group discussion


97 views

topic: What should Michael read re: the Holocaust





Comments (showing 1-12)    post a comment »
dateUp_arrow    newest »

message 12: by Debbie (new)

686757 QB 7 by Leon Uris, and Mila 18 by the same author are both quite vivid too......


message 11: by Michael (new)

1021858 thanks for the info Irene! I've heard good things about that book!


message 10: by Irene (new)

1521651 I'm new to this group, so hello. I read "the Search for Six of Six Million" by Daniel Mendelsohn (sp?) a year ago. The author's grandfather and 4 of his siblings got out of Europe before the Holocaust. One of the grandfather's brothers did not get out and he was killed along with his wife and their 4 children. The author, an academic by profession who knows a thing or two about research, decides he wants to find out what happened to them. Over quite a period of time he was able to find a handful of survivors from the village, who knew his family, who told him what they knew along with their own stories of survival. He also visited the village where it all happened and talking to non-Jews there who knew the family. By methodically piecing together pieces of information he puts together a story of what happened. By dealing with just 6 lives, and the lives of thos who touched them, the story is very personal and immediate. What makes it even more moving is that the survivors are elderly by the time Mendelsohnn begins his search, and a number of them die before he meets them or shortly after he connects with them. It's also a story of his own family and growing up in America. He was close to the grandfather who lost his brother. It's a long book and to be honest I skimmed parts. But much of it was very strong. I recommend it to anyone interested in this period of history, or who is interested in the resources available for researching Jewish families from eastern Europe.


message 9: by Gena (new)

1123072 I read The Book Thief a couple of months ago and had much the same reaction to it as you, Michael. It is an outstanding book.

Two YA novels on the subject that moved me as a kid were Summer of My German Soldier by Bette Greene and Gentlehands by M. E. Kerr. I've since reread Summer of My German Soldier and can confirm that it's a powerful read for an adult, too. Not really a Holocaust novel, but rather a portrait of a devastatingly lonely Jewish girl in rural Arkansas who befriends an escaped German POW. I stayed up all night to finish it, crying and crying and crying.

Gentlehands, if I remember correctly, is about a boy growing up in the 1970s whose beloved, erudite grandfather is accused by the community of Nazi war crimes. Again, not a Holocaust novel per se, but more about how the collective psychological wounds of that era are passed down through generations. I just read a more recent WWII YA novel on a similar subject: Tamar by Mal Peet, which moves between a romantic drama played out by Dutch resistance fighters during the War, and a modern teenage girl's attempt to piece together that narrative in order to understand her late grandfather, one of the members of the resistance. A really beautiful book.


message 8: by Lauren (new)

Nophoto-f-25x33 I think that the graphic novel by Art Speigelman called Maus is a great read. It gives a fresh take on the Holocaust. I am not an avid reader of graphic novels, but I think that this is one that is worth a look.


message 7: by Conny (new)

1062214 I just finished Edith Hahn Beer's The Nazi Officer's Wife How One Jewish Woman Survived the Holocaust. It is probably one of the best books by a Holocaust survivor I have ever read. She survived as a "U-Boat", i.e. under somebody else's name and by being married to a German officer. It is very interesting how she describes her life, but it is also fascinating to read her observations about the Germans in those days in general. Edith Hahn Beer herself is not German, but Austrian. Two of her sisters managed to escape to Israel before the World War II began, but she did not leave because her boyfriend wanted to stay. She lived with her mother, until the Nazis forced her into forced labor. She was put on a train and sent to a very small town to work on an asparagus plantation, and from then on her life becomes an odyssey.
It seems a miracle to me that she did not have a nervous breakdown after she became, what survivors call an U-boat. Imagine to live the life of someone else, behaving totally differently from who you are - not just for a day, but over years...

