♥ Sarah ♥'s Reviews > The Fiery Cross

The Fiery Cross by Diana Gabaldon
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Nov 07, 11

bookshelves: characters-scots-highlanders, genre-sci-fi, time-travel, audiobooks, genre-historical-romance, own
Read from September 20 to October 27, 2011

I think if you've gotten to book five in the Outlander series, then it's pretty much a given that you're a fan. Don't get me wrong, the books are good. But they're so long that there's no way a non-fan would've gotten this far. They would've fallen off the wagon long ago. Because each book averages between 900-1500 pages (paperback) then five books could really be translated to more like ten or fifteen books by normal book-length standards.

So although I'm obviously a fan because I have gotten this far in the series, this book was a pretty big disappointment and quite easily the weakest in the series so far. Anyone who's read anything by Diana Gabaldon could tell you that she loves her details. She loves to tell us each and every tidbit -- right down to who's on the rag and when boobie milk is leaking and uncomfortable. Does she go a bit far on the details? Some die-hard fans would argue that no, absolutely not; everything she writes is gold and should be read and devoured and read again. Although I am still a fan of this series, I really have to disagree. I can understand how some details would advance the plot or add to the personalities of the characters. But Gabaldon takes it a bit too far. We really do not need to know every single detail and if she edited out some of the more mundane and unnecessary details then these books could easily be hundreds of pages shorter, and probably a hell of a lot more enjoyable.

I decided to read this as an audiobook because I have a job where I am able to listen to audio while working and can still catch everything I'm listening to. Because I was disappointed in Drums of Autumn as well, I decided to go that route. So as far as the narration goes, Davina Porter is a flipping genius narrator. She is so good at creating different and unique voices for each character, no matter the accent, language, or gender. Even the men sound fantastic in this. She could seriously have 10 different people in a conversation at once, and I would be able to tell who was who. It's pretty crazy. I haven't listened to a ton of audiobooks, but this was by far the highest quality one I've ever listened to. She's a really fantastic narrator and for that reason (as well as the absurd book length of these books) I will probably continue this series only as audio.

Despite the book being so darn long, really not much happened. I know that sounds insane and impossible. But I would say probably three major things happened in this book and they were very spread out. So in between those three things, mostly what we get is a day-to-day life of the Fraser's. Fun. Even though I love these characters, I really don't care about a lot of this. I want to jump into their lives when exciting things are happening as opposed to when they're cooking dinner for ten pages or changing diapers and breastfeeding for twenty. The stuff that happens in this book is just normal every-day (for the year 1771) stuff and is not exciting in the least to read about, or listen to in this case.

Another thing that is really dragging these down for me is Brianna. I really, really dislike her. She is the ultimate b-word. To the extreme. She is so full of herself and whatever is going on with her. She argues constantly and has the shortest fuse imaginable. I can't tell you how many times even Claire pointed out that "Brianna was on-edge today" and made some excuse for it on her behalf. Why are we making excuses for this woman who behaves like a child the majority of the time? She is extremely annoying and everytime we're forced into her perspective I want to tear my hair out. She's just...ahh! On top of all that, she doesn't deserve Roger at all. I do not understand what he sees in her. She's totally cruel to him all the time and he's a sweet man who doesn't deserve it. In some ways he needs to step up to the plate and take the lead a bit in their relationship, but at the same time she would probably just beat him up if he did.

But aside from the things I didn't like I am still very much attached to the characters (Jamie and Claire especially) and the story overall so I can't justify giving it any less than three stars. I'm excited about one thing in particular that happened at the end of this one as well, but I won't say what to prevent spoilers. But it's pretty awesome! I hear that the next book, A Breath of Snow and Ashes, is very good so I will definitely continue the series. I'm not sure if I will right away or wait a little while though.

More of my reviews at I'm Loving ♥ Books.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Fiery Cross.
sign in »

Reading Progress

09/24/2011 page 195
20.0% "Loving this audiobook. The story is a bit drawn out, but that's a given with Outlander books really. However, Davina Porter is an amazing narrator. Even the guy voices sound awesome! Loving it. :)"
09/25/2011 page 257
26.0% "Off on the road finally! This is when the best stuff happens. Can't wait! :)"
09/27/2011 page 312
32.0% "It's crazy how "Mr. Beardsley" suspiciously resembles the old Bluebeard tale in a lot of ways. Hmm....Also, seriously LOVING this audiobook. I wish I did these all in audio. I forgot how much humor was in these. lol"
09/28/2011 page 358
37.0% "Gah! Brianna is such a bitch all the time. I really dislike her character..."
09/29/2011 page 434
44.0% "I SO still love my Jamie. He's just...*sigh* and he's so cute when he talks about things, like the wiggly little sperm and such. lol" 7 comments
10/15/2011 page 929
69.0% "Nothing's happening! Seriously...a couple big things have happened, but not much really for this far into the book already..."
10/23/2011 page 1267
94.0% "Almost done...almost."
show 5 hidden updates…

Comments (showing 1-3 of 3) (3 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

♥ Sarah ♥ Going to try the audiobook for this. 10+ hours! Wowza. But...I can listen to it when I have to work! :) I have the regular book checked out too though so maybe I'll read when I feel like reading and listen when I don't have time to read. Anyone else ever done that?

message 2: by Dija (new) - added it

Dija I replied to your comment on my review before reading this update, but I'm so glad we're united in our hatred for Brianna, LOL!

♥ Sarah ♥ lol Yes! We are sooo in agreeance there! I don't know how anyone can like her. lol

back to top