group discussion


54 views

topic: AGATB Movie > A Great and Terrible Beauty Movie!


Comments (showing 1-50 of 147) (147 new)    post a comment »

message 1: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 I just read Libba's blog and it said that the script is going to be finished in 4-6 weeks! I am going to die if the script isn't just right, and the actors don't look like the characters, and the realms don't look like the realms. So basically, they make one wrong move and this movie is completely awful in my book. It's going to be fun bashing it though. What do you guys think about it? And who should play the characters?


message 2: by deleted member (new)

Wait! Who's doing the movie?!? I didn't even know they were doing it! .... I'm so lost. :(


message 3: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 There is a movie coming out based on The Gemma Doyle Trilogy.


message 4: by Taylor S (new)

629721 I read the blog also. I like the fact that there is going to be a movie. I'm scared that I'm going to be dissappointed, though. Moviemakers always ruin it for me.


message 5: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 EXACTLY!! They could breathe wrong and I would declare it awful, the books are to precious to me!!


message 6: by Taylor S (new)

629721 I think that Libba has it under control, though. She added a post to her blog today. It is sooooo funny. Everyone has to read it.
Here is the link:
libba-bray.livejournal.com

P.S. Don't think that I'm going off topic. This post is all about the movie.


message 7: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 Omg that post is freaking hilarious!! I love that one!! Its soo awesome!!


message 8: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 Who do you guys think should play Kartik? I cant think of anyone.


message 9: by Taylor S (new)

629721 I think that the four girls and Kartik should all be newcomers, and then the adults should be really seasoned actors and actresses. I think that maybe Maggie Smith or Helen Mirren should be Mrs Nightwing


message 10: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 Ya, definetly newcomers for the girls and Kartik. Who should play Circe? Thats also going to be a tall order for me, Circe has to capture the good and the bad, the light and the dark, but slightly more so with the dark, the actress has to be amazing and again, I don't think that certain picture in my head of her can't be matched.


message 11: by Emily (new)

1068275 When she was in my home town last week I met her and she said she's hoping for brand-new nobody has heard from before actresses... And as long as it wasn't Miley Cyrus.... As she put it "That would not be the best of both worlds"
She also says that writers have basically no control over the movie...


message 12: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 lol I know in her blog when she said no Miley Cyrus, I was dying laughing, Miley would be soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo bad. And Miley is certainly not a unknown. lol "That would not be the best of both worlds" love tht!! You met Libba? LUCKY!!


message 13: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 Hmmmmmmm I was just wondering who would play Miss Mccleethy, that will be interesting.


message 14: by deleted member (new)

Do you know when it's coming out?


message 15: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 I think it's coming out in sometime in 2009, I hope it's a fall movie!


message 16: by deleted member (new)

I can't wait!


message 17: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 I know!! I hope it's a huge hit so I can be like " I loved them before it was a movie, HAH!"


message 18: by Allie, I forgot to say outloud how beautiful you really are to me (new)

835716 Wasn't it funny in the blog with her whole funny idea? That would be hilarious


message 19: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 I know! Libba is soo funny, she could probably be a stand up comedian if she wanted.


message 20: by Allie, I forgot to say outloud how beautiful you really are to me (new)

835716 Did you see the videos she made with Maureen Johnson?


message 21: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 lol Ya! They are soooooo hilarious!


message 22: by deleted member (new)

I would be on a rebellion if Miley was going to play Gemma. I would be outside the movie theatres with signs saying not to watch the movie cause the Miley is an idiot!


message 23: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 I would be protesting with you!


message 24: by Allie, I forgot to say outloud how beautiful you really are to me (new)

835716 me 2



message 25: by Jenny, I'm gone! To find someone to live for in this world (new)

1188252 Omg. Me too. I would hunt down Miley and knock her out and then lock her in the closet. Then go protest.


message 26: by Taylor S (new)

629721 I seriously don't think that Miley will be in the movie. That would be moviemaker suicide for her and all of the casting agents and producers.


