group discussion


49 views

topic: The Gemma Doyle Trilogy > *TSFT SPOILERS!!* What was your reaction to the end of the book?





Comments (showing 41-90)    post a comment »

message 90: by Lindsay (new)

1889852 Yeah, my sister told my mom to read it and she did! We kinda had a family reading or something.


message 89: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Oh wow, your mom liked it?


message 88: by Lindsay (new)

1889852 Not I. I never cry in anything. It's kind of annoying sometimes.


message 87: by Lindsay (new)

1889852 My mom read it, and the trashcan was practically filled with tissues because she was crying so much.


message 86: by Lindsay (new)

1889852 It was a little tiny trashcan that you would put in your room or something, and it's not like anything gross was in there.


message 85: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Through it in a trashcan? Whaaa?????


Gemma is my favorite.


message 84: by Lindsay (new)

1889852 I thought it was kinda weird that he turned into a tree... Oh well. After I was done, I threw the book in the trashcan and then I picked it up and gave it a hug. Weird, I know... Kartik was my favorite character, though!!! :(


message 83: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Hmm. I'm just very very emotionally attached to the characters and the writing was so good in that scene.


message 82: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Hmm. lol, You're not weird, you just didn't get overly emotional. I cried even the second time.


message 81: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Oh, why is this in Fun and Games? I'm weird! LOL


message 80: by Evie (new)

1537232 i know! i cried so hard at that part!


message 79: by deleted member (new)

I wish The Sweet Far Thing came with a warning labeled "you will need tissues!" I cried so hard, I couldn't even read anymore, my vision was completely destroyed by my profuse bawling.


message 78: by Jenny, Sahira Fowlsen (new)

1188252 Harmones


message 77: by deleted member (new)

I didn't cry, though I did tear up a bit. I seriously cried a little bit reading the end of 'The Crow' by Allison Croggon! And Sovay, in some parts. I don't cry a lot for books. But I have learnt that as I get older, the more I cry for books!


message 76: by Ashlynn (new)

1613763 ok! thanks : )


message 75: by Allie, Mary Elizabeth Dixon (new)

835716 Yes, probably my favorite book even tho it makes me cry. It's by Elie Wiesel, if that helps


message 74: by Ashlynn (new)

1613763 Any story about the holocaust is sure to make someone cry... I'll have to look that book up though. Is it really good?


message 73: by Allie, Mary Elizabeth Dixon (new)

835716 It's a true story about the Holocaust....


message 72: by Ashlynn (new)

1613763 Thanks for the welcomes and such! but yeah what is this Night?



message 71: by Lisa (new)

898008 Night? Tell more.


message 70: by Allie, Mary Elizabeth Dixon (new)

835716 I cried too. I like never cry in books, that was something like the 3rd time ever. so that means a lot to me... the two other times it turned out the person wasn't actually dead.
Except for Night. I've read it like 20 times and still cry every. single. time.


message 69: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Ashlynn, welcome to the group! Very true...wow, I didn't think of that.


message 68: by Lisa (new)

898008 Wow, Ashlynn, good observation.

Oh gulp, crying at trees. We have to have a tree cut down because it's too close to our house. That will probably make me burst into tears now! (It's a big one too, but fortunately it doesn't whisper my name when the wind blows, just throws branches on my roof)


message 67: by Ashlynn (new)

1613763 Oh i cried for ages... i'd think i was done then the tears would just keep on pouring out of me. I was unaware i could cause myself to cry by looking at a tree...Other than loosing the very lovely Kartik I think Libba ended it brilliantly. I think they will all find their own ways in the world without having to lean on someone. They will be able to support themselves wonderfully. The end illistrated that life just isn't fair, just fairer than death. I liked that.


message 66: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 :) I'm so happy you enjoyed it! Libba is amazing, isn't she?


message 65: by Lisa (last edited Oct 12, 2008 09:50PM) (new)

898008 Well, one day in to it, and I find myself tearing up suddenly and in the silliest places (drive-thru window, etc.). It is really sad. A couple of silly/odd things that came about while I was reading this: I had some disturbing dreams, oddly appropriate songs kept poking into my head, I did think about Lord of the Rings during the battle scene (someone else mentioned that). I also thought about (and was horrified by it) Titanic (Leonardo dies, Kate lives) even though I've never actually watched more than snips of the movie.

