group discussion
topic:
AGATB Movie >
Movie Actors
Who do you think should play Gemma and the pther characters if they make a movie? (which I think they are) I have no ideas (besides Taylor Lautner for Kartik! yay)
Taylor for Kartik? Really? But Kartik's Indian, and Taylor is already Jacob in Twilight.
I don't know, I think Alexis's beauty is a bit too innocent to play Pippa.
I think Romola Garai or an unknown should play Fee, Anna Popplewell or unknown for Pippa, and unknowns for Gemma and Ann.
as much as i like taylor lautner, i don't think he's a good enough actor, and he's not indian. so i wouldn't want him as kartik...i haven't really thought about any of the actors/actresses. i don't really want to get my hopes up about the movie and then end up not liking it (that's what happened with twilight), so i'm not gonna think about it that much...
Um. No idea. I pictured Gemma like Rachel Hurd Wood while reading the series, but that's all. I think, um, wuts her face...Cate Blanchett would b a good Circe... I think that if she was older, Dakota Fanning could b Fee, she's an AMAZING actress. Alexis would b an OK pippa, not the best, and even tho he's totally hot enough, I can't c Taylor as Kartik. Well, he'll b in New Moon more, so welllc more of his acting then, so possibly.
What about this guy for Kartik....Shahid Kapoor...
Rachel hurd wood for Gemma...
Taylor Momsen for Fee...
He's not bad, but I still say an unknown.
I don't know, there's something about RHW that I don't like for Gem. I can't place my finger on it.
Her hair is absolutely perfect, but her face...it's too delicate, too perfect. She needs to have freckles and stronger features.
Cate Blanchet is Great she is a great actress and would probably play the role perfectly and Taylor is a good one 2 the other two just didn't thrill me
Omgz, i love all of those, not so much the kartik one tho. RHW def, even tho she's a bit delicate, after i saw her picture when i just started the first book, it's how i've pictured gem. the girl for Fee is VERY good also, and of course, circe.
hm, she's not my gemma.
I have a friend, who even tho she's not my gemma, i think she'd be good just following the description. She's tall, and not super skinny, definitly not fat tho, with long red hair, maybe too orange, with greenish-blue eyes, and lots of freckles on her face and arms, and she's around the right age, like 17 I think.
http://content2.catalog.photos.msn.com/f...He's too old, but the best possibility I've seen for Kartik.
Yeah, he's in his 30's, but Kartik needs to have a very dark Indian look. Even though Shahid Kapoor is really Indian, he could pass for any number of ethnicities, maybe he could tan up to be very dark. Remember how dark Kartik was supposed to be (couldn't blend in at the dress up ball). It's going to be a tough one, for sure. Help us out Ballywood! (I've noticed most Ballywood actors tend to be light though, hmmm....)
i think rachel hurd wood would be a good gemma and cate blanchett for circe, but not taylor momsen for fee or that guy for kartik.
(G)Emma wrote: "Hmm, too old, but I get the idea, Lisa. Kinda my image of Kartik, but not exactly. "
i agree
Probably. The only actors I can think of always remind me of the characters they have played before.
(G)Emma wrote: "Grace, I totally agree. Except I still sort of want Dev Patel for Kartik. LOL. "
actually me too emma
XD
i love him in slumdog millionaire
Courtney wrote: "I don't like Dev Patel for Karik. I mean he's Indian, but I just didn't picture Kartik that way."Yeah but we are never going to find a Kartik that fits are mental image perfectly
Dev is a great actor and adorable =)
I do perfer a hotter man but Dev is awesome
Well, that's an interesting twist....now those of us who haven't done our yearly reread will need to try it picturing him!
