group discussion
topic:
remind you of anything?
Comments
(showing 5-54)
post a comment »
Oh him! my bro and friends are trying to get me to read the Percy Jackson & the Olympians Boxed Set series, but I haven't gotten around to it yet. ...well, I did start The Lightning Thief at one point. xD
ok never heard of any you just said except for fablehaven. :) my favorite author is rick riordan. i will put all of these on my to-read list soon!
I'm sorry about your friends ruining it for you. I don't think it's a waste, but it's not the best book ever.You should totally go back and finish those series. They're some of my favorite.
Some other series I recommend are The Goose Girl books. Often called the Books of Bayern, and any other books by Shannon Hale. Also the Dragon Slippers books, and any other books by Jessica Day George. (Those are my two favorite authors.) Also the Fablehaven series and any other books by Brandon Mull, though his books are more for 4-6 graders, but I still enjoy them. xD
Ooh ok a lot of people have said Twilight is a waste, and all my friends are addicted so i know every little secret of the flippin book. its kinda ruined for me. my mom is going to let me read harry potter 1 and 2, but after that she is not sure about it yet. i have read ember, started eragon and i want to finish, uglies 1 and almost finished 2 but i need to continue the series, and i want to read the inkheart series. i read the first book of leven thumps/
let see, I can see The City of Ember, Uglies, Gathering Blue, The Lottery, The Most Dangerous Game, and The Truman Show. though I can't see Twilight at all.My friend said Graceling was really bad, and from what she told me, I can't relate it at all to The Hunger Games.
Hey, THE Ninja etc. Don't disappointed by not being able to read Twilight. It's good, but way overrated; Tell your mom to let you read Harry Potter Boxset Books 1-7. though I understand, my mom wouldn't let me read book 4 and above for awhile; Read the Eragon, Eldest & Brisingr cycle; The Uglies, The Collector's Set Uglies, Pretties, Specials, Extras series is pretty good; The Inkheart Trilogy Inkheart, Inkspell, and Inkdeath Trilogy is good, but Inkdeath is slow; The Leven Thumps series is really good. xD
Sorry. that probably sounded way lame.
were basically same!!! but i havent read twilight, so take twilight out, and we would be :)
i invited u to be friends, if u want
PERCY JACKSON AND THE OLYMPIANS IS THE ALL TIME BEST SERIES EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Twilight is #2
and
Hunger games is #3
hp and twilight: my mom thinks twilight is innnapropriate, and she thinks HP is not good for my age because she read them . thinks 1 and 2 ok...PERCY JACKSON IS MY FAVORITE FAVORITE BOOK SERIES EVER!!!!!!
and when catching fie comes out, then it will be tied with hunger games ;)
i will finish! im doing a public library run this weekend. stocking up for the summer!!
you need to read percy jackson. ive finished the series and got some books signed! author came to my city. hes my fave author
I'm going to read the Percy Jackson! FINISH all of those series! READ Inkheart! Why arent you allowed past 1 and 2 HP, and why arent you allowed twilight?
only...- Leven Thumps (book 1 only)
- Eragon (part of book 1 )
- harry potter (want to read! but only allowed so far allowed, 1 and 2)
- Inkheart (really want to read those!)
-Uglies (yes! uglies was an amazing book! i almost finished pretties, but got bored. i really want to go back now and finish because i hear a lot of awesome things about it!)
-not allowed twilight
none other...
you should check out:
- Percy Jackson and the Olympians!! series
- The city of ember series
thats all that i can think of now..
but on my books list, people are talking about Pendragon series and supposedly that is really good!
have you read:
Harry Potter Series
The Golden Compass Series
The City of Bones Series
Leven Thumps Series
Fablehaven Series
Twilight Series
Eragon Series
Inkheart Series
Vampire Acadamy Series
Uglies Series
House of Night Series
Blue Bloods Series
Well, I'm getting into smaller books now, so I'll stop ther...
Bianca (Najika-the-Ninja) wrote: "i am sensing that ember is turning out to be a bad series....exept for the first book?"
yep pretty much!!!
People of Sparks and The Diamond of Darkwood is worth it, but skip The Prophet of Yonwood because it is a prequel and is the worst book in the series.
What is "The Lottery" ? jw...
