Russell's review

[close]

blog this review

Copy/paste the text below into your blog.

<a href="http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/816.Cryptonomicon?utm_medium=api&amp;utm_source=blog_review" style="float: left; padding-right: 20px"><img alt="Cryptonomicon" border="0" src="http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1157396454m/816.jpg" /></a> <a href="http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/816.Cryptonomicon?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_review">Cryptonomicon</a> by <a href="http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/545.Neal_Stephenson">Neal Stephenson</a> 
 <a href="http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/7808670?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_review"><h3>My review</h3></a>
 rating: 3 of 5 stars Arrgh! I don't remember a book that I both liked and didn't like this much!
 
 Alright, a quick intro snipped from Amazon:
 
 "Cryptonomicon zooms all over the world, careening conspiratorially back and forth between two time periods--World War II and the present. Our 1940s heroes are the brilliant mathematician Lawrence Waterhouse, cryptanalyst extraordinaire, and gung ho, morphine-addicted marine Bobby Shaftoe. They're part of Detachment 2702, an Allied group trying to break Axis communication codes while simultaneously preventing the enemy from figuring out that their codes have been broken. Their job boils down to layer upon layer of deception. Dr. Alan Turing is also a member of 2702, and he explains the unit's strange workings to Waterhouse. "When we want to sink a convoy, we send out an observation plane first.... Of course, to observe is not its real duty--we already know exactly where the convoy is. Its real duty is to be observed.... Then, when we come round and sink them, the Germans will not find it suspicious."
 
 All of this secrecy resonates in the present-day story line, in which the grandchildren of the WWII heroes--inimitable programming geek Randy Waterhouse and the lovely and powerful Amy Shaftoe--team up to help create an offshore data haven in Southeast Asia and maybe uncover some gold once destined for Nazi coffers. To top off the paranoiac tone of the book, the mysterious Enoch Root, key member of Detachment 2702 and the Societas Eruditorum, pops up with an unbreakable encryption scheme left over from WWII to befuddle the 1990s protagonists with conspiratorial ties. "
 
 Whew!
 
 Stephenson takes 918 pages to spin his yarn and in the end I enjoyed most of the ride but I wondered what was the point. After 918 pages, that's not a good thing.
 
 Pros:
 1) It's a long book. If you like to settle down to a long book, this will do.
 2) There is a strong pro-libertarian theme running throughout.
 3) Some of his writing is quite good, entertaining, thoughtful, fun, thought provoking, well done.
 4) He puts out some ideas that are really sharp. His discussion on Athena between Root and Randy got my little hamster wheels turning inside my head. He does this a few times.
 5) Math. Not much but he uses actual math. And it fits with the story.
 6) Cryptography. He uses actual cryptography and it also fits with the story. 
 
 
 Cons:
 1) It's a freaking long book. If you like your books to be in the 200 - 300 page range, give this one a pass.
 2) It just... ends. All the characters suddenly lose all the depth and charm Stephenson had imbued them with and it just stops. I think he should embarrassed that 900 pages weren't enough to end this in a satisfactory manner.
 3) Was there a character not obsessed with sex? No? Right, right, I come from a Puritan background where I was beaten for having impure thoughts, but still, sex was a constant theme for just about every single character. It got really tiresome.
 4) Potty mouths. The lot of them.
 5) Sometimes his writing just sucked. Flat out bad. I wondered if he eschewed an editor.
 6) Bobby Shaftoe's death. At the start of the scene where he dies, I thought "This would be the worst possible place to have him die after all the crap he went through" and, of course, he dies. Lamely.
 
 So do I recommend this book? No, not really. It has some stellar moments, mired in dross. If you still want to read it, well, caveat lector.
 <a href="http://www.goodreads.com/review/list/544124?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_review">View all my reviews.</a>

Russell's review
rating:

Arrgh! I don't remember a book that I both liked and didn't like this much!

Alright, a quick intro snipped from Amazon:

"Cryptonomicon zooms all over the world, careening conspiratorially back and forth between two time periods--World War II and the present. Our 1940s heroes are the brilliant mathematician Lawrence Waterhouse, cryptanalyst extraordinaire, and gung ho, morphine-addicted marine Bobby Shaftoe. They're part of Detachment 2702, an Allied group trying to break Axis communication codes while simultaneously preventing the enemy from figuring out that their codes have been broken. Their job boils down to layer upon layer of deception. Dr. Alan Turing is also a member of 2702, and he explains the unit's strange workings to Waterhouse. "When we want to sink a convoy, we send out an observation plane first.... Of course, to observe is not its real duty--we already know exactly where the convoy is. Its real duty is to be observed.... Then, when we come round and sin...more

Like this review? yes (4 people liked it) flag

comments (showing 1-2 of 2)

newest »

date

message 1: by Jason

12/21/2007 09:34AM

Tying together the families of the characters seemed forced and the ending felt as if the author had written himself into a corner. There's a lot of cool insight into the world of crypto, but the story could have been much more interesting.