group discussion


45 views

topic: Why must disney remake all their classics?





Comments (showing 1-21)    post a comment »
dateUp_arrow    newest »

message 21: by Tom (new)

821945 "Can't wait for the Plan 9 remake!"

It was directed by Rob Marshall, and won the Oscar for Best Picture.


message 20: by Debbie (new)

1380937 Jim wrote: "The same reason every studio in the world is remaking every movie ever made. Can't wait for the Plan 9 remake!"

I can't wait for that one, either, Jim!!!


message 19: by Tom (new)

821945 Now Svanjmayer doing PINOCCHIO -- that I'd see.

I'd say not to be in any rush about ROBOCOP.


message 18: by Phillip (new)

299646 i've never seen robocop...(i know, i KNOW!). it's in my netflix queue.


message 17: by Alex DeLarge (new)

1240502 Esoteric quote from ROBOCOP.

LITTEL OTIK meets Steamboat Willie...or is that "eats"?


message 16: by Phillip (new)

299646 right?


message 15: by Alex DeLarge (new)

1240502 I'll buy THAT for a dollar!!


message 14: by Phillip (last edited 10 days ago, 12:38AM) (new)

299646 c'mon, we're due for a remake of steamboat willie! (by jan swankmeyer)


message 13: by Alex DeLarge (new)

1240502 The underlying problem is that you're watching the Disney channell at all;)


message 12: by Jim (new)

1530422 The same reason every studio in the world is remaking every movie ever made. Can't wait for the Plan 9 remake!


1065366 Becky wrote: "I'm watching the Disney channel with my son today and suddenly Parent Trap comes on. Not my favorite classic with Haley Mills, no some random remake with Lindsey Lohan. Then it hits me, the have ..."

The sub-par remake is just part of the life force that keeps The People's Republic of Disney alive. They mass produce the garbage, but cringe in denial that The Song of the South was ever made. Takes the zip out of my zip a dee doo dah, that is for sure.





message 10: by Heather L (new)

Nophoto-f-25x33 Yet.


message 9: by Tanja (new)

2342217 Some of the remakes aren't that bad. I like to watch the original and remake back-to-back. What I dislike is whenever the remake is doubly cheesy.

And let's face it Lohan is this generation's Haley Mills (cept more bad girl). THANKFULLY they haven't touched Pollyana or Summer Magic :)


message 8: by Sherri (new)

Nophoto-f-25x33 Becky, it's true. The "common wisdom" is that mainstream American audiences will not WATCH foreign films -- films from other countries are for the highbrow, the intelligentsia, the elitists, the hip and wannabe types. To bring them to the US, they must be remade (I'm really surprised that Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon wasn't done over with Keanu Reeve as Li Mu Bai, but maybe that was the magic of Ang Lee, and Chinese actors who could do their own English dubbing)

I'll admit I don't watch a LOT of foreign films (I'm a Miyazaki addict) often because I feel like I need to do research to really 'get' the film and I don't always feel up to it. But I know and love quite a few and I am not usually pleased with "USification" of them.


message 7: by Becky (new)

988660 Its a sad commentary on our society. Though I have heard the joke several times about hou many Jane Eyre movies there are! The fact US movie makers must shock their audiences to get them to watch films, rather than people wanting to enjoy good cinema makes me crave the forgien laungage section of my movie collection. At least these tend to be the originals that the US rips off!


message 6: by Sherri (new)

Nophoto-f-25x33 On the nose, Tom. On the nose.

Also, they are remaking them to appeal to more contemporary audiences (so they can make money again). Many many MANY people -- not just kids -- have no interest in puzzling out the meaning of movies that don't contain familiar ideas, viewpoints, and actions. Face it -- in a world where young starlets step out of cars and give paparazzi crotch shots, cutting the back of a skirt off to expose a young girl's white cotton granny panties isn't really anything that gets a reaction.

Why, after all, do they keep remaking Jane Austen movies? And I think Jane Eyre may be one of the most made/remade movies of all time -- I counted 20 English language versions on IMDB.

Yeah, it's for money, to keep those movie properties bringing in the bucks.


message 5: by Tom (new)

821945 Why must Disney remake all of their classics?

Why, to make money, of course.


message 4: by Heather L (new)

Nophoto-f-25x33 It's not just Disney movies. They just remade FAME, for Pete's sake, a perfectly good 80s movie. You can't tell me there aren't any great scripts being written out there that they feel the need to constantly remake what didn't need fixing.


message 3: by Anna (new)

202331 Yeah big bills.......


message 2: by Phillip (new)

299646 c'mon, lindsey's livelihood depends on those worthless remakes at this point! they just don't giveaway those rehab visits. that girl's got bills to pay...


message 1: by Becky (new)

988660 I'm watching the Disney channel with my son today and suddenly Parent Trap comes on. Not my favorite classic with Haley Mills, no some random remake with Lindsey Lohan. Then it hits me, the have redone Herbie, Freaky Friday, Escape to Witch Mountian, etc. (Most of them have Lindsey Lohen, which doesn't help the cause either) Why? I LOVED all of those classic movies, what was wrong with them. Why the need to re-do them all, with sub par acting, and bad screen shot by screen shot remakes, with not so subtle modernization. Is our society so far removed from the good classics, that this is what we are doomed to live with?




back to top

unread topics | mark unread