions, they also struggled to share their true thoughts with one another which created unnecessary, yet believable, emotional turmoil.
For those who are fans of Laura Frantz or Deeanne Gist, I guarantee The Doctor's Lady is a story that you will love in its entirety. As I said before, wagon train stories are not my thing as there are usually several portions that lag and I find my attention drifting. That is definitely not the case with this one! The action is continuous, the hardships believable, and the romance new and exciting. I have already carved out a place on my keeper shelf for this gem of a novel, and you better believe that it's there to stay. :o)
January 12, 2020
The Doctor’s Lady is the last of Hedlund’s backlist that I had left to read. I was hoarding it a bit, but I’m glad I finally read it. It focuses on both the physical journey to Oregon Country but also the marriage journey of Eli and Priscilla White. Though a bit lighter than it could have been at times, the story incorporates some lovely truths. I wish that the main characters would have opened up to each other a bit sooner, as I got a little tired of the on again/ off again interactions. Both are strong, determined individuals, and that sometimes meant stubbornness on both parts, which did feel genuine. I enjoyed the details of the journey, both things that were harrowing and the more emotional poignant. The fortitude required by this type of journey is impressive, and I love that Hedlund based her story on real historical figures and events.
September 12, 2011
It was well-done in parts, but after awhile all the pent-up longing and smoldering glances got a little bit old.
I know that conflict provides the heart of a novel, but so much of the conflict here amounted to bickering between the protagonists.
Still and all it was a compelling enough story to keep me reading through the preacheriness.
Two things cost this book a fourth star in my mind.
1. Why do all these women have to be so beeyooteeful? Is it not possible to have a heroine who is mildly pretty or even *gasp* homely but kind ?!? And describing a grown woman as having "kitten eyes" was just too cutesy-wootsy for this story.
2. Near the end of the book the plot hinges on a main character doing something so completely and utterly unbelievable and out of character that I almost gave up then and there. SPOILER AHEAD
If you have spent years of your life planning a journey, spent 6 months traversing the country at breakneck speed and risked countless lives just to meet up with a man who is taking you on the final leg of the journey...
I don't care how dyslexic you are or how prideful you might be. You are not going to tuck away the lengthy letter with travel instructions (that the Indians tell you the letter contains). Your whole life has been about that moment and those instructions and you're traveling with THREE other people who can read them. I didn't buy it for a hot second. It seemed to be contrived to let the author make an eventual pedantic speech about pride and cooperation.
So that's why there are three stars here instead of four. And why Christian fiction continues to make me (a devout believer) bugnutty. There is no reason to sacrifice character and story for preaching. None at all.
I know that conflict provides the heart of a novel, but so much of the conflict here amounted to bickering between the protagonists.
Still and all it was a compelling enough story to keep me reading through the preacheriness.
Two things cost this book a fourth star in my mind.
1. Why do all these women have to be so beeyooteeful? Is it not possible to have a heroine who is mildly pretty or even *gasp* homely but kind ?!? And describing a grown woman as having "kitten eyes" was just too cutesy-wootsy for this story.
2. Near the end of the book the plot hinges on a main character doing something so completely and utterly unbelievable and out of character that I almost gave up then and there. SPOILER AHEAD
If you have spent years of your life planning a journey, spent 6 months traversing the country at breakneck speed and risked countless lives just to meet up with a man who is taking you on the final leg of the journey...
I don't care how dyslexic you are or how prideful you might be. You are not going to tuck away the lengthy letter with travel instructions (that the Indians tell you the letter contains). Your whole life has been about that moment and those instructions and you're traveling with THREE other people who can read them. I didn't buy it for a hot second. It seemed to be contrived to let the author make an eventual pedantic speech about pride and cooperation.
So that's why there are three stars here instead of four. And why Christian fiction continues to make me (a devout believer) bugnutty. There is no reason to sacrifice character and story for preaching. None at all.
July 18, 2015
I love the history behind this novel. Based upon the author's note at the end of the novel, many of the details were taken from the pioneers that made the journey to Oregon so many years ago.
The storyline of Eli and Priscilla was o.k., but it was the journey itself that kept the pages turning.
I'm a huge fan of Jody Hedlund. The Doctor's Lady is not at the top of my list, but a good read.
The storyline of Eli and Priscilla was o.k., but it was the journey itself that kept the pages turning.
I'm a huge fan of Jody Hedlund. The Doctor's Lady is not at the top of my list, but a good read.
Read
May 31, 2012If you love to be engrossed in a story deeply rooted in historical events, you'll like this book. Jody Hedlund researches thoroughly and weaves in details of historical events and conditions in a way that they are organic to her stories. This one recreates the experience of being the first woman to travel across the country, braving privation and danger to reach the Oregon territory--and or course find love along the way.
July 3, 2018
I'm hoping this one is different from the other Jody Hedlund books I've read. It features a MOC, but at least there isn't any should I marry him/do I marry her wishy washiness. :)
2.75 stars. I thought we would be bypassing the angst since this story features a marriage of convenience, but what I didn't know was that . I appreciated the hardships and the often hostile environment that the characters endured. Jody Hedlund not only brought to life the danger of their journey but also the beauty they encountered in their surroundings and in the people they met. The historical aspect of this story was interesting, but the MCs weren't that likable. The H spent the majority of the book being hot and cold toward his wife, the h. He was a jerk at times, and I felt pretty bad for the h. On the other hand, she was too passive for me to like her. First, she let her mother run roughshod all over her and then she let her husband do it. And while the idea of a woman who is infertile might have been a source of shame in that time period, it bothered me that the author didn't have the h change her attitude toward her condition until almost the end of the book. Calling herself an "incomplete woman" or an "incomplete wife" bothered me a lot.
