group discussion


59 views

topic: Latest Book > Jaypaw/Jay's Wing (only read this if you've read LONG SHADOWS)





Comments (showing 1-45)    post a comment »
dateUp_arrow    newest »

message 45: by Anna (new)

Nophoto-f-25x33 That's Proboly Why I couldn't be a warrior cat. Imagin going from, Blankkit to Blankpaw, then to Blankpelt, And mabey then Blankstar!

That would get confusing


message 44: by Cinderpelt (new)

2478609 yes it would be hard to remember what they did and what name they had when they did it.


message 43: by Dapplenose (new)

2064638 it is hard to remember firepaw and fireheart. if i use the wrong stage it's not the end of the world...


message 42: by Cinderpelt (new)

2478609 lol! wish i could do that!!


message 41: by Dapplenose (new)

2064638 yeah....but usually i can


message 40: by Cinderpelt (last edited Jul 09, 2009 02:29PM) (new)

2478609 ok.
i probly couldnt remember to do that with each cat!


message 39: by Dapplenose (new)

2064638 yeah, they're still the same cat. but i use the name that they were at the time.


message 38: by Cinderpelt (new)

2478609 oh but their still the same cat- fireheart is his warrior name. firestar is his leader name.


message 37: by Dapplenose (new)

2064638 (i like to refer to the charies by the name that they had at the time) for example, fireheart saved riverclan from starvation, but firestar remade skyclan


message 36: by Dapplenose (new)

2064638 no. just jaypaw


message 35: by Cinderpelt (new)

2478609 i wonder if lionblaze and hollyleaf r part of the ancents to.


message 34: by Dapplenose (new)

2064638 well i have no idea about that but half mon is definately not willowshine. only jaypaw was an ancient


message 33: by Cinderpelt (new)

2478609 Felicity/Rosestar wrote: "You know, I think Half Moon is Willowshine. Because she seems to care about Jayfeather and their descriptions are rather similar."

isnt it only jayfeather who is part of "the ancents" becase of his propocey?


message 32: by Dapplenose (last edited May 17, 2009 07:05PM) (new)

2064638 sorry for complaining so much in it i finally realized that you're not gunna change the group just for me. i have such a thick skull :D
anyways, i'm making it up by bringing goldenwing back!


message 31: by Allie (new)

835716 yeah... ):


736399 Oh I am sorry...it is such a great group


message 29: by Dapplenose (new)

2064638 oh i left that group because it only has one rp and its confusing to me


736399 That's true. In "Warrior's Lovers" we have been using that conflict recently and you can totally see the conflict within.


message 27: by Dapplenose (new)

2064638 Heaven wrote: "i think med cats should be aloud to fall in love as long as the cat she or he is in love with doesn't become his or her mate"

but a crush would distract them fron their duties. it's not like starclan's just trying to be mean!


1327930 Felicity wrote: "I know and then jayfeather would fall in love with her and then...A New Conflict!

Oh and then the next series could be about their kits!"


if they do another series*SIGH*


1327930 i think med cats should be aloud to fall in love as long as the cat she or he is in love with doesn't become his or her mate


message 24: by Dapplenose (new)

2064638 oh yeah!


message 23: by Sella (last edited Apr 26, 2009 11:27PM) (new)

909992 I think leader and medicine cat of two different clans would be awesome!!! If the leader was a she-cat, then that would be breaking THREE warrior codes!! 1) medicine cats can't fall in love, 2) cats from different clans can't fall in love, and 3) she-cat leaders can't have kits!! whoa that would be SOO INTENSE!! XD

O.m.g. If it was between two leaders, I know who it would be!! Leopardstar and Onestar!! I totally see it!! :D

Or, for the medicine cat and leader of different clans thing...Leopardstar and Littlecloud!! or Leopardstar and Barkface...


message 22: by Dapplenose (new)

2064638 me too. maybe deputy and deputy...


message 21: by Allie (new)

835716 yea, but im kinda over meddie cat love


736399 That would be cool!

Oh, I got an idea for an interesting forbidden love! What if two clans were at war and their leader and medicine cat fell in love? That's never happened!


message 19: by Allie (new)

835716 ...that WOULD b cool!


message 18: by Dapplenose (new)

2064638 oh yeah 2 LEADERS that would be so cool! but lepardstar is the only female and thunderclan doesn't share a broder, so if she does...onestar or blackstar. or 2 deputies.


message 17: by Sella (last edited Apr 17, 2009 09:55PM) (new)

909992 I know!! It's getting really annoying.

...but you know what forbidden love would be REALLY cool and original? A forbidden romance between two leaders of two different clans!!

Yeah, something like that already sorta happened- with Bluestar and Oakheart- but with two different leaders, it would be exciting!!!


message 16: by Dapplenose (new)

2064638 too much forbiden romance already.


message 15: by Sella (new)

909992 Yeah. They could fall in love, but I doubt they'd have kits.


message 13: by Jordan (new)

1441909 i don't think that would happen because they are both medicine cats


message 12: by Allie (new)

835716 maaaybbe!


736399 I know and then jayfeather would fall in love with her and then...A New Conflict!

Oh and then the next series could be about their kits!


message 10: by Allie (new)

835716 that would be awesome!!! maybe!!


message 9: by Sella (new)

909992 Oooh...you mean, Half Moon is reborn into Willowshine? OMG that would be SO COOL!!


736399 You know, I think Half Moon is Willowshine. Because she seems to care about Jayfeather and their descriptions are rather similar.


message 7: by Sella (new)

909992 I hope they do!


message 6: by Lennon Boy 482 (new)

677064 That was awesome. They must bring Half Moon up in the next book, don't you think?


message 5: by Sella (new)

909992 lol. that sucks...uhh...0.0


message 4: by Allie (new)

835716 D:
still confused. lol.


message 3: by Sella (new)

909992 I know, time travel always confuses me...but I guess what happened was, Jaypaw's spirit is Jay's Wing, and he was reborn, and so he was the one who led the cats to the mountains. And I guess that meant that Holly and Lion were those cats too...but which ones?? And it doesn't make sense- how did Jay's Wing know all those things about the warriors clans, and how did he know about the mountains, if jaypaw wasn't even born yet??

Yeah, and I really liked Half Moon. It made me sad when Rock said that she never saw Jay's Wing again...:(


message 2: by Allie (new)

835716 Very cool!!!!! But also very confusing. What was the part he said when he got back, 'The Three had returned'? Like Holly and Lion had been there too? but i liked that! I really did! him being Jay's wing, then like going back and being Jaypaw as Jay's wing...that doens't make sense does it? Oh well, time travel and reborn stuff has always confused me. but i love it, cuz he's always been so close to the cats there! I liked Half Moon...I'm sad they didn't make a bigger deal out of her.


message 1: by Sella (new)

909992 What do you think about how Jaypaw used to be one of the cats that used to live at the lake, and how his spirit was "reborn"? I think it's pretty cool...if not a bit confusing. You?


back to top

unread topics | mark unread