Leftbanker's Reviews > The Olive Farm: A Memoir of Life, Love, and Olive Oil in the South of France
The Olive Farm: A Memoir of Life, Love, and Olive Oil in the South of France
by Carol Drinkwater
by Carol Drinkwater
Leftbanker's review
bookshelves: travel
Apr 04, 11
bookshelves: travel
Recommended to Leftbanker by:
People who eat at The Oilve Garden
Recommended for:
People taking a break from Harlequin Romances
read count: nearly once
More lifestyle porn. Jesus, another A Year in Provence, Under the Tuscan Sun -esque memoir of an over-privileged hack who buys an old place in a foreign land and fixes it up. She makes it appear in this book that she is so original in wanting to buy a romantic old farm in France. Who the fuck wouldn’t want to do this if they had the resources? This book should be subtitled: Every noun must have an adjective, every verb an adverb. Here she is talking about her idyllic wonderland:
And, in among all of these gregarious and bohemian activities, I slip away unnoticed to a cool stone room of my own, lined head to foot with books, sprawling with maps and dictionaries, switch on my computer and settle down peacefully to write.
Maybe I’m being too snarky but it sure seems to me like she could use the practice…and an editor. Can you bear to read more?
“Summer is slipping away, like the silent falling of petals [Don’t petals fall in spring?]. Everyone has left, and we are on our own. The swallows gather, autumn sets in, rustic and rather rainy.”
There is a bit about olives to be learned but it just isn’t worth the effort.
And, in among all of these gregarious and bohemian activities, I slip away unnoticed to a cool stone room of my own, lined head to foot with books, sprawling with maps and dictionaries, switch on my computer and settle down peacefully to write.
Maybe I’m being too snarky but it sure seems to me like she could use the practice…and an editor. Can you bear to read more?
“Summer is slipping away, like the silent falling of petals [Don’t petals fall in spring?]. Everyone has left, and we are on our own. The swallows gather, autumn sets in, rustic and rather rainy.”
There is a bit about olives to be learned but it just isn’t worth the effort.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Olive Farm.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-5 of 5) (5 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Diane C.
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Dec 29, 2008 11:42am
John, this is a CHICK book. Go read a Colin Harrison book.
reply
|
flag
*
Diane wrote: "John, this is a CHICK book. Go read a Colin Harrison book."If he writes as poorly as this woman, I think I'll take a pass on that. And what does "chick book" mean, exactly? To begin with, you don't grow olives on a farm. They grow on trees so you would call it an orchard (verger in French), don't you agree? I didn't learn anything about life in France from this book. They only reason I read it was that I saw other people reading it back when I lived in Seattle. Don't blame them, Seattle people read everything and anything. This is not a good travel book.
To be pedantic, a collection of olives trees is generally called a grove, not an orchard. The same is true of orange and lemon trees. - But I agree, there is no room for purple prose in modern writing.

