group discussion


348 views

topic: Recommendations, Anyone? > Something Really Depressing





Comments (showing 62-111)    post a comment »

message 111: by Ofmatt (new)

1604742 Yes :) It's the only movie I'm looking forward to being released in theaters anytime soon.


message 110: by Atishay (new)

1595626 The Road.. it's being made into a movie starring Viggo right?
I've added the book to my tbr.


message 109: by Ofmatt (new)

1604742 I don't know if it has already been said, but: The Road by Cormac McCarthy.



The Road


message 108: by Emily (new)

976884 Yes it is a really good story, but very sad.


message 107: by Jeane (new)

1530627 Emily, I didn't think about it as a depressing story. More like a beautiful, well written story.


message 106: by Emily (new)

976884 I just finished A Thousand Splendid Suns talk about a depressing book.


message 105: by Kathy (new)

971945 I haven't read that one, Lisa. I've been meaning to read The Gravedigger's Daughter. I met JCO at the National Book Festival in D.C. four years ago and had my picture taken with her. She was very gracious.


message 104: by Lisa (new)

1384920 Did you read Wonderland? Talk about depressing. That being said, I am a huge JCO fan.


message 103: by Atishay (new)

1595626 It was me with the Bambi Petra. The soundtrack given by Disney to that movie was superb. Have you seen its part 2? It was launched by Walt Disney a couple of years back. Check this out:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0447854/

You must watch this one if you liked the first one.


message 102: by Kathy (new)

971945 I admit that I didn't read every posting, but I scanned them and didn't notice the queen of depressing reads mentioned. Joyce Carol Oates is the go-to girl for major depressing stories. Luckily, she is a kick-a.. author, too. Falls was an excellent novel. I enjoyed the history of Niagra and Love Canal mixed in with the story, along with the depressing saga of the characters. We Were the Mulvaneys (spelling?) was one that it has taken me years to get over.


message 101: by Petra X (new)

1237196 Who said Bambi? That is the ultimate cry-movie but the book, the original, is wonderful too.


message 100: by Paula (new)

432030 Chrystal, that was a good one! I cried at the end and had goosebumps.


message 99: by Chrystal (new)

1564366 I can't believe that Suzanne's Diary for Nicholas by James Patterson hasn't been mentioned. That book had me absolutely sobbing! And Nineteen Minutes by Jodi Picoult had me crying as well. I just finished that one a few days ago.


message 98: by Leila (last edited Nov 18, 2008 04:36AM) (new)

1238671 The Bluest Eyeby Toni Morrison. We read it in class and my goodness - it's one of the most emotional books that I have ever read :( :( :( :( :( When I put this many sad smilies, I mean it. There were countless of times when I just wanted to enter the novel, pick the main character and take it home to give it comfort, support and love and a big hug :( As for the summary, well the description is quite good :)

It also has an amazing stylistic language, with a variable narrator and language style. Some sections may be seen as weird for the first time but when thinking about why it is so and being a bit analytical, you really understand the effectiveness and how it relates to the novel.


message 97: by Atishay (new)

1595626 I agree with you Susanna.


message 95: by sadester (new)

1639674 ya that is true.


message 94: by Susanna (new)

1109068 Disney's Bambi is not only technically great, but the story is not one any animated studio would try to tell nowadays. Too much of a "downer" for today's audience, I imagine. Also, no fart jokes!


message 93: by Atishay (new)

1595626 Disney's Bambi? It was a deeply moving story complemented by an outstanding score by Walt Disney. For me, that 1942 animation beats today's latest animated movies by a mile.


message 92: by sadester (new)

1639674 ya it practically broke my heart!


message 91: by Jeane (new)

1530627 Okay, a movie I never want to watch that one!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


message 90: by sadester (new)

1639674 haha same here. and my dog skip makes me cry cause i love dogs a ton and when that man starts to beat skip with a shovel, boy am i a goner. and then when he doesn't die... wow, and i don't usually cry in movies but right now i think i am being very emotional... oh wow.


message 89: by Fiona (new)

1356469 Disney's The Fox and Hound makes me cry the most out of all of them. I just feel so sad.

I cry in the beginning. I cry when he has to say goodbye to the old woman. I cry when he falls out with his friend. And I cry at the end when their childhood voices are replaying saying they will always be friend and nothing will stop them.

In fact, I well up now thinking about it. Oh dearie. :(


message 88: by sadester (new)

1639674 you know what movies have made me cry that i watched recently? fox and the hound, little women, hancock(i was sad when i thought will smith was going to die!), and my dog skip.


message 87: by Stephanie (new)

1690572 The kite runner




message 86: by Atishay (new)

1595626 Yeah me too. This one looks a more emotional kind though. I'm sure Linda meant 'bawling' when she said 'few tears'. :)


message 85: by Jeane (new)

1530627 Atishay, that sounds good. i liked P.S. I love you a lot.


message 84: by Atishay (new)

1595626 Hmm Linda.. I just read the synopsis of The Wednesday Letters. Looks like something on the lines of P.S I love you, but a different angle and a more intense feel to it. I've added it to my TBR. Thanks!


message 83: by Linda (new)

Nophoto-f-25x33 The Wednesday Lettersis good for a few tears.


message 82: by Jeane (new)

1530627 Laura, it must be!!!! There was a main character in there, the way she thought and lived....it made me adore that book so much!!!!!

