Goodreads | Camie's review

Camie's review

[close]

blog this review

Copy/paste the text below into your blog.

<a href="http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2156.Persuasion?utm_medium=api&amp;utm_source=blog_review" style="float: left; padding-right: 20px"><img alt="Persuasion" border="0" src="http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1160527159m/2156.jpg" /></a> <a href="http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2156.Persuasion?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_review">Persuasion</a> by <a href="http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/1265.Jane_Austen">Jane Austen</a> 
 <a href="http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/6325105?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_review"><h3>My review</h3></a>
 rating: 3 of 5 stars Jane Austen is always a good experience for me. And Persuasion has been no exception. However, I do not believe that this book can stand in the same class as her other masterpieces. Although intriguing, much less intriguing; witty, but not as witty as expected. In my mind, the bar is set very high for Miss Austen, as I have seen what delights she is capable of. This is not Jane Austen at her best. 
 
 Anne is a good girl, an obedient daughter, and, let’s face it, a boring, backbone-less character. Next to her silly siblings and friends, certainly we like her the best, but if there’d been an Elizabeth Bennett among the party. . . Anne wouldn’t have had a fighting chance at “favorite character.” But, she is not without some virtue. There’s nothing worse than thwarted love for the sake of duty, followed by burning, torturing regret. Anne carries this regretful spirit and suppression with dignity. She is not happy, but she’s not sad—she’s empty. Nothing in her life makes sense, and she doesn’t fight it. She’s hopeful, yet consigned. When her lost love returns and shows interest in another—a younger, livelier, more beautiful woman—Anne retreats and hides her secret longing. She doesn’t let the feeling overwhelm her and pushes forward, no matter how much her heart fights against it. Her face is perfect serenity, while her heart aches with pain. Sufficeth to say, though she bears her cross without complaint, she will not be so easily persuaded again. Endurance is the theme, perhaps too well driven home. She has this side to her, but it is the only side we see or know about. And her Captain Wentworth is equally as dull, if not more so. 
 
 Really, I am being too severe. Overall, I loved the book (How could I not, I ask you, as an Austin fan?), with its flaws—and what I consider weakly developed characters. The story is still compelling, and we are still waiting on hold every moment to see if Wentworth will really ignore her and move on with his life with someone new, or if he’ll come back to the woman he once loved so well. Perhaps if Austen has been permitted to stay on earth a little longer, she would’ve had time to smooth out these problems. As it is, I would much rather have read this book than not.
 
 <a href="http://www.goodreads.com/review/list/87293?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_review">View all my reviews.</a>

Camie's review
rating:

Jane Austen is always a good experience for me. And Persuasion has been no exception. However, I do not believe that this book can stand in the same class as her other masterpieces. Although intriguing, much less intriguing; witty, but not as witty as expected. In my mind, the bar is set very high for Miss Austen, as I have seen what delights she is capable of. This is not Jane Austen at her best.

Anne is a good girl, an obedient daughter, and, let’s face it, a boring, backbone-less character. Next to her silly siblings and friends, certainly we like her the best, but if there’d been an Elizabeth Bennett among the party. . . Anne wouldn’t have had a fighting chance at “favorite character.” But, she is not without some virtue. There’s nothing worse than thwarted love for the sake of duty, followed by burning, torturing regret. Anne carries this regretful spirit and suppression with dignity. She is not happy, but she’s not sad—she’s empty. Nothing in her lif...more Jane Austen is always a good experience for me. And Persuasion has been no exception. However, I do not believe that this book can stand in the same class as her other masterpieces. Although intriguing, much less intriguing; witty, but not as witty as expected. In my mind, the bar is set very high for Miss Austen, as I have seen what delights she is capable of. This is not Jane Austen at her best.

Anne is a good girl, an obedient daughter, and, let’s face it, a boring, backbone-less character. Next to her silly siblings and friends, certainly we like her the best, but if there’d been an Elizabeth Bennett among the party. . . Anne wouldn’t have had a fighting chance at “favorite character.” But, she is not without some virtue. There’s nothing worse than thwarted love for the sake of duty, followed by burning, torturing regret. Anne carries this regretful spirit and suppression with dignity. She is not happy, but she’s not sad—she’s empty. Nothing in her life makes sense, and she doesn’t fight it. She’s hopeful, yet consigned. When her lost love returns and shows interest in another—a younger, livelier, more beautiful woman—Anne retreats and hides her secret longing. She doesn’t let the feeling overwhelm her and pushes forward, no matter how much her heart fights against it. Her face is perfect serenity, while her heart aches with pain. Sufficeth to say, though she bears her cross without complaint, she will not be so easily persuaded again. Endurance is the theme, perhaps too well driven home. She has this side to her, but it is the only side we see or know about. And her Captain Wentworth is equally as dull, if not more so.

Really, I am being too severe. Overall, I loved the book (How could I not, I ask you, as an Austin fan?), with its flaws—and what I consider weakly developed characters. The story is still compelling, and we are still waiting on hold every moment to see if Wentworth will really ignore her and move on with his life with someone new, or if he’ll come back to the woman he once loved so well. Perhaps if Austen has been permitted to stay on earth a little longer, she would’ve had time to smooth out these problems. As it is, I would much rather have read this book than not.
...less

Like this review? yes (1 person liked it) flag

comments (showing 1-2 of 2)

newest »

date

message 1: by Nancy

09/18/2007 04:33PM

Speaking as a spinster, this book was for me a gentle and slightly ironic expression of hope. I think it deserves more than three stars.