group discussion


134 views

topic: The Gemma Doyle Trilogy > Fee and Pip!?!?! (TSFT SPOILER ALERT!!)





Comments (showing 257-306)    post a comment »

message 306: by Peanut (new)

2769975 Taylor S wrote: "So, what do you think about Pip and Fee? It totally shocked me. I mean, I knew that they were really close, but that close? Whoa! "

I was really shocked i just thought that got to be really close friends.


message 305: by ChLoE (new)

2871503 I love Twilight! It has a very very large amount of issues in the sick-ness department it needs to sort out, but the books were still addictive. Haha,


message 304: by (G)Emma , Allie's a barbie doll!! (new)

611251 GR is doing freaky shtuff, I hope this pulls back the general folder...


message 303: by Minnie (new)

1297177 haha i used to be obsessed with Twilight. and then i read AGATB. now, im not obsessed anymore. lol

oh, and what were you guys talking about before twilight? in havent been on this group in MONTHS!!


message 302: by Allie, I'm not a princess, this ain't a fairy tale (new)

835716 Yeah. the obsessiveness is annoying.


message 301: by Kaitie♥ (new)

1351890 I love Twilight. But the whole hype about it making me want to kick it out of my house


message 300: by Lindsay (new)

1889852 It's an anime... But I know that the author likes anime because this random person was reading a Shonen Jump magazine, which is an anime publishing company thing, and only people who know about anime would know about Shonen Jump.


message 299: by Allie, I'm not a princess, this ain't a fairy tale (new)

835716 What's bleach?


message 298: by Lindsay (new)

1889852 Deliabookworm wrote: "Allie wrote: "Definately. All the amazingness minus the controlling, semi-jerkish part."

I have never read the Mortal Intruments Series, but a semi jerk? Edward is far worse than that...lol I ..."


Wait, is the Mortal Instruments Series the City of Bones and stuff? Grrr... The author totally stole her idea from Bleach! That filthy... *mutters under breath*



message 297: by Lisa (new)

898008 Deliabookworm wrote: "Yeah, then I read Breaking Dawn, lol. And reread the series (for the millionth time) with a new eye."</

Same story here. Funny how that worked...addictive drug and antidote all with color coordinated book jackets.



message 296: by ♥BookGeek♥ (new)

2254001 Oh. That figures


message 295: by deliabookworm (new)

2072336 Yeah, then I read Breaking Dawn, lol. And reread the series (for the millionth time) with a new eye.


message 294: by ♥BookGeek♥ (new)

2254001 Huh? You used to love it?


message 293: by deliabookworm (new)

2072336 I hate Twilight in general, lol, you can find my posts on the "Twilight Haters" group. I know why some people like it though, I used to love it too. :)


message 292: by ♥BookGeek♥ (new)

2254001 Hey, Edward is sort of a jerk in some parts of the series! I like Edward but he still can be a jerk


message 291: by Allie, I'm not a princess, this ain't a fairy tale (new)

835716 Tamora Pierce is awesome.
and GRRR, even tho he can be i jerk i LOVE edward. :)


message 290: by deliabookworm (new)

2072336 Allie wrote: "Definately. All the amazingness minus the controlling, semi-jerkish part."

I have never read the Mortal Intruments Series, but a semi jerk? Edward is far worse than that...lol I hate Edward.



message 289: by ♥BookGeek♥ (new)

2254001 Really? I've never read her books! But I'm planning to!


message 288: by Kaitie♥ (new)

1351890 I Love Tamora Pierce books! I haven't read them in such a long time though! :(


message 287: by (G)Emma , Allie's a barbie doll!! (new)

611251 Yes, exactly!


message 286: by Allie, I'm not a princess, this ain't a fairy tale (last edited May 29, 2009 02:31PM) (new)

835716 Definately. All the amazingness minus the controlling, semi-jerkish part.


message 285: by (G)Emma , Allie's a barbie doll!! (new)

611251 Oh, I agree with him being somewhat of a jerk. I didn't like him for that reason. I wasn't surprised when he turned out to be gay, and that didn't affect my perception of him. Oh I love his gay boyfriend. He is most definitely my favorite character. Jace is like a better version of Edward in my opinion.


message 284: by deleted member (new)

lol


message 283: by Allie, I'm not a princess, this ain't a fairy tale (last edited May 28, 2009 09:52PM) (new)

835716 I know. That sounded weird and I put that wrong. He was kinda an idiot and a jerk in the beginning, that's all. But yes, him being gay did influence me not liking him a bit, but I wouldn't have anyway, and didn't like him before I found out that he was. But now I do more, because he's nicer. And has an awesome and funny boyfriend, lol. (*whispers* I'd like to point out that I absolutley love his (even more) gay boyfriend. Easily my favorite character, other than Jace. But Jace is like Edward so...)


message 282: by (G)Emma , Allie's a barbie doll!! (new)

