Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Why Marx Was Right” as Want to Read:
Why Marx Was Right
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Why Marx Was Right

3.90  ·  Rating details ·  2,347 ratings  ·  212 reviews
In this combative, controversial book, Terry Eagleton takes issue with the prejudice that Marxism is dead and done with. Taking ten of the most common objections to Marxism—that it leads to political tyranny, that it reduces everything to the economic, that it is a form of historical determinism, and so on—he demonstrates in each case what a woeful travesty of Marx's own t ...more
Hardcover, 258 pages
Published April 12th 2011 by Yale University Press
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
3.90  · 
Rating details
 ·  2,347 ratings  ·  212 reviews


More filters
 | 
Sort order
Martyn
May 14, 2011 rated it it was amazing
Recommends it for: Marxists, Lefties, Anyone who cares
This is a fabulous book. It’s not an apology for Marxism but rather a reinvigoration of the original philosophy of the man, a philosophy which has been unfairly maligned over the last century due mainly to the twin state-capitalist monstrosities built in its name by Stalin and Mao. There is nothing in Marx’s writing that leads one to think of state terror and closed societies, quite the contrary.

In this book, Eagleton takes a different, commonly held criticism about Marxism for each chapter head
...more
Randal Samstag
Dec 11, 2011 rated it really liked it
Shelves: economics, philosophy
Ever need a handy compendium to use when you were in discussions with tiresome right-wingers about how Marx and Marxism was a “Fatal Conceit” or “The Road to Serfdom”? (The quoted references are, of course, to anti-socialist tracts by F. A. Hayek.) Well, if you live in the United States, there would be plenty of individuals who would so debate you. But then again, probably not so many of you would want to. But, for those who would, Terry Eagleton has provided such a compendium. His new book, Why ...more
David M
Thing is, Eagleton tries to have it both ways when he says that the great thing about Marxism, more than any other theoretical system, has been its practical impact on the world and its influence on historical movements, but then goes on to completely disavow the most obvious, prominent case of this; Eagleton claims that what happened in Russia last century actually had nothing to do with Marxism, Stalin wasn't really a Marxist, etc.

In my view, Zizek displays superior intellectual honesty in his
...more
Helen Razer
Jan 28, 2017 rated it it was amazing
I have no notion why the publisher's sought to sell this perfectly reasonable book as "controversial". It is in no way shocking. It is a measured account of a very good thinker. It does contain some of Eagleton's (chiefly) decent jokes, which I always enjoyed as a student when reading his famous, and useful, companion to literary criticism. Otherwise, nothing outrageous to see here but a great synopsis for the Marxist beginner.
This is a marvellous introduction to Marxist thought. I imagine it w
...more
Carmen
Nov 12, 2011 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Entertaining. Never imagined I'd write that about a text on Marxism, but Eagleton writes with an urbane erudition not to be missed. Not only does he effectively dismantle many popular misconceptions about Marxism, he does so with dry but ultimately sympathetic wit. No angry revolutionary rhetoric but a great deal of wisdom and savvy that convinces the reader of several very important truths. The phrase "socialism or barbarism," is shown to be, despite the mind blowing technological advances capi ...more
Tim Pendry

This is an Apologia for the unwitting founder of the latest but possibly not the last of the great ‘herd’ religions.

The book itself is not a complete failure. If you are studying Marxism, it would be a good text that summarises the best case for it much as one might go to Tertullian or Augustine to get the best case for Early Christianity.

Similarly, no babies should be thrown out with the bathwater of Communist history. Marx can be seen as analyst and as historical fantasist. As analyst, he off
...more
Mizuki
Jan 05, 2015 rated it liked it
3.5 stars. The author shows his knowledge on Marxism and he answers a number of frequently asked questions concerning Marxism in the 21st century societies, he gives out understandable, reasonable explanation as much as he can. However, despite the author's reader-friendly and humorous tone, Marxism is complicated, it's still difficult to understand (you have to have basic knowledge about the topics to understand this book) and sometime the author sounds a bit too smug and sure of himself (I'm n ...more
Ellie
Aug 20, 2011 rated it really liked it
Why Marx Was Right by Terry Eagleton seems to me to be a good candidate for required reading for all high school students-as well as people my age looking for a good introduction to Marx. It doesn't hurt to be a little left of center but it's not a prereq. Well-written, well-reasoned, the book is a welcome introduction to an important figure by an excellent writer. Eagleton is not rabid on his subject and is able to see flaws in his subject. And while this book won't tell someone all they need t ...more
Donald Linnemeyer
Jul 02, 2011 rated it really liked it
Shelves: economics
The title grabbed me, and it was well-worth the read. Great writing, and surprisingly, not at all dogmatic or shrill. You didn't get an impassioned, furious defense of Marxism against our capitalist overlords. Instead, Eagleton simply talks you through how Marx himself is grossly misunderstood and misconstrued in most popular criticisms. And he doesn't place Marx above reproach; Eagleton is perfectly willing to disagree with him.

