Darwin, Co\/lD and Science Fiction from Rutgers

Darwin, Co\/lD and Science Fiction from Rutgers

by Jeffrey Dach MD

I bring your attention to a recent letter published in PNAS by Emanuel Goldman, Dept of Microbiology, Biochemistry and Molecular Genetics, New Jersey Medical School, Rutgers. (5)

The Un\/accinated are a threat to the \/accinated ?

In this letter, the esteemed Dr. Goldman makes a number of false assertions and cleverly deceptive omissions to make the argument that the unvaccinated are a threat to the vaccinated.  According to Dr. Goldman, unvaccinated people are a “breeding ground” for mutant variants and are therefore a threat to the vaccinated. You might have guessed Dr Goldman’s solution to this problem: The government should institute draconian measures to achieve 100% vaccine compliance with vaccine mandates. Of course, there is nothing like a totalitarian government to save us from ourselves. Exactly why Dr Goldman is so enamored with totalitarian enslavement is well known in psychology as the “Stockholm Syndrome”.    One wonders what Dr. Goldman has in store for us next, forced sterilization of the unfit mandated by the State, also called Eugenics ?

Darwinian Evolution Turned Upside Down

Number one, Darwin would turn over in his grave if he could see his beloved teachings turned upside down by Dr Goldman’s erudite piece.  Goldman cites Darwin to support his claims. In reality, Goldman’s argument is the exact opposite of Darwin’s teachings.

Antibiotics Create Super Bugs, Vaccines create Super Viruses

The well known medical example of “Darwinian Evolution” is selection pressure produced by antibiotics creating antibiotic resistant superbugs such as MERSA.  Farmers are familiar with their version of selection pressure when they over use weed killer chemicals on their crops.  The next year, farmers discover they have created resistant super weeds immune to the weed killer chemicals.

Dr. Goldman has turned the tables on this argument. Up is down and down is up. Black is white and white is black.  His argument in the vaccinated is the reverse of Darwin’s teachings, analogous to arguing that normal healthy people not using antibiotics are a threat to antibiotic users because healthy people, not using antibiotics are magically creating the super bug variants.

Likewise for the farmer’s example, Dr. Goldman’s argument turns that one on its head as well.  The next farm over, with pristine acres of corn and soybean fields, not treated with massive doses of weed killers are somehow magically creating the weed killer resistant super weeds, not the next door farm which uses massive doses of weed killers on the crops.

This Argument is Complete Rubbish

Of course, it is clear for all to see that Dr Goldman’s argument is complete rubbish.  This is so far off from real science as to be nonsensical.  In reality, vaccines produce selection pressure on viruses causing evolution of mutant viral strains, similar to the selection pressure induced by antibiotics on bacteria.  This is especially true for RNA viruses such as CO\/lD, influenza, RSV, Dengue etc. which naturally have a very high mutation rate.

Michiel Niesen Study

This is confirmed by Michiel Niesen et al (2021) who did COVID virus whole genome sequencing in vaccinated “breakthrough” infections as well as unvaccinated infections confirming a striking reduction in diversity in the virus variations  in the vaccinated patients.  In other words, in the vaccinated, the vaccine is producing selection pressure creating a narrow range of vaccine resistant variants which then cause breakthrough infections.  While in the un-vaccinated patients, more diversity in variants were found indicating lack of selection pressure.

The Rubbish Gets Worse

Intertwined with all the fake science about how vaccines prevent vaccine resistant variants, rather than create them, Dr Goldman manages to give us a glimmer of truth in his piece, informing us those who have contracted and recovered from Covid are now immune to the virus, “therefore be the equivalent of vaccinated“.

I would add here that Dr. Goldman is neglecting to mention recent studies showing vaccine immunity wanes after six months or so, reducing efficacy against the new Delta strain to 40-60 per cent range.

These revelations prompted the booster shot program already given to millions in Israel. In Australia, Dr Kerry Chant has informed the population to get used to repeated booster shots ad infinitum.  A study by Gazit in Israel quoted in Bloomberg News August 27, 2021, compares immunity in the unvaccinated (Covid recovered) to the vaccine immunity showing superior and more durable immunity in the Covid Recovered compared to the vaccinated.(12)

Here is a quote from the esteemed Dr Goldman’s piece:

“The unvaccinated will either get sick and survive, and therefore be the equivalent of vaccinated, or they will die and therefore be removed as breeding grounds for the virus….Vaccinations offer a much more humane response to prevent spread of this disease. The path forward is in the hands of the unvaccinated, and in the political will of the authorities…in 1665, during the Black Death plague, “to prevent the disease spreading, a victim was locked in their house with their entire family, condemning them all to death” End Quote Dr Goldman (5)

Four Convenient Omissions

The tip off we are dealing with science fiction is the comparison of COVID with the Black Death Plague of 1665, also known as Bubonic plague caused by the bacterium Yersinia pestis, which is treatable in modern times with antibiotics.  In 1665, Bubonic plague carried a high mortality rate (near 100% untreated), in modern times curable with antibiotics.  This is nowhere near the infection mortality rate (IFR) for Covid which is based on age.  Youngest age groups have such a small risk as to be statistically near zero.