611251 Allie, I think it's interesting how you worded that. I'm not attacking you, but I think it's interesting how because he's gay means that he had to prove himself to be a good person and friend. I might be interpreting it wrong, but I just find that interesting.


message 281: by Kaitie♥ (new)

1351890 There were hints?


message 280: by deleted member (new)

yep i totally understnd i just wasn't sure because how u wrote that it seemed like u did


message 279: by Allie, I'm not a princess, this ain't a fairy tale (new)

835716 Somewhat. It's complicated, I'm not totally against them or hate them or anything. But it's not the point and I'm not getting into it, I'd appreciate it if you just respect my thoughts and beliefs.


message 278: by deleted member (new)

wait do u have something against gays???


message 277: by Allie, I'm not a princess, this ain't a fairy tale (new)

835716 I saw it coming. I guessed in the first book, and in Rebel Angels I was pretty much positive that Fee really loved Pip, and still did. Still, I was a little surprised, idk why really, lol, since I was sure by then that they were lesbians.
I agree w what someone said... if libba revealed that earlier, i admit that i would be prejudiced and not liked Fee and Pip as much as I do. With the hints that i noticed, i got used to it and to them.
Like in Cassandra Clare's the Mortal Instruments series. One of the main characters is gay, and you find out pretty early in the first book. I was surprised, and didn't like him for a long time, until he really proved himself to be a good person and friend.


message 276: by deleted member (new)

whhaaaa wat???


message 275: by ♥BookGeek♥ (new)

2254001 Whaaaa????


message 274: by deleted member (last edited May 26, 2009 03:14AM) (new)

=^0


message 273: by Kaitie♥ (new)

1351890 Yaaaaaaaaa :D


message 272: by deleted member (new)

i thought about it but was like no way... big surprise there


message 271: by Kaitie♥ (new)

1351890 Whoa Courtney! You actually saw it coming? I totally didn't! :D


message 270: by deleted member (new)

yeah


message 269: by ♥BookGeek♥ (new)

2254001 Well, I understood that part but still wouldn't she have to face it sooner or later seeing that Pip wasn't good at all before they kissed or anything like that though. I know why Fee would have a hard time believing Gemma about everything she says about Pip and all but I thought that she was going to have to face the fact sooner or later.


message 268: by Jessalina (new)

937938 As I said before, I somewhat saw it coming. I wasn't surprised by any means. But I think Felicity still loved her, because they were apart. It's that saying, being apart makes the heart fonder. Also Fee didn't want to see was Pippa was becoming. She wanted to see Pippa as she once was.


message 267: by deleted member (last edited May 25, 2009 05:41AM) (new)

BookGeek wrote: "Did anyone NOT see that comming? Because I know I didn't. But why in the world would she still love Pip? I hated her in the end because of her selfishness and how she wants Gemma's power to herself..."

i thought it made sense she loved her for who she used to be not for who she became to be.


message 266: by ♥BookGeek♥ (new)

2254001 Did anyone NOT see that comming? Because I know I didn't. But why in the world would she still love Pip? I hated her in the end because of her selfishness and how she wants Gemma's power to herself. and now Pip and Fee are lovers?! How in the world does that make sense?


message 265: by deleted member (new)

yes but do u think that if she had immediately reveled there secret before we new who there characters were would that have changed opinions on them???


message 264: by Aana (new)

Nophoto-f-25x33 Taylor S wrote: "So, what do you think about Pip and Fee? It totally shocked me. I mean, I knew that they were really close, but that close? Whoa! "

(G)Emma wrote: "I was practically banging myhead against the wall when I found out! It was so freaking obvious!!!!! "

I read that part a few times before it actually believed it. I think that Libba Bray was trying to and was very succesful in making a point there about issues we're dealing with today. Gays and Lesbos are just like the rest of us exceot for the fact that they like the same gender. If you have read the entire series and get ti know everthing else about felicity and piper before you learn about thier relationship your opinion about them doesnt really change.



message 263: by deleted member (new)

well yes but i mean in the way of it is the same as any other relation ship


message 262: by (G)Emma , Allie's a barbie doll!! (new)

611251 Hahha, yesss.


message 261: by Lisa (new)

898008 (G)Emma wrote: "No relationship is easy to understand. "

True that!


message 260: by (G)Emma , Allie's a barbie doll!! (new)

611251 No relationship is easy to understand.


message 259: by deleted member (new)

i think gay relation ship[s are easy to understand it's just a bit different then wat most people are use to


message 258: by (G)Emma , Allie's a barbie doll!! (new)

611251 Hm, interesting. I should read all of these.


message 257: by Lisa (new)

898008 I tend to be more comfortable or understanding with gay relationships than with lesbian relationships in books. My husband is the opposite. The Mercy Thompson series by Patricia Briggs has a very compelling gay character/couple.


« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7
back to top

unread topics | mark unread