Interesting, readable, and balanced, at least for a book of this ti
...more
Maja Solar
May 10, 2018 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I really appreciate the ability to write (on difficult issues) clearly and simply + to write a popular but not vulgar book!
Christy
Sep 22, 2011 rated it really liked it
Shelves: read-2012
The most refreshing and legitimately optimistic book I’ve probably ever read. Eagleton deftly rescues Marx from the dustbin to which right-wingers, postmodernists, silly liberals and capitalist triumphalists have consigned him. And he does it in such a chummy, cant-free style, while thoroughly answering one attack after another, that it’s like the lamplight from a cottage window on a foggy night. While this will always be contentious, he makes a strong case for the fallacy of blaming Marx’s thou ...more
Paul Rhodes
Jul 03, 2011 is currently reading it
Nearly finished with it. Eagleton has a wonderfully impish wit. Quite delightful. Yes, I know that as a Catholic I cannot be a Marxist. Specifically, this means that I cannot accept the Marxist attempt to build a heaven on earth, but that does not prevent me from accepting the Marxian critique of capitalism. Chesterton did. Now I know that a person like Jeri would say that Chesterton did not know much about economics. To that I would say that a person like Jeri who thinks Bush der Zweite was a g ...more
Prithvi Shams
Apr 26, 2015 rated it really liked it
This book is structured as a point by point refutation to some of the major criticisms of Karl Marx, such as apparent disappearance of "labor class" in Post-Industrial Technocrat society, supposed animus between Socialists and the State, Marx's views on revolution and violence, Marx's deterministic view of history and social change etc. This is a great read for the uninitiated , and I've personally found the arguments compelling.
Sarah
May 25, 2016 rated it really liked it
A refutation of the various criticisms of Marx's work. This is great for those who want to be able to highlight differences between Marx's theories and the negative ways the leaders of various communist countries act.

And easy read for such a difficult topic, written in an entertaining style.
Asa Wilder
Feb 04, 2017 rated it it was amazing
ummm...not sure what's going on here with the goodreads algorithms, but I very much approve!

description
Christopher
Jan 03, 2014 rated it it was ok
As unfashionable as Marxism is these days, Terry Eagleton believes that the events of our time make a strong case for it. Why Marx Was Right is an argument on two fronts, one being that Karl Marx never advocated for much of what was attributed to him, and the other that what Karl Marx actually proposed is very appropriate for our age.

When I read the book, I was open to giving Marxism a fair hearing, as I wonder if the technological developments and "post-scarcity" world of our time call for a ne
...more
Hunter Tidwell
Aug 06, 2017 rated it really liked it
I have qualms about certain parts of this book - as a staunch opponent of Mao and Stalin, as someone who thinks anyone trying to rehabilitate them is a dipshit and enemy of the working class, I still think Eagleton goes to far in describing them as mass murderers. There are also times where he will accept a critique of Marxism as valid without mounting a defense against it - at the end of the third chapter, he ponders that socialism could have been achieved had history happened differently, as i ...more
Chris
Jan 12, 2016 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: favorites
"I am out to present Marx's ideas not as perfect but as plausible. To demonstrate this, I take in this book ten of the most standard criticisms of Marx, in no particular order of importance, and try to refute them one by one."

I found these counterarguments mostly convincing and undeniably thought-provoking.
"Eh, Chris", you might wonder "wasn't Eagleton preaching to the choir though, sort of, in your case?"
Yes, but that wouldn't stop me from questioning his claims. I also wouldn't stubbornly re
...more
Don
Jun 23, 2011 rated it liked it
Was Marx right? I don't know, but Eagleton makes a good case for him being anything but discredited and irrelevant 20 years after the collapse of the Soviet Union. Eagleton's explication of Marx's voluminous writings reveals a complex and compelling thinker who bears little resemblance to the bloodless "from each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs" caricature we learned about in high school.

I found "Why Marx Was Right" more edifying than enjoyable because it is patently d
...more
Public_enemy
Oct 26, 2011 rated it it was ok
Recommends it for: nobody
Shelves: philosophy
Another flabby book with shallow and unconvincing arguments that attempts to show communism in better light. The only communism we know is the one which was represented in the history; there is no some kind of "misunderstood, not-yet-happened communism". Even if it could have happen differently, the true definition of communism is that it is the ideology of weaklings (Weaklings of the world, unite!)(Revenge of the nerds!). I will always be against that. The only reason why I gave 2 stars for thi ...more
Peter Landau
Jul 19, 2015 rated it really liked it
WHY MARX WAS RIGHT by Terry Eagleton reminded me of reading Albert Camus’ famous anti-death-penalty essay, “Reflections on the Guillotine,” in that both take their opponents’ best arguments and systematically dismantle them. It’s an uncompromising defense of Marx’s theories and an insightful look at how he as been so wrongfully maligned over the past century. It’s also a relevant read offering a way out of the seemingly dead-end, destructive state of capitalism that we find ourselves in today, a ...more
Caterina
Oct 11, 2015 rated it really liked it
Recommends it for: aspiring Marxists and working class heroes
An easy and entertaining read, even for those not familiar with Karl Marx's work. This is actually a Marxist's view on Marxism, so expect it to be a bit biased. If you are looking for a simple and well-written approach, do read this, especially, if Gramsci and Adorno are not your average fun read!
Joel
Oct 22, 2018 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
An excellent primer for reconsidering Marx in light of the 21st century.