I think my favourite books all are favourites because I found something that connects with my thoughts, dreams, hopes, way I live.....


message 81: by Laura (new)

1394928 Maybe thats why we liked Prodigal Summer so much Jeane!


message 80: by Jeane (new)

1530627 I think I liekd the loop so much because of the woman that cared about the wolves, the way she thought and acted...there was something that touched me a lot. Probably my ideas about animals, animals-people...that are sometiems really extreem.
Something in the story connected with some thoughts of me, so believes....


message 79: by Paula (new)

432030 I had heard other people say they didn't care for "The Loop" as much but I'll give it a shot. I'm usually different anyway.


message 78: by Paula (new)

432030 Ohhh Thanks Jeane! Now I'll have to dig through my stacks and move them up!!


message 77: by Paula (new)

432030 The True Story of Hansel and Gretel is a very good book. It is depressing but very good.


message 76: by Atishay (new)

1595626 Ohk Jeane.. now you're really getting me charged up about The Loop. There must be something in it that attracted you so much.


message 75: by Jeane (new)

1530627 Atishay, my friend read tem all too but she didn't like The loop as much as me. Difficult knowing how much I adored it!


message 74: by Atishay (new)

1595626 Paula, you must read the others too. I've read 'The Divide' but it wasn't as sad as 'The Horse Whisperer', and maybe that's why not as good.(that's my opinion). You might wanna try 'The Loop' too. It's pretty good from what I've heard (ask Jeane).
The most anticipated read for me is The Brave which comes out next year.


message 73: by Jeane (new)

1530627 Yahoo Paula!!!!! In a different way there is always some sad part in them yes, for sure emotional! I hope you adore them! And get ready for his new one next year!!!


message 72: by Paula (new)

432030 Atishay, I read "The Horse Whisperer" and have 3 others of his in my stacks but haven't read them yet. Are they all sad like "Horse Whisperer"?


message 71: by Paula (new)

432030 I always break mine up also Tara. I couldn't read one dismal book after another or I'd be in the psych ward! LOL


message 70: by Dorie (new)

1412216 I added The True Story of Hansel and Gretel to my "to find" list as well. It sounds good. Thanks for the recommendation, bnoir.


message 69: by SuzieR (new)

176931 I read The Mayor of Casterbridge in high school and remember quite enjoying it!

I've just finished the most depressing book I've ever read - Vernon God Little by DBC Pierre! It had been sitting on my shelf for over 2 years before I picked it up. I was in despair by the end of it!


message 68: by Fiona (last edited Nov 14, 2008 12:00PM) (new)

1356469 I've added the ones I don't already have that really interest me to my to-buy list. (naughty, naughty... maybe I should get them from the library. Trouble with libraries I always take out more then I can red during that time!)

The true story of Hansel and Gretel sounds really good and I got to read it. I love WW2 themes.

Re-named to-buy as to-get. Sounds more positive.


message 67: by Veronica (new)

1685258 Bridge to Terabithia is a great classic quicky to guarantee tons of tears. I think it's the suspense at the point where you know somethin awful is about to happen but there's nothing you can do to warn the characters. It is young adult, but severely dark considering. I would suggest it's only categorised thus because the main characters are children.

Also The Lonely Passion of Judith Hearne is utterly depressing. It starts off awkward and sad, and ends without hope of improvement or redemption. I would never ordinarily recommend it because it is so sad, but in this case if that's the sort of thing you're after it's a good choice because the writing is absolutely masterful.

Hope you find some goodies Fiona!


message 66: by Jeane (new)

1530627 Laura, the same title caught my eyes!!!!!:-)))))


message 65: by Atishay (new)

1595626 Is Thomas Hardy's biography depressing ?


message 64: by Laura (new)

1394928 OOOOOOOhhhhhhh a Mall of Menstruating!

Remind me to stay away from THAT one.

OOk. Yike.


message 63: by Jed (new)

41292 Depression and Dystopia are my thing.

Random Acts of Senseless Violence - Jack Womack
(most depressing book I ever read)

Caught Stealing, Six Bad Things & A Dangerous Man - Charlie Huston
(three books, one story, no mercy)

Howard Street - Nathan Heard

Sarah - J. T. LeRoy

In The Hat - Dannie Martin

The Menstruating Mall - Carlton Mellick

Born Bad - Andrew Vachss


message 62: by Fiona (new)

1356469 Oooh goody. Oh... mebbe I get it for Mum as christmas pressie. Maybe that's a bit self-serving or whatever though!


« previous 1 3
back to top

unread topics | mark unread

Books mentioned in this topic

My Sister's Keeper (other topics)
The Friday Night Knitting Club (other topics)
River of Heaven: A Novel (other topics)
The Turtle Warrior (other topics)
Never Let Me Go (other topics)
More...

Authors mentioned in this topic

Cormac McCarthy (other topics)