I do have to say that I appreciated that this story didn't focus on the romance of the story much. Since the love story between the MCs was slow in coming and then unconvincing, that fact didn't bother me much. I also like that the MCs didn't focus a lot on the attractive physical attributes of the other person. That was refreshingly mature.
Overall, I would recommend this book to someone who enjoys historical inspiration fiction, but only if you like eleventh hour declarations and a story that doesn't revolve around romance. The MCs also didn't rely on God much. They did most things by their own strength. I would have been interested in reading about what happened after they started trusting Him more. That would have been interesting. The journey there, however, was a bit dull.
2.75 stars. I thought we would be bypassing the angst since this story features a marriage of convenience, but what I didn't know was that . I appreciated the hardships and the often hostile environment that the characters endured. Jody Hedlund not only brought to life the danger of their journey but also the beauty they encountered in their surroundings and in the people they met. The historical aspect of this story was interesting, but the MCs weren't that likable. The H spent the majority of the book being hot and cold toward his wife, the h. He was a jerk at times, and I felt pretty bad for the h. On the other hand, she was too passive for me to like her. First, she let her mother run roughshod all over her and then she let her husband do it. And while the idea of a woman who is infertile might have been a source of shame in that time period, it bothered me that the author didn't have the h change her attitude toward her condition until almost the end of the book. Calling herself an "incomplete woman" or an "incomplete wife" bothered me a lot.
I do have to say that I appreciated that this story didn't focus on the romance of the story much. Since the love story between the MCs was slow in coming and then unconvincing, that fact didn't bother me much. I also like that the MCs didn't focus a lot on the attractive physical attributes of the other person. That was refreshingly mature.
Overall, I would recommend this book to someone who enjoys historical inspiration fiction, but only if you like eleventh hour declarations and a story that doesn't revolve around romance. The MCs also didn't rely on God much. They did most things by their own strength. I would have been interested in reading about what happened after they started trusting Him more. That would have been interesting. The journey there, however, was a bit dull.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 10, 2016
This was one of the most gripping, heartfelt stories I have read in a long time. Jody Hedlund brings the characters and the trials and tribulations they face along their journey to life. I felt like I was traveling with them. The story was well-written and beautifully captured Eli and Priscilla's story.
http://faithlovebooks.blogspot.com/20...
http://faithlovebooks.blogspot.com/20...
September 26, 2011
Review first posted on my blog, Legacy of a Writer.
It’s not often I read a historical fiction that so enthralled me, I could not stop reading, but that's what I discovered in this book. The Doctor’s Lady has officially been dubbed my favorite historical of the year! Gripping me in a way that few books but suspense/thrillers do, I was pulled into the characters’ lives. Even after I finished the book, I was still so wrapped up in Priscilla and Eli’s world!
Both Priscilla White and Eli Ernest are memorable, believable characters. It didn’t take me long to fall in love with Eli’s strong, but gentle ways. Wow, he sure sounded like a hunk! Priscilla’s determined and strong spirit was what drew me to her as she set out to cross the western plains on a trail that no white woman had tried before. What a daunting—and very frightening—undertaking, yet Priscilla puts her trust in the Lord and sets out with head high. I loved her plucky spirit!
More than I had expected from a historical, The Doctor’s Lady had a really suspense edge to it. Continually on a deadline to reach their next checkpoint, several times their little band arrived too late. Their journey took around eight months, and there was constant stress and lurking danger in many different forms. I highly encourage you to read the Author’s Notes at the back of the book (yep, I always do!). You will be astounded how many things that take place in this book are what really happened to Narcissa Whitman, the first white woman to travel to Oregon.
I read (and really enjoyed!) Jody’s debut novel, The Preacher’s Bride, earlier this year and could tell this author had talent. What made this next release even better is I could just feel the improvement—in her writing, storyplot, characters…everything! The Doctor’s Lady seemed to breathe life with each word Jody penned. Wonderful and completely captivating!
While I’ve read many good historical fiction books this year, The Doctor’s Lady had something about it that instantly pushed it ahead of all the others to rest on my favorite’s bookshelf. And there I am sure it will remain, to be picked up in the near future and reread at leisure. If you love a heartwarming historical fiction to curl up with on the couch, this is the book to grab for. Open the book and go west with Priscilla and Eli, and be prepared to never think of Narcissa Whitman’s story the same way again. In short, I highly recommend this book. Read it!
It’s not often I read a historical fiction that so enthralled me, I could not stop reading, but that's what I discovered in this book. The Doctor’s Lady has officially been dubbed my favorite historical of the year! Gripping me in a way that few books but suspense/thrillers do, I was pulled into the characters’ lives. Even after I finished the book, I was still so wrapped up in Priscilla and Eli’s world!
Both Priscilla White and Eli Ernest are memorable, believable characters. It didn’t take me long to fall in love with Eli’s strong, but gentle ways. Wow, he sure sounded like a hunk! Priscilla’s determined and strong spirit was what drew me to her as she set out to cross the western plains on a trail that no white woman had tried before. What a daunting—and very frightening—undertaking, yet Priscilla puts her trust in the Lord and sets out with head high. I loved her plucky spirit!
