<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<GoodreadsResponse>
	<Request>
		<authentication>false</authentication>
		    <method><![CDATA[]]></method>
	</Request>
	<review id="75745162">
    <user id="216786">
    <name><![CDATA[Ken-ichi]]></name>
    <location><![CDATA[Oakland, CA]]></location>        
    <url><![CDATA[http://www.goodreads.com/user/show/216786-ken-ichi]]></url>
    
  </user>
    <book>
  <id type="integer">6376401</id>
  <isbn>037541519X</isbn>
  <isbn13>9780375415197</isbn13>
  <ratings_count type="integer">19</ratings_count>
  <text_reviews_count type="integer">6</text_reviews_count>
  <title>The Sibley Guide to Trees</title>
  <average_rating></average_rating>
  <image_url>http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1255789324m/6376401.jpg</image_url>
  <link>http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6376401-the-sibley-guide-to-trees</link>
<author>
  <id type="integer">9798</id>
  <name>David Allen Sibley</name>
  <ratings_count type="integer">535</ratings_count>
  <text_reviews_count type="integer">88</text_reviews_count>
</author>
</book>

    <rating>3</rating>
  <votes>1</votes>
  <spoiler_flag>false</spoiler_flag>
  <shelves>
        <shelf name="guides" />
        <shelf name="learning" />
      </shelves>
  <recommended_for><![CDATA[]]></recommended_for>
  <recommended_by><![CDATA[]]></recommended_by>
  <read_at>Sun Oct 25 00:00:00 -0700 2009</read_at>
  <date_added>Sun Oct 25 23:34:02 -0700 2009</date_added>
  <date_updated>Sun Oct 25 23:49:41 -0700 2009</date_updated>
  <read_count></read_count>
    <body><![CDATA[Sibley's bird guides have become the authoritative field guides to the birds of North America, and with good reason: thoughtful, consistent layout combined with beautiful, precise illustrations and lots of helpful ID notes make for a great experience.  So, I was pretty intrigued to find he made a guide to trees.  Like the bird guides, it is beautiful and packed with great information (the range maps are particularly useful), but overall it's not quite up to snuff.  I've actually been reading the guide (intro, looking up favorite trees, etc) for a few days, but I just gave it a test drive in the field today and found it sadly wanting, especially in comparison the the drier key approach used in my go-to plant guide for this area, Beidleman and Kozloff's <a href="http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1013348.Plants_of_the_San_Francisco_Bay_Region_Mendocino_to_Monterey_Revised_Edition" title="Plants of the San Francisco Bay Region  Mendocino to Monterey, Revised Edition by Linda Beidleman">Plants of the San Francisco Bay Region</a>.  One major problem is a lack of any kind of preview or index system.  Sibley's bird guides begin each family or major group with a grid of all the species contained therein, which is pretty useful for giving the whole group a glance and picking out the bird you've got in your binocs, and when this fails those guides are still pretty flippable: go somewhere close to the bird you're looking at (passerines, divers, raptors, etc), start flipping, and you'll see something similar.  It's much harder to do this for trees, given their highly variable appearance, so it's hard to narrow down possibilities.  Sure it's a pine but... this is the west.  There are a lot of pines.  Many practical tidbits seem to be lacking as well, like the &quot;hairy armpits&quot; where the veins fork on the underside of a coast live oak leaf, or the way a juniper's berries smell like gin when crushed.<br/><br/>Overall, I think this is a great home reference, but I'll stick to keys in the field.]]></body>
    <url><![CDATA[http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/75745162]]></url>
</review>

</GoodreadsResponse>