group discussion


72 views

topic: AGATB Movie > Rating





Comments (showing 92-141)    post a comment »

message 141: by Katrina (new)

2141438 (G)Emma wrote: "Hmm, I don't really care if Kartik isn't GORGEOUS. Just average looking, but the boy's gotta be able to ACT.

I'd rather have plain looking Kartik who can act amazingly than a gorgeous Kartik wh..."


I totally agree with that!


message 140: by deleted member (new)

rightt


message 139: by deleted member (new)

ya since the book is a YA book not a junior


message 138: by deleted member (new)

thats so true....they would totally screw up the book if theyy did that!(made it pg)



message 137: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Exactly Grace.


message 136: by Grace (new)

Nophoto-f-25x33 Kelsey wrote: "there is NO WAY it would be pg"

yeah. I would actually be pissed.

B/c i know that they would have simmered down so much on the book.

AGATB isn't sugarcoated.

Its real. thats what i love about it.


message 135: by deleted member (new)

there is NO WAY it would be pg


message 134: by Grace (new)

Nophoto-f-25x33 Kelsey wrote: "it will DEFINETLY be PG-13"

FO SHIZZLE


message 133: by deleted member (new)

it will DEFINETLY be PG-13


message 132: by Grace (new)

Nophoto-f-25x33 it would definitely be pg-13

it could possibly be pg but i doubt it.

if they do the running naked girls they will be wearing underwear ofcourse

lol


message 131: by deleted member (new)

exactly


message 130: by deleted member (new)

it could jsut be like ann is normal pretty and fee and pip could just be gorgeous...


message 129: by deleted member (new)

she is supposed to look like a normal person remember the other people at the school r supposed to b really pretty but she is supposed to be just like a normal everyday person


message 128: by deleted member (new)

well lots of okayly pretty people want to be prettyer it's wat most people do


message 127: by deleted member (new)

i never found her over weight


message 126: by Allie, Mary Elizabeth Dixon (new)

835716 Me too, Bee


message 125: by deleted member (new)

i pictured her chubby but just barley not over weight at all with mousey brown hair and brown eyes


message 124: by deleted member (new)

i dont get how anyone can see her like that Court


message 123: by deleted member (new)

ye true i think of her with like black hair though


message 122: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 I agree Courtney, but with light hair instead of brown hair.


message 121: by deleted member (new)

ya true it could b hard i guess


message 120: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Hmm...I disagree. Well, she'll be easy to find, but how people see her varies probably more than any of the other girls. I know some people see her with blonde hair and blue eyes some who see her with brunette hair and brown eyes. Thin, cubby. It all varies.


message 119: by deleted member (new)

yeah ann is probably going to be an easy pick


message 118: by deleted member (new)

i pretty much think anyone could be ann.... because shes so plain...has to have good acting skills of course...


message 117: by deleted member (new)

i don't know


message 116: by deleted member (new)

i dont really care who is PIP


message 115: by Allie, Mary Elizabeth Dixon (new)

835716 hm... i take that back. She's still not my fee, but i like her better when her hair is down, more gentle looking, even tho i kno fee is supposed to be strong. like these-
http://i.thisislondon.co.uk/i/pix/2007/0...
http://content7.flixster.com/photo/49/01...
however, i think she might be too old, she was born in 1982, so she'd b 27, i think? not that she couldn't do it, but still. RHW was born 1990, so she'd only b 19


message 114: by Allie, Mary Elizabeth Dixon (new)

835716 Romola is okay, but not my fee for sure...no idea y tho. Anna Popplewell would be a good pippa, i still like Rachel HW for Gemma...


message 113: by deleted member (new)

haha yupp. thats my favroite show! and he's my favorite character in that showw


message 112: by deleted member (new)

me neither but i have heard of him on there i only no of him because of Gilmore Girls




message 111: by deleted member (new)

yea...and i dont watch heros


message 110: by deleted member (new)

ya he is a great actor though i haven't seen him in anything recently besides Heros


message 109: by deleted member (new)

haha bee is good. but they could totally make him indian with a bunch of make up☺ haha i would loveee him to playy that partt


message 108: by deleted member (new)

agree with bee or wat ever she calls herself


message 107: by deleted member (new)

who cares milo is amazingly gourgeoussss!!!!!!!!!!!!


message 106: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 The dialogue matters the most. I want the actors to act really well, how they look is not as important.


message 105: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 My biggest wish is that the script is good. That's really my top priority. Then casting.


message 104: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 I hope they don't either. But in the words of John Green, you can't ruin a book with a movie.


message 103: by deleted member (new)

ya true


message 102: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Yeah, I just like how Romola looks. She has that strength about her.


message 101: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Hmm. She's a bit too much like Fee. There's a sort of confidence her eyes. But she's my choice if anyone.


message 100: by deleted member (new)

i don't know i kinda think fee sould maybe be a newwie


message 99: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 I think Anna Popplewell should be Pip if not an unknown. Ann and Gem are toughies, I don't like RHW for Gem. There's just something about her...

I would really like Romola Garai for Fee, if not an unknown.

http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/Guar...




message 98: by deleted member (new)

y Fee???


message 97: by deleted member (new)

i agree with Court


message 96: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Hmm, why is that?


message 95: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 What girls do you think should be unknowns and which not?


message 94: by deleted member (new)

ya definetly


message 93: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Well, if the people in charge of casting do their job, they'll be good actors.


message 92: by deleted member (new)

yeah exept 4 the fans might not b as good of actresses and then it looks REAL fake


« previous 1 3
back to top

unread topics | mark unread

Books mentioned in this topic

Breaking Dawn (other topics)
New Moon (other topics)