More than I had expected from a historical, The Doctor’s Lady had a really suspense edge to it. Continually on a deadline to reach their next checkpoint, several times their little band arrived too late. Their journey took around eight months, and there was constant stress and lurking danger in many different forms. I highly encourage you to read the Author’s Notes at the back of the book (yep, I always do!). You will be astounded how many things that take place in this book are what really happened to Narcissa Whitman, the first white woman to travel to Oregon.
I read (and really enjoyed!) Jody’s debut novel, The Preacher’s Bride, earlier this year and could tell this author had talent. What made this next release even better is I could just feel the improvement—in her writing, storyplot, characters…everything! The Doctor’s Lady seemed to breathe life with each word Jody penned. Wonderful and completely captivating!
While I’ve read many good historical fiction books this year, The Doctor’s Lady had something about it that instantly pushed it ahead of all the others to rest on my favorite’s bookshelf. And there I am sure it will remain, to be picked up in the near future and reread at leisure. If you love a heartwarming historical fiction to curl up with on the couch, this is the book to grab for. Open the book and go west with Priscilla and Eli, and be prepared to never think of Narcissa Whitman’s story the same way again. In short, I highly recommend this book. Read it!
November 30, 2011
When I received the opportunity to read this novel, I jumped at the chance! I had read so many wonderful things about Jody Hedlund's writing, that I knew I couldn't pass it up. Within just a few pages, I knew that all of the 5 star reviews were right -- The Doctor's Lady is a story not to be missed! And as the old saying goes, you can't judge a book by its cover, well with this one you can. The cover is one of the most gorgeous I've seen, and the story inside the cover is just as captivating; one that I won't soon forget.
With romantic tension, realistic characters, and plenty of action, there wasn't anything about the story that I didn't like. The pacing was fantastic, with never a dull moment in sight. And the romance? Well, let's just say my heart skipped a beat on several occasions. Jody has certainly impressed me with her ability to write an engaging, faith-filled story -- so much so, that I can't wait to read the rest of her work!
What I love about Priscilla, is that she's so easy to relate to. I could identify with her on so many levels. On several occasions in the book, I found myself thinking, "That's exactly how I would feel," or "That's just how I would respond!" She has a strong desire to serve the Lord and to be a missionary, but she doubts her abilities when she's out of her comfort zone. She knows that she's lived a pampered, sheltered life, and at times it leaves her feeling weak and selfish. She's truly a wonderful character, and I really appreciate how Jody's portrayal of Priscilla "walking out her faith," led me to examine my own heart.
I love the historical aspect of the novel, and how well Jody took the real story of Marcus and Narcissa Whitman, and created it into a magnificent novel that explores all of the hope and heartache of westward expansion. If you're a fan of this type of historical, I think you'll be very happy with one. I loved every moment of this story, and highly recommend it!
**Thank you to the publisher for providing a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.**
With romantic tension, realistic characters, and plenty of action, there wasn't anything about the story that I didn't like. The pacing was fantastic, with never a dull moment in sight. And the romance? Well, let's just say my heart skipped a beat on several occasions. Jody has certainly impressed me with her ability to write an engaging, faith-filled story -- so much so, that I can't wait to read the rest of her work!
What I love about Priscilla, is that she's so easy to relate to. I could identify with her on so many levels. On several occasions in the book, I found myself thinking, "That's exactly how I would feel," or "That's just how I would respond!" She has a strong desire to serve the Lord and to be a missionary, but she doubts her abilities when she's out of her comfort zone. She knows that she's lived a pampered, sheltered life, and at times it leaves her feeling weak and selfish. She's truly a wonderful character, and I really appreciate how Jody's portrayal of Priscilla "walking out her faith," led me to examine my own heart.
I love the historical aspect of the novel, and how well Jody took the real story of Marcus and Narcissa Whitman, and created it into a magnificent novel that explores all of the hope and heartache of westward expansion. If you're a fan of this type of historical, I think you'll be very happy with one. I loved every moment of this story, and highly recommend it!
**Thank you to the publisher for providing a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.**
March 18, 2020
Inspired by missionaries, Marcus and Narcissa Whitman, and their difficult cross-country trip to serve the Nez Perce Indians in Oregon, this story had its ups and downs...literally. Across endless prairies, up rocky heights, down treacherous mountainsides, two missionary couples (names detailed below) faced many adventures, hardships and desertions along the way.
Maybe not my favorite book by this author’s, but still very good.
Time and location: 1836, Angelica New York to the west coast along the Oregon Trail.
Characters:
Dr. Eli Ernest: Missionary on his way back to Oregon, had to find a wife
Priscilla White: Heart set on never marrying, instead devoted to being a missionary in India
(Both married for convenience and set off for Oregon to Nez Perce Indians)
Henry and Mabel Spaulding: Missionary couple they traveled with..Mabel, surprisingly pregnant
John and Richard, English names for two Nez Perce Indian boys who crossed the country with Dr. Ernest
Maybe not my favorite book by this author’s, but still very good.
Time and location: 1836, Angelica New York to the west coast along the Oregon Trail.