Libba Bray is incredible. I did have to snort when Gemma thought about meeting someone and marrying one day ("so, what happened to your last boyfriend," "oh, he died for me.")I'm hoping Gemma can find happiness and sense of purpose without a new man.


message 64: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 :D! Your welcome, I have to spread the love!!


message 63: by KrIsTiE fAyE (new)

707820 I gotta say I love these books. Thanks for the recommendation!!!!! I recommend these to everyone now



message 62: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Ahhh, interesting eh??? She gives a lot of info, I really love and appreciate her for that. (Among other reasons).


message 61: by KrIsTiE fAyE (new)

707820 both.....i mainly am looking at Libba's answers....


message 60: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 The answers or the entries?


message 59: by KrIsTiE fAyE (new)

707820 thanks.....there is soo much there Emma


message 58: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Krisite, try going to Libba's blog and find an entry called TSFT Answers. Libba explains A LOT.


message 57: by KrIsTiE fAyE (new)

707820 I enjoyed the ending. I really didn't cry because I was in pure shock. I just wished there was more information. I wanna know what actually happens.


message 56: by Jenny, Sahira Fowlsen (new)

1188252 Haha! so true, so true


message 55: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 :), Don't worry, just take some time to grieve, and then you'll really be able to understand.


message 54: by Eliza (new)

1325181 i was extremely weirded out. although, after reading what a bunch of you guys said, i like it a lot more now. but it was just so unexpected and dark. and sweet. and happy. and sad. i guess i don't really know what i think!:)


message 53: by deleted member (new)

Me and my friends ditched a lifeguard! It was fun! We were at the pool and he wanted to play our game but we didn't want him to, so when he threw the ball we took it and ran! Yay!


message 52: by Sharayah (new)

1306002 Sweet I live by the ocean too, but dont get to go down there much its all rocky and cold not a nice sandy beach haha.


message 51: by Allie, Mary Elizabeth Dixon (new)

835716 yea, SoCal. I'm doing Jr. Lifeguards, a program where you go to the beach every day for three weeks, and swim and run and learn about lifeguarding and stuff. funness!


message 50: by deleted member (new)

You live near the ocean? Lucky!


message 49: by Allie, Mary Elizabeth Dixon (new)

835716 I'm just v. silly, all my friends are, we'll start cracking up for no reason and have random splashing fights in the ocean


message 48: by Sharayah (new)

1306002 Awesome!


message 47: by deleted member (new)

I am silly with my friends, and when I'm acting I'm not nervous, its just I went to camp and we did a lot of acting EXCERSISES where we had to be silly, and I just really didn't like doing that. If I play a silly character I will LOVE it though! The 2 plays I wrote (I finished the second one) are comedies, so yeah.


message 46: by Allie, Mary Elizabeth Dixon (new)

835716 me and my friends are ALWAYS silly, lol.


message 45: by Sharayah (new)

1306002 Haha, I have been training since I was 2 I doubt a change in the plans would be acceptable. I LOVE singing just have super bad stage freight lol. Perfect huh :) My mom says I can be whatever I want to be but I would hate to put so many years and so much money to waste. I plan to have other jobs but singing will be a big one :) If I can pull myself together that is.


message 44: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 Haha, ooorrr, you could pick something more practical.


message 43: by Sharayah (new)

1306002 Same. I wish I felt comfortable with it though. I hate being in front of people in general but my future is based on me singing and so I need to learn how to deal with it... haha


message 42: by (G)Emma , Carolina Doyle (new)

611251 I hate being silly in front of people.


message 41: by deleted member (new)

I don't do silly unless I want to. If I don't want to, I won't. Its just not possible to get me to do something like that. Most of the times I am silly with my friends, but in front of people I don't know I am barely ever silly unless I'm making jokes, which I tend to make a lot of."


« previous 1
back to top

unread topics | mark unread