group discussion


24 views

topic: Books: Fiction > "Daemon" by Daniel Suarez





Comments (showing 1-1)    post a comment »
dateUp_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Richard, Founder and CEO (last edited May 03, 2009 03:44AM) (new)

1662632 Book: Daemon
Author: Daniel Suarez

Key concepts:
* Singluarity as human-engineered AI (mad-scientist variety)
* AI presented as non-sentient/non-conscious (i.e., not a true singularity event)
* Possible "stunted" singularity?
* Plausible conditions for the prevention of a true singularity are implied
* Depiction of events during transition
* Depiction of human social condition post-Singularity

 On its face, Daemon is a tech thriller that doesn't ever invoke the idea of the singularity at all. A mad-scientist type creates a complex of distributed AI programs, each awaiting specific triggering conditions, the first of which is news of his death. The initial events are very bloody and confusing to the unsuspecting humans, and the book primarily traces how various people react to this confusion: some are drawn in as co-conspirators by the Daemon, others try to fight it, while yet more try to maintain denial that any extra-human agents are involved at all.

* * * * * Spoilers! * * * * *

 Suarez's Daemon is not explicitly about the Singularity at all: the word is never used, and through most of the story it is emphasized that the AI is no more than a large complex of interacting scripts, scattered through the internet, each passively waiting and observing for its own triggering event (e.g., the "daemon" of the title).

This is largely contradicted by events depicted in the last chapters, where the AI's orchestrations of its human minions exhibits a more and more complex planning and motivation. The conceit is retained to the end that the conversations performed by the dead creator's avatar were recorded as set-piece speeches before the action begins, but this becomes largely implausible by the end of the book.

Normally, such a very limited AI shouldn't have become the entity triggering the singularity at all, and it is actually possible to read this as a preemptive not-quite-sentient AI that imposes social conditions which prevent the emergence of a truly transformative AI agent. But in order to plan and manage society effectively, the Daemon (the AI) would need to learn and react to a changing situation as the years go by. Perhaps trusted programmers could be enlisted to edit the AI's components over time -- the story presents that AI as coordinating cells of humans to accomplish large tasks which those people don't individually understand.

But this actually involves a plot weakness: this level of planning really does require a much more sophisticated AI than the story ever discusses. This could be seen as a non-quite sentient AI, or a stunted-AI that is inherently limited to be symbiotic with human society.


 The book is set in the very near future. The sophistication of the AI itself and some of the technology used superficially in the cyberpunk-ish later chapters are currently implausible.

This means that the social conditions are our social conditions, and the author does a decent job of presenting the many forms of denial, fear, bewilderment and more complex reactions that people will likely exhibit.

We are teased with some nuances that the book, as a thriller, never delves into. For example, this Daemon now a omniscient and omnipotent totalitarian overseer? If it remains a non-judgmental demigod (though amoral and of questionable benevolence), is it possible that this will lead to long-term social stability? If people are sometimes used as pawns in the Daemon's plans, to what extent would they remain culpable for what would have been immoral acts under previous social conditions?


Fiction depicting a singularity transition can often be apocalyptic, for the humans at least. One appealing aspect of Suarez's usage is that there remains a role for humanity, even if it is subserviant to an authoritarian overlord.


back to top

unread topics | mark unread

Books mentioned in this topic

Daemon (other topics)

Authors mentioned in this topic

Daniel Suarez (other topics)