Characters:
Dr. Eli Ernest: Missionary on his way back to Oregon, had to find a wife
Priscilla White: Heart set on never marrying, instead devoted to being a missionary in India
(Both married for convenience and set off for Oregon to Nez Perce Indians)
Henry and Mabel Spaulding: Missionary couple they traveled with..Mabel, surprisingly pregnant
John and Richard, English names for two Nez Perce Indian boys who crossed the country with Dr. Ernest
May 15, 2013
This is the second book I've read by Jody Hedlund. Such an incredible story of the rough journey of Narcissa and Marcus Whitman. What I love so much about Jody's stories is her creative portrayal of real people and their struggles. My heart was so sensitive for each person in this book the entire time that I read it... especially for Priscilla. Being barren and having to endure children and pregnant women would be something I wouldn't be able to handle. It broke my heart when the one thing she yearned for was stripped from her. I wept much while reading this book, but I also saw how each person was determined to complete the journey for the sake of the mission. I am also a sucker for marriages of convenience... I'm thinking that I should end up in a situation that calls for a marriage of convenience. I'm ready for it =)
February 2, 2013
I was looking forward to going west on what would become the Oregon trail, as the first white woman. In 1836, no white woman had traveled that far, and the name Oregon trail wasn't even birthed yet. At that time, it was missionary law that a married couple must make the journey together to prevent the intermixing of white man with the Indian woman, or heathens, as they were called since they had not been exposed to the gospel, and were therefore living uncivilized. So, Eli and Priscilla entered into an agreed marriage, or business partnership, so the missionary group would allow and fund their efforts. I was disappointed that once the journey began, there was an extreme childish focus on their crush that was growing each day. The inner dialect vocalized the inner turmoil and it was a she/he loves me, she/he loves me not at its worst. Eli felt compelled to keep his feelings at bay so in the event the journey became too dangerous, he could live up to his end of the bargain and ship Priscilla back to NY with the promised annulment. The feelings the author continued to voice were melodramatic and ridiculous considering no woman would travel that far and endure that much to reach the finish line and call it quits. What would be the point in suffering for so many months, and suffering they did! I was delighted to discover at the very end of the book that this novel was based on an actual couple and the events that the author depicted were taken from the diary of the actual first white woman to go that far west. Even the discovery that the actual couple entered into marriage under the same pretenses was interesting to me. And, just as Eli and Priscilla grew to love one another, the actual couple did as well. I wish I had known this in the beginning, but it still would not have compensated for the silly romance.
September 11, 2011
I was swept away. In the tide of a love discovered after a marriage. In an adventure filled with the thrills of the trail. Swept away in a novel filled with everything I love in really good fiction.
Jody Hedlund is a new name in today’s fiction, but one I firmly believe will not be leaving us any time soon. I certainly hope to never see that day! Hedlund crafts a story that stirred my heart and emotions with the expert wielding of her deft writing hand.
Priscilla and Eli are characters you just long to meet. They sing with depth upon the page. They remain the flawed characters you cheer for to reach their coveted ending, but at the same time never want to their story to end, because you know you must leave them.
The romance sizzled upon the page! Talk about forbidden attraction between this couple. The entire book I seemed to be holding my breath for them to finally reach that moment when they could give up their misguided holdings. And when that moment came…I mustn’t talk too much for fear of giving away the ending. But talk about a release of a lungful of air and a more than one happy sigh.
I wish I never had to close the cover of this book. It’s too good to only read once, this book will have to be savored over and over again.
Jody, you have a wonderful gift!
This review is my honest opinion. Thanks to the publishers through CFBA for my copy to review.
Jody Hedlund is a new name in today’s fiction, but one I firmly believe will not be leaving us any time soon. I certainly hope to never see that day! Hedlund crafts a story that stirred my heart and emotions with the expert wielding of her deft writing hand.
Priscilla and Eli are characters you just long to meet. They sing with depth upon the page. They remain the flawed characters you cheer for to reach their coveted ending, but at the same time never want to their story to end, because you know you must leave them.
The romance sizzled upon the page! Talk about forbidden attraction between this couple. The entire book I seemed to be holding my breath for them to finally reach that moment when they could give up their misguided holdings. And when that moment came…I mustn’t talk too much for fear of giving away the ending. But talk about a release of a lungful of air and a more than one happy sigh.
I wish I never had to close the cover of this book. It’s too good to only read once, this book will have to be savored over and over again.
Jody, you have a wonderful gift!
This review is my honest opinion. Thanks to the publishers through CFBA for my copy to review.
May 26, 2019
When the west of America continent was still unexplored except for certain business people, Eli Ernest had been there and now, he wants to go and build a missionary there. To do so, the missionary committees require him to be married. Ms Priscilla White on the other hand has a dream to do missionary works in India. She is also fall short to the committees' requirement. They both come up with a marriage of convenience to fulfill both of their dreams.
Marriage of convenient is one of my fav romance trope and paired with based on true stories which also one of the things that I like in my fiction reading, I have high hopes for it. And upon finishing it, I'm glad I read it. Eli is one determine man and Priscilla is a strong woman. It was there but never mention until the very end.
May 27, 2021
Priscilla White's desire to be a missionary not only leads her to make a marriage of convenience to a doctor, Eli Ernest, in ministry to native American's in Oregon, but also to make a trek from New York across the rugged United States to Oregon as the first white woman to successfully achieve this. Hedlund's story is full of hardships, heartaches, and girtty determination as Priscilla and Eli, along with another couple, make their way across the US in 1836 to the Oregon territory.