Dr. Goldman conveniently omits four important things.

1) Covid mortality rate for people under age 50, the IFR infection fatality rate is  .005 (CDC data) meaning a 99.5% survival rate, not the greater than 90% mortality of the Bubonic Plague (Black Death). Of course, for Children aged 0-19, these young people have an infinitesimally small IFR of 0.00003, (99.997% survival CDC data), which means statistically speaking, they are at no risk from COVID, and develop robust immunity to the virus very promptly, similar to immunity conferred by other childhood  viruses.  No mention of children in Dr Goldman’s piece.

2) The second thing omitted is that we now have modern medicine with its many anti-viral drugs such as Ivermectin, Hydroxychloroquine, Anti-inflammatory drugs, and anti-thrombotic drugs all used for Early Treatment of Covid-19, resulting in a 80-90 per cent reduction in hospitalization and mortality from COVID infection. (13)

We have Vitamin D and Zinc, deficiencies of which are known to be risk factors for severe outcomes from Covid.

This Early Treatment Protocol converts the viral infection into a much lower infection fatality rate of .0005 ( 99.95% survival) for the under 50.  For the Elderly, Early treatment is equally beneficial although this group remains at higher risk because of underlying medical conditions.

3) The third thing omitted from Dr Goldman’s erudite piece is the risk of severe adverse effects from the vaccines, a point made by Dr Bart Classen.(1)

Increased morbidity and mortality of the vaccines exceeds that of the virus especially when considers the availability of “Early Treatment” as promoted by Pierre Kory, Paul Marek and Peter McCullough MDs.  Unless, of course, the authorities use illegally obtained totalitarian powers to ban the use of early treatment drugs such as HCQ and IVM.  To the extent this has been done, these are criminal acts of malfeasance which will be held accountable and brought to scales of justice.

Leaky Vaccines with Reduced Efficacy and Increasing Adverse Effects

The Fourth thing of course is the vaccine is “leaky” meaning the vaccine does not prevent infection and transmission of the virus in the vaccinated.  Israeli data shows even though 80 % of the population has been vaccinated, the highest case rate ever has been achieved. Does this sound like the  vaccine is working?  At this same time, Israeli government data is showing 60 % of Covid Patients hospitalized are fully vaccinated. US CDC data shows thousands of vaccinated people have been hospitalized and about 20% of those have died from COVID.  Vaers Data shows 14,000 deaths reported after the vaccine, 80% of which occurring in the first week after the vaccine.  Of course, the vaccine manufacturers have no liability for any of these injuries, having been granted immunity (no pun intended)  by an act of Congress in 1986.

Perhaps Dr. Goldman should re-read the many studies now available showing fully vaccinated people becoming symptomatic with COVID infection requiring hospitalization and dying in spite of the vaccine.  Viral Loads in vaccinated people with break through infections are equal to or greater than the pre-vaccine era.

If the vaccine had the same or less morbidity and mortality as other common vaccines, and had an efficacy rate of greater than 70%, then I myself would stand in line for the jab. Unfortunately these criteria have not been met.  Draconian vaccine mandates are not the answer to the Covid 19 problem as Dr Goldman suggests.

Calling for a Complete Halt to the Vaccination Program

One wonders if Dr Goldman has ever discussed his ideas with Dr Geert Vanden Bossche, a virologist who has called for a complete halt to the vaccination program, instead, replacing it with widespread use of early treatment with highly effective repurposed anti-viral drugs (Ivermectin, etc.) (9-11)

“Given the huge amount of immune escape that will be provoked by mass vaccination campaigns and flanking containment measures, it is difficult to imagine how human interventions would not cause the COVID 19 pandemic to turn into an incredible disaster for global and individual health…. [There should be an] immediate halt to the mass vaccination program and replacing it by widespread use of antiviral chemoprophylactics [Ivermectin] while dedicating massive public health resources to scaling early multidrug treatments of Covid-19 disease.” end quote Dr. Geert Vanden Bossche DVM PhD

Conclusion: Science fiction exists in many forms. Lately it has been infiltrating our COVID medical literature.  One wonders if this represents a manifestation of the Stockholm Syndrome applied to the COVID Plandemic.

