group discussion


125 views

topic: Fiction Book Discussions > Memoirs of a Geisha by Arthur Golden


Comments (showing 1-23 of 23) (23 new)    post a comment »
dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Emilee, Smurfy! (new)

934927 I finished this book about a week ago. Great book. I will be watching the movie this weekend.

It is very sad. Covers the life a a young Geisha growing up in Japan before, during and after World War II.

Very captivating and hard to put down. It is interesting to see the life of a geisha. Good research was conducted to complete the novel. Golden did a great job writing the book. Clearly, written by a man but did fairly well writing in first person as a woman.

Great book there was a few disturbing parts in the book but overall I am glad that I read this book.


message 2: by Allison (new)

1637878 Emilee, I agree-its very captivating! I loooove all the rich descriptions of the setting and details, they are fabulous.

I think the ending was disappointing, but the wonderful writing more then made up for it.


message 3: by Fiona (new)

1356469 I loved this book, and it was a surprise for me too as I didn't think I would to begin with. I'd had no previous interest in Japan but my sister sent me the book and so I read it... and adored it!




message 4: by Emilee, Smurfy! (new)

934927 The end could have been better especially since the majority of the book was so amazing.


message 5: by Lorena (last edited Apr 07, 2009 07:01AM) (new)

948934 I agree with you ladies, it was a great read, we read it as part of a book club and there were tons of things to discuss and little gems everyone had highlighted.

I loved the movie too, although it was very different from the book, the relationships are not the same; however the wardrobe, the sets, the gardens everything is just breathtaking.


message 6: by Wendy T (new)

1383279 This is another books that I loved. I read this book many years ago and truly loved it. I never did see the movie.


message 7: by Fiona (new)

1356469 The movie is really good, a lot like the book although obviously not perfect... but when are they? I think it captures the novel perfectly and was like walking into my imagination.


message 8: by Fiona (new)

1356469 And the soundtrack was absolutely beautiful.


message 9: by Wendy T (new)

1383279 Fiona wrote: "The movie is really good, a lot like the book although obviously not perfect... but when are they? I think it captures the novel perfectly and was like walking into my imagination."

Good to know, maybe I'll rent it then. Thanks :)



message 10: by Emilee, Smurfy! (new)

934927 I'll have to get the soundtrack. I loved the movie too!


message 11: by Kathy (new)

1942069 We read this several years ago for bookclub. I thought it was an excellent book. The characters were well developed and the history of geishas were very interesting.


message 12: by Jacqueline (new)

1326635 I loved this book too. I'm always fascinated when an author writes something from the perspective of the opposite gender and a completely different culture. What a feat to achieve, and Arthur Golden did a fantastic job.

As for the movie, I thought it was exceptionally done, especially the soundtrack, which is one of my favorite John Williams movie soundtracks. And many of the actors didn't know English yet still had to pull off the language on camera. Plus it was beautiful. :)


message 13: by Daena (new)

2067191 loved the book and movie! i was totally captivated by the book that i reread it again after 2 weeks. I have also watched the movie many times...


message 14: by Lisa (new)

1866026 Saw the movie first then read the book and was so glad I did. The movie was beautiful and very faithful to the book but there is never enough time in a movie to really explore the motivations of the characters. I loved the way the book ended!


message 15: by Terra (new)

2179317 Ok, I am not going to read any of the posts because I just bought the book yesterday. I can't wait to read it, I heard it's a great book and it's good that I haven't seen the movie. :-)


message 16: by Emilee, Smurfy! (new)

934927 Oh I bought the movie at walmart over the weekend $5.00!


message 17: by Pris (new)

2140523 i watched the movie...maybe i will read the book


message 18: by Petra X (last edited Apr 21, 2009 06:42PM) (new)

1237196 Something interesting about the book: Arthur Golden based the book on his extensive interviews with the leading geisha of her time, Mineko Iwasaki (now a nightclub owner). She made him promise that he would not sexualise the geisha's role. Which he did. So she sued him and lost - Memoirs of a Geisha is, after all, fiction. So she wrote her own book Geisha: A Life 0743444299 which is much better, less sensational but much more detailed.



message 19: by Emilee, Smurfy! (new)

934927 I am going to have to read Geisha: A Life. Sounds like it would be a good read.


message 20: by Terra (new)

2179317 Thanks Petra X! I just added that to my "to-read" shelf!


message 21: by Lea (new)

1412116 Petra X wrote: "Something interesting about the book: Arthur Golden based the book on his extensive interviews with the leading geisha of her time, Mineko Iwasaki (now a nightclub owner). She made him promise th..."

I remember this slightly differently -- that she sued him because she had been assured that her identity would be kept private, and that the suit was settled out of court. I could be wrong. It was several year ago now, right?



message 22: by Thomma (new)

2100448 I read Memoirs of a Geisha almost two years ago, but what an excellent novel! I thought Arthur Golden did a great job writing from a female POV.


message 23: by Ingrid (new)

2349124 I love the book & the movie wasn't bad but the book was way better I think...


back to top


unread topics | mark unread

Books mentioned in this topic

Geisha: A Life (other topics)

Authors mentioned in this topic

Arthur Golden (other topics)