This story has well crafted main and secondary characters that bring this long, arduous trek to life in the rugged uncharted era of pioneer days. The relationship between Eli and Priscilla was interesting to watch as they progressed from barely tolerating one another to friendship and beyond. They both grew and moved past previous hurts. It was only when they both turned things over to God and grew in their faith did they finally achieve happiness.
This story has well crafted main and secondary characters that bring this long, arduous trek to life in the rugged uncharted era of pioneer days. The relationship between Eli and Priscilla was interesting to watch as they progressed from barely tolerating one another to friendship and beyond. They both grew and moved past previous hurts. It was only when they both turned things over to God and grew in their faith did they finally achieve happiness.
September 14, 2011
I love that this book is loosely about real people. Most of the time with a marriage of convenience story, its a silly and unbelievable progression of how the marriage comes about. But Hedlund does a good job easing it in.
The pacing was right on, and although its not completely without a few clichés its more original than not. I like Eli. He has the best lines. And the heart of this story is definitely there.
It does get a bit annoying 3 quarters of the way thru. The traveling story line gets worn down. But the pacing is still pretty good. Its the kind of story that, if you put it down for a bit, you'll want to pick it back up again soon after.
I would give this 3 1/2 stars if I could, but I don't think its a full 4 stars because the ending had some unbelievable parts and cheesy bits.
Over all though, its a good way to spend some escape time.
The pacing was right on, and although its not completely without a few clichés its more original than not. I like Eli. He has the best lines. And the heart of this story is definitely there.
It does get a bit annoying 3 quarters of the way thru. The traveling story line gets worn down. But the pacing is still pretty good. Its the kind of story that, if you put it down for a bit, you'll want to pick it back up again soon after.
I would give this 3 1/2 stars if I could, but I don't think its a full 4 stars because the ending had some unbelievable parts and cheesy bits.
Over all though, its a good way to spend some escape time.
August 23, 2016
A heartwarming story about frontier courage based upon the first woman to cross over the Continental Divide to become a missionary to the Nez Perce during the 1830's. Often dramatic but then there was a lot of drama in traversing virgin lands in the newly charted American west. The romantic portion of the story was very entertaining and sweet, a worthwhile read.
April 25, 2020
TITLE gets 0 stars -- such a lame title!!!
This book is based on real people and diary entries of one of the first two European-descent women to travel overland to the Oregon Territory in the 1830s, but of course, much of it is fictional and it has been turned into a romance novel. The women were missionaries--one married to a clergyman the other two an MD--and this is very much a Christian romance, so even though it is fairly accurate historically speaking, it is not going to be every romance reader's cup of tea. However, if you like that sort of stuff this might be up your alley. (yes, using two different figures, but after all I did just read a romance novel for a reading game, because purely romance novels are not among my favourite genres by a long shot, BUT this was a "marriage of convenience" romance, which upped it a bit for me, and it wasn't all pretty and gentle and that sort of thing--there are people here with dark pasts--but it isn't what I'd call a gritty Christian novel, either, even though some ugly stuff comes in.
This book is based on real people and diary entries of one of the first two European-descent women to travel overland to the Oregon Territory in the 1830s, but of course, much of it is fictional and it has been turned into a romance novel. The women were missionaries--one married to a clergyman the other two an MD--and this is very much a Christian romance, so even though it is fairly accurate historically speaking, it is not going to be every romance reader's cup of tea. However, if you like that sort of stuff this might be up your alley. (yes, using two different figures, but after all I did just read a romance novel for a reading game, because purely romance novels are not among my favourite genres by a long shot, BUT this was a "marriage of convenience" romance, which upped it a bit for me, and it wasn't all pretty and gentle and that sort of thing--there are people here with dark pasts--but it isn't what I'd call a gritty Christian novel, either, even though some ugly stuff comes in.
December 27, 2011
Though the beginning started out slowly, the tension gradually builds to an adventure-and-action-packed plot in The Doctor's Lady. I read this book in less than twenty-four hours, drawn in by the development of the characters and details of what the trip West was like for the first female to cross the Continental Divide.
I enjoyed how Priscilla and Eli interacted with one another. They learned to trust one another achingly slowly, which at times made me want to shout, "Just tell her what you're thinking!" But, of course, there is little reality in fiction if characters always agree with each other or give everything away. I really liked that Priscilla and Eli became friends before they ever fell in love--and it was a rocky road to that end!
Most fascinating was the spiritual growth that Priscilla and Eli experienced. The trip to Oregon Country taxed them both to their limits and there were a lot of scenes in which danger played a major role and my heart pumped fast! I was sorry to see the story end.
What I Didn't Like As Much
The slow beginning and the necessity of packing a months long journey West into a book caused me to get a "choppy" feeling every once in a while. I would have liked to see some of the scenes ended a little later rather than turning a page and discovering two days (or weeks!) had gone by.
Why I Recommend This Book
All in all, The Doctor's Lady was a very interesting book with a storyline like none I have ever seen before. The premise was entirely original and the plot fascinating at every twist and turn. I intend to check out Jody Hedlund's other book, The Preacher's Bride.
April 13, 2015
Emilee you were right; this is an exceptional book. Priscilla and Mabel and most certainly the tremendous Eli kept me reading long into the evening. There was never a dull or slow moment in this book. I embarked on a journey with these characters and I'm fortunate to have learned so much about love, faith and fortitude.