The Hunger Games did sorta remind me of the City of Ember...i never read on. I began People of Sparks but then I stopped cuz i just got out of it. Any one reccommend me continuing?
i feel like i barely contributed to this comment chain...heheh
I definitely agree that Hunger Games is very similar to Graceling, especially since I read them both back to back. My cousin who read Hunger Games was telling me about Battle Royale and how it was basically an older version of Hunger Games in Japan.(whoa, lots of italics!)
I was really reminded of "The Lottery" but then I kind of wound into "The Most Dangerous Game", another short story. But I also thought of The Giver, and The Girl Who Owned a City.
Just the fact that it took place in the future and it's like a "new world" that it reminded me of The City of Ember.
Mieley wrote: "I don't think you get any closer than Graceling, by Kristin Cashore."yay! I just got this from the library the other day! yay!!
The Hunger Games is pretty much like every other sci-fi book.. just way better. Any type of futuristic America book, like City of Ember and even Uglies is very similar, just with different plots. Story and character wise I don't think you get any closer than Graceling, by Kristin Cashore.
There's another short story ... I think it's in one of the lit books I've got at school. "The Survivor"? I'm not sure. Anyway, the setup is similar - manufactured death-matches. However, it looks more at what happens AFTER, to those who make it through and how it affects them, and those around them.Several reviews have mentioned Battle Royale, but I think the similarity is pretty shallow.
It reminded me a little bit of The Giver, but not really. A lot of people compare The Hunger Games to Graceling (which is also very good), and I agree. I find it amusing that even the two main character's names (Katniss and Peeta, Katsa and Po) in the two books begin with the same letters--and in the girls' even the same first three. Also the prequel/sequel/whatever to Graceling will be titled Fire and The Hunger Games sequel might be Catching Fire? Hmmm...
"The Lottery" is a short story by Shirley Jackson. I studied it in High School. Basically, it's this town getting all excited about this lottery, but you don't know what the winner gets. In the end you find out that the "winner" gets stoned to death by the town ... I can't remember exactly why, but I think it's something along the lines of "appeasing the gods" so that they have good crops or something in the coming year.
Is the lottery any good? would anyone recommend this if I liked the hunger games? Someone had said on a blog that it reminded them of the handmaid's tale and this couldn't be more far off. I read that book and it was MUCH more adult like and kind of disturbing actually. The only similarity I saw at all was that it was a distopian novel.
I definately would have said the giver meets lord of the flies. Lord of the Flies really shows that nature mentality of youth being put in a situation like this "out in the wild" so to speak. This was obviously more set up but I found it so different than anything I've ever read. It was a great mashup in a way. I have to admit that the romance twist really caught me as well. I am fully anticipating a full on Peeta/Gale/Katniss love triangle!
Lazygal you nailed it: "I tell them it's The Lottery meets The Truman Show meets Lord of the Flies meets Survivor on steroids..." I thought not only of Shirley Jackson's "The Lottery" immediately but also a short story by Ursula Le Guin "Those Who Walk Away from Omelas," about the suffering of one small child for the good of society and that society accepting it as a part of life. Certainly, there are shades of that here only there is a greater number of children suffering and it is not only for the "greater good" of the 12 Districts (continuing to keep them in line) but for the entertainment of the people in the Capital.
Kim and Monica, that's exactly right, but you've forgotten to add Jackson's The Lottery. When I talk to my peers, I tell them it's The Lottery meets The Truman Show meets Lord of the Flies meets Survivor on steroids; with my students, I'll drop The Lottery and The Truman Show (the former isn't read any more, and the latter is before their time) and add City of Ember, House of the Scorpion and/or The Giver/Gathering Blue.Elissa, I was turned on to Ember by a dyslexic student who told me I *had* to read it; he was very disappointed by Sparks, as was I. The movie's coming out in October and I wonder if the lack of love for the sequels/prequels will affect ticket sales.
unread topics | mark unread
Books mentioned in this topic
Graceling (other topics)The Hunger Games (other topics)
The Girl Who Owned A City (other topics)
Uglies, The Collector's Set (other topics)
Inkdeath (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Brandon Mull (other topics)Jessica Day George (other topics)
Shannon Hale (other topics)
Rick Riordan (other topics)