Articles With Related Interest

Peter McCullough MD on Early Treatment Interview

Rochelle Walenksy of CDC Warns About ADE

Vitamin D and Covid 19

Links and References

1) Classen, B. “US COVID-19 Vaccines Proven to Cause More Harm than Good Based on Pivotal Clinical Trial Data Analyzed Using the Proper Scientific Endpoint,“All Cause Severe Morbidity”. Trends Int Med. 2021; 1 (1): 1-6.” Correspondence: J. Bart Classen, MD, Classen Immunotherapies, Inc 3637. Classen US COVID19 Vaccines Proven to Cause More Harm than Good Trends Int Med 2021

2) Revolting against the dystopian COVID vaccine manifesto with data, science, in order to save humanity
There is only one rational conclusion from examining all the data: COVID vaccines are both unsafe and ineffective. If the forces of evil pushing medical tyranny prevail, then a very dark vaccine dystopia probably awaits us. lifesitenews Joel S. Hirschhorn Mon Sep 13, 2021

3) Sebastian Rushworth M.D. A reflection on covid mania 9/23/21

4) September 22, 2021 Why Do Doctors Go Along with COVID Panic Porn and CDC Prescriptions? By Ted Noel, MD

5) Goldman, Emanuel. “How the unvaccinated threaten the vaccinated for COVID-19: A Darwinian perspective.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 118.39 (2021).Goldman How the Unvaccinated Threaten the vaccinated PNASl

6) Yeh, Ting-Yu, and Gregory P. Contreras. “Full vaccination is imperative to suppress SARS-CoV-2 delta variant mutation frequency.” medRxiv (2021).Contreras Vaccination to Suppress Mutant Variants

full pdf
7) Niesen, Michiel, et al. “COVID-19 vaccines dampen genomic diversity of SARS-CoV-2: Unvaccinated patients exhibit more antigenic mutational variance.” medRxiv (2021). Niesen cOVID 19 VACCINES GENOMIC DIVERSITY July 2021

Strikingly, we find the diversity of the SARS-CoV-2 lineages is declining at the country-level with increased rate of mass vaccination (n = 25 countries, mean correlation coefficient = -0.72, S.D. = 0.20)….. Prospective validation of these macroscale evolutionary patterns using clinically annotated SARS-CoV-2 whole genome sequences confirms that vaccine breakthrough patients indeed harbor viruses with significantly lower diversity in known B cell epitopes compared to unvaccinated COVID-19 patients (2.3-fold, 95% C.I. 1.4-3.7).

8) Yahoo FinanceYahoo Finance Natural immunity emerges as potential legal challenge to federal COVID-19 vaccination mandates Alexis Keenan
Alexis Keenan·Reporter September 25 2021,

9)  Vaccine Expert Vanden Bossche Calls For “Immediate Halt” To Vaccinations, Says They Encourage “Escape Mutant” Variants Friday, Aug 13, 2021

“Given the huge amount of immune escape that will be provoked by mass vaccination campaigns and flanking containment measures, it is difficult to imagine how human interventions would not cause the COVID 19 pandemic to turn into an incredible disaster for global and individual health…. [There should be an] immediate halt to the mass vaccination program and replacing it by widespread use of antiviral chemoprophylactics [Ivermectin] while dedicating massive public health resources to scaling early multidrug treatments of Covid-19 disease.” Geert Vanden Bossche DVM PhD

10) C-19 Pandemia: Quo vadis, homo sapiens? Geert Vanden Bossche DVM PhD Blog

11)  The Vaccines: Awesome Ingenuity or A Huge Mistake?
Jun 22, 2021 Dr. Chris Martenson’s Peak Prosperity

12) Gazit, Sivan, et al. “Comparing SARS-CoV-2 natural immunity to vaccine-induced immunity: reinfections versus breakthrough infections.” medRxiv (2021).

13) Procter, Brian, and McCullough “Early Ambulatory Multidrug Therapy Reduces Hospitalization and Death in High-Risk Patients with SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19).” Int J of Innovative Res in Med Sci (IJIRMS) 6.03 (2021). Multifaceted-highly-targeted-sequential-multidrug-treatment-of-early-ambulatory-high-risk-SARS-CoV-2-Infection

Published on September 26th, 2021 by Jeffrey Dach MD

The post Darwin, Co\/lD and Science Fiction from Rutgers appeared first on Jeffrey Dach MD.