October 17, 2011
Jody Hedlund in a fairly new author but I must say she has got to be one of my favorite new authors I’ve been introduced to this year!! Her books are amazing and The Doctor’s Lady is no exception!! In fact, The Doctor’s Lady has just made my favorite Christian Historical book of 2011!!
Priscilla is a young lady who feels God is calling her to the mission field but is heart broken when the Board of Missions refuses to send her on a mission unless she is married. In steps Eli, Eli is young doctor who knows God is calling him to heal the physical and spiritual needs of the savages out in the West. Again, Eli is told her also must find a spouse before he can set up a Mission in the Oregon Country. After much convincing and back-and-forth Eli and Priscilla who’ve known each other for about a week decide to agree to a marriage of convenience only and decide to venture to the West as missionaries.
I fell completely and utterly in love with the characters in The Doctor’s Lady. Priscilla and Eli are characters that just tug on your soul and the depths that we are introduced to them are riveting! They aren’t perfect characters by any means but they are strong in their faith and strong in strength. If Priscilla makes it all the way to Oregon she’ll become the first women to ever survive the hard journey there.
Jody Hedlund has this magic about her writing that has you holding your breath with anticipation through the romantic scenes and feeling your heart breaking through the trials!! And of man is that romance exciting!! This entire book is about how Eli and Priscilla are only in a marriage of name only yet as they grow closer together there is no denying the strong connection and sparks that are flying!! I was rooting for things to work out for Eli and Priscilla all the way through the story and I was holding my breath hoping that they would survive this hard journey to their goal.
By the end of this book you feel things coming together and I felt like I could just explode in emotions and tears of joy and I was sad that it had to come to an end. This is one of those books that although you are satisfied with the ending, you are disappointed that you are done reading about the characters that moved your life!
Jody is a very talented author and I feel there is only more amazing things that are coming from her! I feel she is right up there with some of my other favorite Christian authors like Deeanne Gist!! Her characters are deep and evocative, her romance is exciting and emotional and the spiritual matter is subtle yet meaningful and I will enjoy reading this book again and again!
If you haven’t had a chance to read any books by Jody Hedlund yet, I say now is the time and The Doctor’s Lady is the book!!
Content: There is a lot of mentions of relationships between married couples and an instance or two of violence that wouldn't be suitable for teens. I feel this is for a mature audience only.
Thank you to Bethany House for providing me a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own; I would not recommend this book if I didn't LOVE it!!
Priscilla is a young lady who feels God is calling her to the mission field but is heart broken when the Board of Missions refuses to send her on a mission unless she is married. In steps Eli, Eli is young doctor who knows God is calling him to heal the physical and spiritual needs of the savages out in the West. Again, Eli is told her also must find a spouse before he can set up a Mission in the Oregon Country. After much convincing and back-and-forth Eli and Priscilla who’ve known each other for about a week decide to agree to a marriage of convenience only and decide to venture to the West as missionaries.
I fell completely and utterly in love with the characters in The Doctor’s Lady. Priscilla and Eli are characters that just tug on your soul and the depths that we are introduced to them are riveting! They aren’t perfect characters by any means but they are strong in their faith and strong in strength. If Priscilla makes it all the way to Oregon she’ll become the first women to ever survive the hard journey there.
Jody Hedlund has this magic about her writing that has you holding your breath with anticipation through the romantic scenes and feeling your heart breaking through the trials!! And of man is that romance exciting!! This entire book is about how Eli and Priscilla are only in a marriage of name only yet as they grow closer together there is no denying the strong connection and sparks that are flying!! I was rooting for things to work out for Eli and Priscilla all the way through the story and I was holding my breath hoping that they would survive this hard journey to their goal.
By the end of this book you feel things coming together and I felt like I could just explode in emotions and tears of joy and I was sad that it had to come to an end. This is one of those books that although you are satisfied with the ending, you are disappointed that you are done reading about the characters that moved your life!
Jody is a very talented author and I feel there is only more amazing things that are coming from her! I feel she is right up there with some of my other favorite Christian authors like Deeanne Gist!! Her characters are deep and evocative, her romance is exciting and emotional and the spiritual matter is subtle yet meaningful and I will enjoy reading this book again and again!
If you haven’t had a chance to read any books by Jody Hedlund yet, I say now is the time and The Doctor’s Lady is the book!!
Content: There is a lot of mentions of relationships between married couples and an instance or two of violence that wouldn't be suitable for teens. I feel this is for a mature audience only.
Thank you to Bethany House for providing me a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own; I would not recommend this book if I didn't LOVE it!!
August 25, 2011
From the stunning cover and the engaging opening, all the way through to the emotional ending, I adored The Doctor's Lady.
Eli Ernest, will stop at nothing to return to Oregon and start a mission for the Nez Perce Indians, including getting married and doing the unthinkable--journeying out west with a woman. Priscilla White burns with fervor to teach the gospel in India and, for personal reasons, leave the nest of her hometown, but unless she's married, she can't do mission work. An unlikely marriage is arranged between Eli and Priscilla, and together with another missionary couple, they soon trek across the country, facing impossible odds and their personal demons.
Ms. Hedlund combined two of my favorite literary themes--a setting in the American West and a marriage of convenience. I was cheerfully surprised at what an adventure this book turned out to be. The pace, tension, historical accuracy, and romance felt woven into a fine silk under the hands of an expert. I didn't want to put this one down, and indeed, I only did for twelve hours!