And the asparagus plantation where the Nazis sent her, is in the same little town where I went to senior highschool. Of course, there was never any reason to believe that this little town would have been a haven of resistance against the brown plague, but it is somewhat strange and shocking to read about it on the other side of the world seventy years after it happened. Neither my father's nor my mother's families lived in the area at the time, but it would be interesting if the farmer's family is still living there.


message 6: by Sandi (new)

811687 The one book, other than Anne Frank's diary, that moved me more than any other was The Hiding Place by Corrie Ten Boom. Ten Boom was a girl during WWII whose parents hid Jews from the Nazis. It's one of those books that makes me wonder if I'd have the courage to do the right thing or not.

A more recent book is Sarah's Key by Tatiana de Rosnay. It's a fictional account of one girl's experience during the round-up and incarceration of Jews in France and a 21st century journalist's uncovering the little girl's story and her husband's family's connection to it.


message 5: by ♥Eva♥ (last edited Apr 06, 2009 02:34PM) (new)

1336770 Night by Elie Wiesel is the most excellent Holocaust book I've read so far. Sala's Gift was very good also.
Those Who Save Us is supposed to be great too- my sister is borrowing my copy and I just today got Survival in Auschwitz in the mail and also The Nazi Officer's Wife How One Jewish Woman Survived the Holocaust

I have a holocaust list that may help you if you want to take a look. Some are rated and some are to-read but I only add those that look REALLY interesting to me because my to-read list is so long and it's getting out of control. :)


message 4: by Michael (new)

1021858 Thanks for starting this topic Summer and for the suggestions everyone!


message 3: by Deb (last edited Mar 21, 2009 11:51AM) (new)

1099486 I just finished Those Who Save Usby Jenna Blum. It is an excellent portrayal of how the Holocaust affected the German population, as well as the after-affects for one family years later in the U.S. A very well written book--I couldn't put it down--my book group will be discussing it next week and I'm really interested to see what people think.


message 2: by Conny (new)

1062214 I think you should try Still Alive A Holocaust Girlhood Remembered. It is a really good memoir and I enjoyed it very much, if that can be said about a book about the Holocaust. There are so many out there, that it is hard to recommend something.Here are a few that are on my tbr-list: Sala's Gift My Mother's Holocaust Story, Survival in Auschwitz, The Nazi Officer's Wife How One Jewish Woman Survived the Holocaust, and Robert Merle's "Death is my Trade".


message 1: by Summer (new)

227351 Books On The Nightstand: Difficult (but Necessary) Reading

Posted: 13 Mar 2009 02:00 AM PDT

By Michael

In episode 26 of the podcast, Ann and I discussed books that had been sitting patiently on our shelves and that we finally got around to reading. I gushed and raved over The Book Thief and mentioned that, even though I hadn't read Night by Elie Wiesel, I imagined The Book Thief was similar in its power.

I was getting into bed the other evening and noticed Night sitting on the bookshelf near my nightstand. (Yes, I actually have a bookcase next to my bed - so why are there still piles on the floor?) Night has been sitting on that shelf since it was published in a new translation back in 2006. I decided the time was right to read the book.

I'm only half-way through, but it's easy to see why this book has endured and has been so acclaimed. The book is shocking in its horrors, and rightly so. It brings the holocaust to life in a way I haven't encountered since I visited the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum. (An unbelievable experience. If you've never been, and the Holocaust is something you want to know more about, I highly recommend it.)

Here's my question to all of you wonderful readers out there: What else should I read on this subject? I've read Anne Frank's The Diary of a Young Girl and Maus. There's also a new book out called Every Man Dies Alone that's getting amazing reviews, so I may have to pick that one up too. What else?


I recently read:
I Have Lived A Thousand Years  Growing Up In The Holocaust

A fiction one you might try is:
Briar Rose


back to top

unread topics | mark unread

Books mentioned in this topic

Briar Rose (other topics)
I Have Lived A Thousand Years: Growing Up In The Holocaust (other topics)
The Nazi Officer's Wife: How One Jewish Woman Survived the Holocaust (other topics)
Sala's Gift: My Mother's Holocaust Story (other topics)
Survival in Auschwitz (other topics)
More...

Authors mentioned in this topic

Elie Wiesel (other topics)