I really really wanted to give this book a 4, because I LOVE Margie Palatini's books!!! But I don't know... I've sat on this for about a month stewing. I didn't know if it was my mood or what, but I wasn't that impressed with it when I read it the first time. It is definitely cute and clever, and I know the kids will read it, but it's simply not as memorable as Bedhead or Piggie Pie or the Bad Boys!