One of my favorite things in this book is the very believable chemistry and internal conflicts pushing and pulling at Priscilla and Eli. I understood and sympathized with both of them. The friendship between Mabel and Priscilla touched me so much, I couldn't help the tears rolling down my cheeks in the final chapters. I feel like I have a better understanding of what it really took to settle in the west, and this book more than satisfied my love of a larger-than-life, protective man matched with a strong, generous woman.
I can't recommend The Doctor's Lady enough! It's one of the best books I've read this year. In fact, I'd put it in my top 3 of 2011, and I read 50-75 books a year. It's THAT good!
Eli Ernest, will stop at nothing to return to Oregon and start a mission for the Nez Perce Indians, including getting married and doing the unthinkable--journeying out west with a woman. Priscilla White burns with fervor to teach the gospel in India and, for personal reasons, leave the nest of her hometown, but unless she's married, she can't do mission work. An unlikely marriage is arranged between Eli and Priscilla, and together with another missionary couple, they soon trek across the country, facing impossible odds and their personal demons.
Ms. Hedlund combined two of my favorite literary themes--a setting in the American West and a marriage of convenience. I was cheerfully surprised at what an adventure this book turned out to be. The pace, tension, historical accuracy, and romance felt woven into a fine silk under the hands of an expert. I didn't want to put this one down, and indeed, I only did for twelve hours!
One of my favorite things in this book is the very believable chemistry and internal conflicts pushing and pulling at Priscilla and Eli. I understood and sympathized with both of them. The friendship between Mabel and Priscilla touched me so much, I couldn't help the tears rolling down my cheeks in the final chapters. I feel like I have a better understanding of what it really took to settle in the west, and this book more than satisfied my love of a larger-than-life, protective man matched with a strong, generous woman.
I can't recommend The Doctor's Lady enough! It's one of the best books I've read this year. In fact, I'd put it in my top 3 of 2011, and I read 50-75 books a year. It's THAT good!
September 20, 2011
The novel begins in 1836 in Angelica, New York, where Priscilla White, an unmarried woman with a wish to be a Christian missionary in India, waits to find out her assignment. Her life takes an unexpected turn, however, when Dr. Eli Ernest, a single man in need of a wife in order to accept the sponsorship of the Mission Board for his own mission into the West, makes her a business proposal. If she will agree to marry him, on paper alone, they will get the approval of the Board, and each will be able to fulfill their calling. When she agrees, they set out on an adventure that takes them from New York, to Pittsburgh, to St. Louis, to Oregon Country where they not only discover much about the new land and people there, but their own hearts.
One of my favorite aspects of THE DOCTOR’S LADY is the historical rendering of the unexplored American wilderness. I was fascinated to learn about modes of transport, early settlements, and the interactions between Native peoples and whites. It is clear that Ms. Hedlund did her research, and she perfectly balances information and narrative.
I also enjoy the style in which the book is written. Ms. Hedlund paints such vivid portraits of her settings and characters that I could see every scene as clearly as if it was on film. She is also a master of tension and plotting. I turned pages long into the night, and finished the book in three days.
Finally, THE DOCTOR’S LADY represents quality romance reading. As a work of Christian historical romance, the faith of the characters in spite of adversity, and the purity of the love story are a breath of fresh air without ever feeling heavy-handed or overly-idealistic. Priscilla and Eli are human, realistically drawn characters and I missed them after I closed the pages of the book.
One of my favorite aspects of THE DOCTOR’S LADY is the historical rendering of the unexplored American wilderness. I was fascinated to learn about modes of transport, early settlements, and the interactions between Native peoples and whites. It is clear that Ms. Hedlund did her research, and she perfectly balances information and narrative.
I also enjoy the style in which the book is written. Ms. Hedlund paints such vivid portraits of her settings and characters that I could see every scene as clearly as if it was on film. She is also a master of tension and plotting. I turned pages long into the night, and finished the book in three days.
Finally, THE DOCTOR’S LADY represents quality romance reading. As a work of Christian historical romance, the faith of the characters in spite of adversity, and the purity of the love story are a breath of fresh air without ever feeling heavy-handed or overly-idealistic. Priscilla and Eli are human, realistically drawn characters and I missed them after I closed the pages of the book.
March 24, 2014
Pros: The author is talented with dialog and small witty sentences. I found the chemistry between the characters realistic (it is a clean romance). The characters were strong and I really enjoyed the first half of the book.
Cons: I felt the second half of the book lost its "momentum." I was seeking to find more of an addicting story line (like in the beginning), but instead the plot was filled with more "dangerous experiences" and I felt the suspense sag.
I am a conservative Christian and as a warning, this author does not shy away from the fact that married couples have "relations." There was once sentence in the beginning that I thought should have been omitted or rephrased (describing the step-father's horrible character) - it almost ruined the book for me, but that was just me. Again, she is a blunt author which might not appeal to all.
Second warning, this book deals with some serious topics in regards to (I am just going to have to say it), rape.
Overall, this book was not a waste of time. The story is based on historical facts and I was addicted - having read it in two days. I will not recommend it to my conservative clean-romance friends - but if someone asks me, I would say its an okay read.
Cons: I felt the second half of the book lost its "momentum." I was seeking to find more of an addicting story line (like in the beginning), but instead the plot was filled with more "dangerous experiences" and I felt the suspense sag.
