group discussion
topic:
News >
PROOF!!!! FIRESTAR DIES!!!!
Comments
(showing 98-147)
post a comment »
It is sad. Even the best of the clan leaders have to go sooner or later. Look at Tallstar. He was one of the most noble of all the Warrior cats.
yep. ive never acctuly READ that book, but i took this harper-colins quiz on it and at the end it told me the stuff i missed. one of the answers to a question was, all the clan leaders got 9 more lives. so if erin hunters gonna kill firestar then it might take a while.
Cinderpelt wrote: "yeah, but in Secrets Of The Clan he (and all the other leaders) got 9 more lives for leading their clans to their new homes after the destruction in their old one. so he has 14, i guess."
??? really?
Heaven wrote: "i think he has four lives left
Firestars quest
saving shadowclan
scourge
sickness
sickness"
I think you're right also.
yeah, but in Secrets Of The Clan he (and all the other leaders) got 9 more lives for leading their clans to their new homes after the destruction in their old one. so he has 14, i guess.
Sella,
You're right on there Sella. Everyone should just relax. When it's time for Firestar to go he will go.
Sella wrote: "OKAY EVERYONE STOP AND LISTEN UP TO ME!!!!!!!
Everyone stop panicking!! Shame on you, Annie, for bringing on a false alarm! I quote:
"Who knows how every one of Firestar's nine lives will end."
..."
Yay!
I didn't see the video yet.This is only someone else's
concept. I made a comment on this web site that I can
accept the fact that Firestar will eventually die but I hope that it will be defending his clan and not through treachery.
concept. I made a comment on this web site that I can
accept the fact that Firestar will eventually die but I hope that it will be defending his clan and not through treachery.
The website I saw it on is:
www.freewebs.com/ashfurfans/ashfurslife....
Click on at the left where it says fanmail and hatemail. Then click on page 4 and see Darttail's
comments.
www.freewebs.com/ashfurfans/ashfurslife....
Click on at the left where it says fanmail and hatemail. Then click on page 4 and see Darttail's
comments.
Grayfur wrote: "I read from another web site that Erin is planning to
have Firestar die. Brace yourselves people."
what website is that? im scared!!!!
Grayfur wrote: "I read from another web site that Erin is planning to
have Firestar die. Brace yourselves people."
She'd have to kill him off, what? Five times?
I love Firestar! He's my favorite character. I have a Firestar Fans group....I'll sit vigil when he dies. Haha, not really. I'll just cry like when Cinderpelt died.
he will die eventually, he's not immortal, but that doesn't mean the erins are going to kill him anytime soon
Whisperleaf/Soul/Annie wrote: "Okay, at the end of the paragraph,
Quote:
"I wish Firestar nothing but peace and a long life. Ha, empty words from me,
who knows how every one of Firestar's nine lives will end."
Unquote:
..."
What! That's not proof! It just says "who knows HOW Firestar's nine lives will end."
That's not saying Erin gonna kill him off. Who knows how any of the cats will die anyway...
It's not like every cat can live forever. He is getting rather old.
Sam wrote: "Let me clear this up! Firestar has 5 lives to lose. I, for one may not be sorry to see him go. Just deal with it and move on! He lost one with BloodClan, another with the rat attack helping SkyClan..."
all the leaders got 6 lives for leading their clans to safty. it says that in secrets of the clan.
Whisperleaf/Soul/Annie wrote: "OMYGOSH OMYGOSH OMYGOSH!!!! FIRESTAR IS GOING TO DIE!!!! THE ERIN HUNTERS ARE GOING TO KILL HIM AND I HAVE PROOF!!!! PROOF!!!!!"
THE ERIN HUNTERS??!! HOW COULD THEY!!!!!!!!!
Dapplenose (Marisa) wrote: "thunderclan is starting to get kinda like a higharchy if that's the right word.leader- firestar
deputy- firestar's son in-law
med cat- his daughter
other med cat- his grandson"
omg wow that is a good point!! it's totally true!!! i never noticed it before. :D and, did you mean ANARCHY?
Allie wrote: "Dapplenose (Marisa) wrote: "totally. firestar is nothing like fireheart. the erins boring-a-fied him so that they could talk about other cats. do you see any of the fireheart that he used to be in ..."
i didn't say he isn't awesome. he just isn't exciting
Dapplenose (Marisa) wrote: "thunderclan is starting to get kinda like a higharchy if that's the right word.
leader- firestar
deputy- firestar's son in-law
med cat- his daughter
other med cat- his grandson"
weird...
Dapplenose (Marisa) wrote: "totally. firestar is nothing like fireheart. the erins boring-a-fied him so that they could talk about other cats. do you see any of the fireheart that he used to be in him? he didn't get wiser, he..."
no! firestar is still awesome! just more boring cuz we don't see his POV anymore!