message 27: by deleted member (new)

She could NEVER pull it off! Her country accent would SO not work! And the movie would be totally UNSUCCESSFUL!


message 28: by Allie, I forgot to say outloud how beautiful you really are to me (new)

835716 lol. libba would hate it 2


message 29: by deleted member (new)

Libba would probably sue, and tell them on like LIVE TV that she had no part in the casting of this movie. And Miley would cry and get kicked off, and then they would get a new actress! Yea!


message 30: by Allie, I forgot to say outloud how beautiful you really are to me (new)

835716 hooray!


message 31: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 lol rock on!


message 32: by Allie, I forgot to say outloud how beautiful you really are to me (new)

835716 i like these people. scroll down like halfway

http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=h...


message 33: by Allie, I forgot to say outloud how beautiful you really are to me (last edited Jun 15, 2008 09:56PM) (new)

835716 oh! and go to youtube and if you but 'a great and terribe beauty-characters' theres also a great one, but i think they put ithal instead of kartik. Brigid is perfect! I like Rachel Hurd-wood for Gemma for sure, and in another one i think Keira would be awesome as pippa if she had black hair. and if you type in 'a great and terrible beauty- felicity and pippa' theres a great one for them.


message 34: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 Seriously, I am sooooo happy and excited right now, because I'm praying that Romola Garai is going to be cast for Felicity! I have no idea why I thought she would be old now, but she was Briony in Atonment, so I'm really hoping that she is going to be Felicity!


message 35: by deleted member (new)

Who is Romola Garai?


message 36: by Jenny, I'm gone! To find someone to live for in this world (new)

1188252 I don't know. I'll look her up in google.


message 37: by Jenny, I'm gone! To find someone to live for in this world (new)

1188252 http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0304801/ Here is a link to her IMDb page.


message 38: by deleted member (new)

If Eva Green was younger she might actually make a good Pippa!


message 39: by Jenny, I'm gone! To find someone to live for in this world (new)

1188252 Yeah, if she were younger. Except I sort of see pippa like Alexis Bledel. Not exactly but pretty close.
Check this out Helena, someone just mentioned her for the movie on the site imdb for playing Gemma. And she's not my exact vision of gemma but I think she could pull it off. Look wise. But, she needs green eyes. But acting wise I don't know, I've never seen her act. She's a model right now, though. Exept it says she's interested in acting.

http://nymag.com/fashion/models/cdicker/...


message 40: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 She looks absolutely nothing like my Gemma.


message 41: by Jenny, I'm gone! To find someone to live for in this world (new)

1188252 Eh, yeah... You have to get her outside of modeling pics.


message 42: by Jenny, I'm gone! To find someone to live for in this world (new)

1188252 And she needs to be taller with a longer face.


message 43: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 And not so many freckles.


message 44: by Jenny, I'm gone! To find someone to live for in this world (new)

1188252 Yeah, but Gemma has that many freckles. She grew up in india. But I don't know Cyntia does have a lot. My gemma doesn't have as many as her, but still quite a lot.


message 45: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 You know, you all are going to kill me for this but, I didn't really picture her with freckles. A dust of them on her cheeks and nose, but otherwise, not really.


message 46: by Jenny, I'm gone! To find someone to live for in this world (new)

1188252 Its fine, every one sees her different. Honestly I like the girl's on the book covers the most.


message 47: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 Me too. What's your favorite cover? I love TSFT.


message 48: by Jenny, I'm gone! To find someone to live for in this world (new)

1188252 I love TSFT the most too. But, I see Gemma as the girl on Rebel Angels.


message 49: by (G)Emma , Cuz when a heart breaks no it don't break even (new)

611251 Really? I certainly don't. I don't know how to explain her.


message 50: by Jenny, I'm gone! To find someone to live for in this world (new)

1188252 Except she's tanner with more freckles.


« previous 1 3
back to top


unread topics | mark unread