It is extremely unfortunate that citizens of the global west hear the name Karl Marx and think only of the horrors committed by Stalin, et al.

This is akin to judging Christianity only based on the crusades, or on hate groups like Westboro Baptist.
Or perhaps using 9/11 as the only means for understanding Islam.

I.E. focusing on horrific historical distortions of concepts, rather than considering faithful engagements.

To qu
...more
Adam
Jul 09, 2018 rated it it was ok
Shelves: abandoned
Full of philosophical waffling and limp similes, doesn't address the central economic or empirical issues at all.
Tom
Dec 24, 2012 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: philosophy-books
This book was much better the second time around. In the first reading of this, Eagleton felt more like a fanatic and court fool than an academic seriously defending Marxism; although, to be fair, that does sometimes come across. Eagleton errs to the side of Marxism, obviously, and is perhaps a touch too favourable in places. That said, his criticism and simple writing style do a lot to high-light the useful contributions of Marxism and the major distortions by the Conservative free marketeer cr ...more
Keith Akers
Feb 18, 2014 rated it really liked it
The title might lead you to believe that this would be a summary of Marx’s views, which is not quite correct. Instead, it is a polemic against those who have prematurely dismissed Marx — after Stalin, after the fall of the Soviet Union, after the “end of history.” History, it turns out, is not quite over yet.

In turn, Eagleton takes up ten myths about Marxism: (1) that Marxism is finished; (2) that everywhere it has been implemented, it has produced terror, tyranny, and mass murder; (3) that it
...more
Jeremy
Aug 07, 2017 rated it liked it
So I read this at the request of a journal editor, and would not have otherwise. It's far too adulatory towards Marx, overall, but does a good job of defending Marx against some of the cheap shots to which he has been subjected. One regrettable tactic the author resorts to over and over--Marx is only responsible for good things that folks who claim to be for him have done, not for any of the bad things. So Marx gets credit for all the work that socialists and communists have done on behalf of an ...more
Joel
Mar 14, 2012 rated it liked it
Didn't the twentieth century show Marxism to be a deeply flawed dream? Eagleton doesn't think so and expends a good deal of rhetoric and wit to demonstrate that many popular perceptions of Marxism are just plain wrong. Along the way he makes many claims that will surprise the casual student of political theory such as that Marx was a champion of individual rights, hated overbearing states and loved his Aristotle. Ultimately though the format of the book betrays Eagleton. Since each chapter attem ...more
J.W. Horton
Feb 09, 2014 rated it really liked it
If you know someone who is resistant to Marxism, who has at hand all the well-worn and complacent arguments against it, give this person Eagleton's book. WHY MARX WAS RIGHT is well argued and clearly written. (In fact, I've been noticing about Eagleton that he has a writing style rather similar to that of C.S. Lewis.) This book is very illuminating both for those on the Left, but especially for those who are not.

Eagleton takes on in successive chapters each of the following arguments against Ma
...more
Will
Mar 08, 2015 rated it really liked it
Eagleton has compiled a wonderful guide on how to argue against the sweeping generalizations of anti-Marxists. It's important to discuss with those who completely dismiss the ideas of socialism and equality as too idealistic or too broad some of Marx's prescient and valuable ideas. Eagleton's book rejects the dominant notion that everything Marx wrote is no longer applicable and provides an invaluable resource to those who love to debate politics. Social classes still exist (though they are far ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

Readers also enjoyed

  • Estado y revolución
  • German Ideology
  • How to Change the World: Marx and Marxism 1840-2011
  • Reading Capital
  • A Companion to Marx's Capital
  • Marx's Capital
  • Socialism: Past and Future
  • The Revolutionary Ideas of Karl Marx
  • Democracy Against Capitalism: Renewing Historical Materialism
  • Zombie Capitalism: Global Crisis and the Relevance of Marx
  • History and Class Consciousness: Studies in Marxist Dialectics
  • Labor and Monopoly Capital: The Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century
  • One Dimensional Woman
  • An Introduction to the Three Volumes of Karl Marx's Capital
  • Russian Thinkers
  • The Idea of Communism
  • Did Someone Say Totalitarianism?: 5 Interventions in the (Mis)Use of a Notion
See similar books…
636 followers
Widely regarded as Britain's most influential living literary critic & theorist, Dr Eagleton currently serves as Distinguished Prof. of English Literature at the Univ. of Lancaster & as Visiting Prof. at the Nat'l Univ. of Ireland, Galway. He was Thomas Warton Prof. of English Literature at the Univ. of Oxford ('92-01) & John Edward Taylor Prof. of English Literature at the Univ. of Ma ...more
“After all, if you do not resist the apparently inevitable, you will never know how inevitable the inevitable was.” 142 likes
“Genuine equality means not treating everyone the same, but attending equally to everyone’s different needs.” 84 likes
More quotes…