To Review or Not to Review ...

I'm happy to say I was able to steal some time to read over the holidays, and I’m adding a number of books to my Goodreads shelf today. I feel obliged to comment on the fact that, for the majority of these books, I am not assigning a rating or writing a review.* I enjoyed reading each and every one of these works (otherwise, I would not have finished them), but I am reticent to rate and review books within roughly the same genre as my own TRANSCENDER (i.e., YA Fantasy). Call me squeamish, but it just seems bad form somehow.

As a relatively new author, I know how incredibly difficult the writing process is and how much effort goes into coaxing a finished manuscript out of the germ of a story idea—and that’s only fraction of the larger process of bringing a book to publication, and actually selling copies. Consequently, I believe every author who has lovingly cultivated a book to completion and successfully delivered it to the marketplace deserves my praise and admiration.

I’m grateful for every honest review of TRANSCENDER; because it helps me better understand what resonates with readers and what falls flat. Reviews have always been an integral part of the world of literature, and I frequently read a few before purchasing a book. So I hope those of you who follow my reviews will forgive me this little idiosyncrasy. I'll continue to rate and review books that fall outside of the YA Fantasy genre.

*Since rules are made to be broken (don’t tell my kids I said that), I have given a five-star rating to Maggie Stiefvater’s The Scorpio Races, and I’ve written a short review. In my opinion, this book stood out from all the rest. I highly recommend it.
 •  2 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on February 06, 2012 13:36
Comments Showing 1-2 of 2 (2 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Christina (Ensconced in Lit) Vicky, this makes me appreciate you even more! I've even wondered this sometimes... how one can honestly critique someone else in the same genre. I'm glad you liked some of my suggestions too!


message 2: by Vicky (new)

Vicky Savage Christina wrote: "Vicky, this makes me appreciate you even more! I've even wondered this sometimes... how one can honestly critique someone else in the same genre. I'm glad you liked some of my suggestions too!"

It's hard figuring out author etiquette for a newbie like me!


back to top