I am a conservative Christian and as a warning, this author does not shy away from the fact that married couples have "relations." There was once sentence in the beginning that I thought should have been omitted or rephrased (describing the step-father's horrible character) - it almost ruined the book for me, but that was just me. Again, she is a blunt author which might not appeal to all.
Second warning, this book deals with some serious topics in regards to (I am just going to have to say it), rape.
Overall, this book was not a waste of time. The story is based on historical facts and I was addicted - having read it in two days. I will not recommend it to my conservative clean-romance friends - but if someone asks me, I would say its an okay read.
September 17, 2011
There is just something soooo romantic about marrying a complete stranger only to fall in love with him later-
Yeah...I guess when you type it out like that it doesn't sound very appealing. But in Christian fiction, the marriage of convenience story line is one of my favs and The Doctor's Lady rocks this plot device.
In order to pursue careers in missions, Eli and Priscilla need to find spouses. Since neither of them is interested in getting married, they decide to be disinterested together, thus begins a beautiful business relationship.
I love how Hedlund throws Priscilla and Eli together in a cross country caravan with her former flame (cause when your husband's just not that into you, the last person you need witnessing the fact is your ex-honey and his pregnant wife). Alternately awkward and poignant moments ensue making this subplot one of my favorites of the book.
If you're looking for a highly engaging historical romance that's heavy on the romance (my favorite kind), pick up The Doctor's Lady and hang on for the ride.
Yeah...I guess when you type it out like that it doesn't sound very appealing. But in Christian fiction, the marriage of convenience story line is one of my favs and The Doctor's Lady rocks this plot device.
In order to pursue careers in missions, Eli and Priscilla need to find spouses. Since neither of them is interested in getting married, they decide to be disinterested together, thus begins a beautiful business relationship.
I love how Hedlund throws Priscilla and Eli together in a cross country caravan with her former flame (cause when your husband's just not that into you, the last person you need witnessing the fact is your ex-honey and his pregnant wife). Alternately awkward and poignant moments ensue making this subplot one of my favorites of the book.
If you're looking for a highly engaging historical romance that's heavy on the romance (my favorite kind), pick up The Doctor's Lady and hang on for the ride.
May 28, 2018
.
The first book in this series was intriguing for its time period.
So I was really looking forward to another inspirational experience. That was squelched when I had to struggle to get through each extremely descriptive scenic scene, chapter after chapter, waiting for any sign of character building or bonding between these people (with the exception of the two women) struggling for so many months through the unknown.
The writer seemed to concentrate too much of the actual facts from a diary and less time focusing on the emotional substance. I didn't really want a history lesson and I felt like this is what the majority of the story was.
The conclusion was rushed and left readers standing on the edge of a precipice, wondering if they missed something.
It was clean, stands on its own, and offers an assumable H.E.A.
The first book in this series was intriguing for its time period.
So I was really looking forward to another inspirational experience. That was squelched when I had to struggle to get through each extremely descriptive scenic scene, chapter after chapter, waiting for any sign of character building or bonding between these people (with the exception of the two women) struggling for so many months through the unknown.
The writer seemed to concentrate too much of the actual facts from a diary and less time focusing on the emotional substance. I didn't really want a history lesson and I felt like this is what the majority of the story was.
The conclusion was rushed and left readers standing on the edge of a precipice, wondering if they missed something.
It was clean, stands on its own, and offers an assumable H.E.A.
March 11, 2022
There were moments when I wanted to give Eli a good smack alongside the head. Wake up, man. You love that girl! But bless his heart, his realization and confession was worth the wait.
Both Eli and Priscilla had lessons to learn as they set out across the vast country in 1836. I enjoyed the pacing of the novel. It covered a great amount of time and included the difficulties inherent to the journey, but the story never dragged.
Robin’s Ratings
5🌟 = Out of this world. Amazing. Unforgettable. A personal favorite.
4🌟 = Excellent read. Couldn’t put it down. Will recommend to others.
3🌟 = Liked it. Glad I read it. Engaging/entertaining.
2🌟 = The book was okay, but I’ve enjoyed other books so much more.
1🌟 = For whatever reason, I didn’t like it and can’t recommend it.
Both Eli and Priscilla had lessons to learn as they set out across the vast country in 1836. I enjoyed the pacing of the novel. It covered a great amount of time and included the difficulties inherent to the journey, but the story never dragged.
Robin’s Ratings
5🌟 = Out of this world. Amazing. Unforgettable. A personal favorite.
4🌟 = Excellent read. Couldn’t put it down. Will recommend to others.
3🌟 = Liked it. Glad I read it. Engaging/entertaining.
2🌟 = The book was okay, but I’ve enjoyed other books so much more.
1🌟 = For whatever reason, I didn’t like it and can’t recommend it.
August 21, 2013
This was a great escape for a stressful weekend. Had fun with these characters who were perfect for each other but couldn't see it. I love arranged marriage story's and this one didn't disappoint. This author does a great job of mixing the preaching in with the story and it doesn't feel heavy. Her books are adult Christian books that I have enjoyed reading.
March 31, 2016
Grabbed this today at the library. There wasn't quite enough of it! It was interesting how she blended in facts with the journey of her fictional characters. I really enjoyed Priscilla and Eli, as well as Mabel. Hedlund is a good writer, and I definitely plan on reading more of hers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 426 reviews