Heaven wrote: "This is the coolest book in the entire universe. I finished it in just two days and normally that would be my mom. It revieled a lot of secrets that we have been wondering about forever."

I did too!

yup.

i loved long shadows! i cant belive ashfur wanted to KILL firestar!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Lol, no this is the first time.

okeeyz. i thot i was being really stupid and she was in another book b4...

No. I think she was one of the ancient cats.

pretty much, yea
okay, ya kno how there was a starclan cat, brightspirit? have we met her before? i can't remember

Yeah, they heard a rustle or something. So maybe someone was listening, and then killed Ashfur to save Squirrelflight...but who would do that? Maybe Brambleclaw? *gasp* Or Leafpool? Wait, no. That doesn't make any sense. Both Brambleclaw and Leafpool were there the whole time- but Squirrelflight was missing! It HAS to be her!

ya and i've been wondering what it was

back to earlier, didn't it say something about during the fire them hearing something?...

fine you win but hopefully we will soon find out

EXACTLY. That's why I'm proving you wrong, Heaven, when you said "and it could be one of their brothers and sisters and sometimes it does work that way." You were saying that one of Firestar's siblings could have been the kits' parent, saying that one of the kits' GRANDPARENTS could have been their PARENT!!!!!

it still could be absolutely possible and my grandma wouldn't be my mom because it is impossible your grandma is actually your mom's mom

It would be really disgusting if the kits parent is one of Firestar's siblings. I mean, THINK ABOUT IT!!! It's like you found out that your GRANDMA was actually your MOM!!!

And Heaven, when Hollyleaf said that, she didn't actually know. She was just freaking out, and she was like, "OMG WHAT IF WE'RE NOT CLAN MEMBERS?!?"

well leafpool is squirrelflights kin so it is if you are related

no. kin would be ur offspring. so kin of ur kin would have 2 b ur grandkids. or kits. but wutever, idc

Allie wrote: if they were one of firestar's siblings kits, it wouldn't b kin of your kin"

well if they are his bros or sises than they would be kin of your kin

um. she was just freaking out, wondering if they were or not. and sella's right, if they were one of firestar's siblings kits, it wouldn't b kin of your kin

like toward the end of long shadows and hollyleaf said it

and it could be one of their brothers and sisters and sometimes it does work that way

When did "they" say "We aren't clan members?" And who do you mean about "them"?

It can't be one of Firestar's brothers or sisters. Because then their GRANDPA's SIBLING would have been their father. It doesn't work that way!!

I think that they may be one of Firestars Bros or sisis that we dont know about because they said in the book not in exact words "We aren't clan members"
But they could be Leafpools

Lol, sry. I was a bit excited yesterday, since I just finished the book. XD Anyways...yeah, I agree, I've thought they were Leafpool's ever since the first book of Power of Three. XD

lol sella caaalllmmm down. I agree with pretty much everything u said, and thought the same things about Jayfeather and Ashfur and stuff. But i think it' spretty obvious they're leafpools, just cuz the hints and the way she acts around them. yes, the book was awesome.

OMG I KNOWW!!!!!! IT WAS AMAZING!!! ITS MY FAVORITE OUT OF ALL THE SERIES!! SO MANY PLOT TWISTS, SOO EXCITING!!

...do you mind if I now go off on a rant of all the things I think about it? if you do, too bad. so...

OMG!!!!! I KNEW IT ALL ALONG!!!!! From the very first book of the Power of Three, I KNEW that the three kits weren't Squirrelflight's!! I PREDICTED IT!! AND I WAS RIGHT!!!! OMG!!! Well, I thought that just Jayfeather and possibly Hollyleaf were, I didn't think Lionblaze wasn't Squirrelflight's too. BUT STILL!!! OMG!!! It annoys me that we didn't find out WHO their REAL mother is, since I want to confirm my suspicion of Leafpool and Crowfeather being their real parents!! OMG!!

AND I KNEW THAT ASHFUR WAS THE ONE WHO HELPED HAWKFROST!!! I KNEW THAT HE WAS THE ONE WHO LED FIRESTAR TO THE TRAP AT THE END OF SUNSET!!! I KNEW IT!! AND I WAS RIGHT!!!!!!!!! OMG!!!!!!!!!!! XD Well, I didn't suspect it was because he wanted to hurt Squirrelflight. I thought it was just because he was furious at Brambleclaw for stealing Squirrelflight away, so he got revenge-crazy and did it. BUT STILL!!! OMG!!!

Wow, Ashfur's seriously messed up. He loved Squirrelflight, and then now he's all like "I WANT TO HURT YOU AND TEAR YOU APART FROM INSIDE!!!" Um..okay. No comment. Except for that fact that I hate him. XD

ANYWAYS...

OMG! OMG !OMG !OMG OMG! OMG !OMG OMG!!!!! AND THEN WHEN ASHFUR DIED...WHOA!!! I DID NOT SEE THAT COMING!!! AT ALL!!! And now I think that Squirrelflight MUST have killed him. It all fits. She was missing before the gathering- around the time when he'd been killed. And when she came back, her excuse wasn't very strong. AND- she was covered in water and mud!! AND ASHFUR WAS FOUND IN A STREAM, WET AND COVERED IN MUD!! See the connection?!?! SHE MUST HAVE KILLED HIM!!! SHE MUST HAVE DONE IT SO THAT HE WOULDN'T SPILL HER SECRET AT THE GATHERING!!! Because she and the three apprentices were the only ones that KNEW what Ashfur was going to do, therefore the only ones who had a reason to kill him! But none of the three killed him, because we're IN their Point of View, so we KNOW they didn't do it!!

Squirrelflight HAS to have done it!! She has a motive, and all the evidence points to straight to her. Still...it's hard for me to imagine Squirrelflight killing someone. I mean, it's SQUIRRELFLIGHT, for crying out loud!! SQUIRRELFLIGHT!! We've been inside her head, in her point of view, in the New Prophecy series. We know that she's a kind person. She doesn't go killing people, EVEN if she has a motive to!!

But I had this theory...maybe she killed Ashfur by accident. Maybe she sought him out before the gathering because she wanted to try again to convince him not to tell the secret, and then maybe he got fed up so he attacked her, and then maybe Squirrelflight was trying to defend herself and maybe accidentally got carried away and killed him!! At least, that's what I'd LIKE to believe, if Squirrelflight was the one who killed him. But it could be someone else entirely...I have no idea...*siiigh*

I JUST CANT BELEIVE ALL THESE THINGS HAPPENED!!!! 0.0

This is the coolest book in the entire universe. I finished it in just two days and normally that would be my mom. It revieled a lot of secrets that we have been wondering about forever.