Goodreads | Maggie's review

Maggie's review

Eragon (Inheritance) - Eragon Book 1
by Christopher Paolini

[close]

blog this review

Copy/paste the text below into your blog.

<a href="http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/113436.Eragon_Eragon_Book_1?utm_medium=api&amp;utm_source=blog_review" style="float: left; padding-right: 20px"><img alt="Eragon (Inheritance) - Eragon Book 1" border="0" src="http://s3.amazonaws.com/photo.goodreads.com/books/1171677619m/113436.jpg" /></a> <a href="http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/113436.Eragon_Eragon_Book_1?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_review">Eragon - Eragon Book 1</a> by <a href="http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/8349.Christopher_Paolini">Christopher Paolini</a> 
 <a href="http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/5202386?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_review"><h3>My review</h3></a>
 rating: 3 of 5 stars I am not going to go into how this book is or is not better or different than the movie. Frankly, I don't want to get into it. 
 Basically, I read this on a friend's suggestion. Usually I stray away from the 'young adult' section, if only the reputation (perhaps an innacurate one) of churning out chliche fantasy novels that seem to be more suited towards making a quick prophet than creating a work of artistry. In many ways, Eragon does not stray from the common concept of dragons, elves, and magic, as do many fantasy novels. At the time I read it, I became engrossed with, although it is, quite plainly, nothing that new. Ofcourse many books, for better or worse, introduce no new creatures beyond the familiar territory of mythical beasts and beings, and Eragon is no exception. 
 The reason I give it an average rating is because the story is interesting enough to follow through. Whether it be witches, ghosts, or dragons, all pre-conceived notions, writers must still create their own laws and worlds in wich these beings must reside, and Paolini has done so with much care. Although it may still not be far off his predecessors' trails, he has created a believable world along with it's residents. 
 As this is only the first of three, I can't very well review this book's plot as a whole. On it's own, it lacks a deffinitive beggining, middle, and end. The climax did not reach as far as it could have and more development of characters and notions would be needed. However, if you look at it as only the beggining of a larger story, it seems to fit perfectly. After reading the second book, I must say that the word 'trilogy' fits these perfectly. Not a series of stories concerning the same character(s), nor seperate journeys joining to form a single quest. It is a single story that just happens to be of a length, more conveniently spread through-out three installments. As the third book is not yet available at the time I wright this, I cannot say if the plot ammounts to as much as it seems or if Paolini will pull off something extrordinarily different. 
 I can however say, after reading the second book, that the writer is improving, as he is still not fully developed, and, if properly nertuered, will become something much greater. As a first work, I'd say that he has potential, but it has not been fully realized. He is still young and can reach greater heights. This is proven by the pure progress he has made between the first and second books. In my opinion, the second book is better. Ofcourse, as being the middle of a story, ofcourse it will be, by default, more exciting as it reaches it's climax.
 In closing, I wouldn't hesitate in reccomending this book to the reader hoping to be introduced into the world of fantasy books. However, for the hard core fantasy fan, I think this series is a bit too predictable. It is the norm among fantasy tales, although I cannot compare how it stands ount against them in other respects. This is not a book that will pull at you to continue reading it after you set it down, but is entertaining none the less, although I'm sure many would disagree to what extent. 
 <a href="http://www.goodreads.com/review/list/315010?utm_medium=api&utm_source=blog_review">View all my reviews.</a>

Maggie's review
rating:
recommended for: Readers interesed in exploring the fantasy genre

I am not going to go into how this book is or is not better or different than the movie. Frankly, I don't want to get into it.
Basically, I read this on a friend's suggestion. Usually I stray away from the 'young adult' section, if only the reputation (perhaps an innacurate one) of churning out chliche fantasy novels that seem to be more suited towards making a quick prophet than creating a work of artistry. In many ways, Eragon does not stray from the common concept of dragons, elves, and magic, as do many fantasy novels. At the time I read it, I became engrossed with, although it is, quite plainly, nothing that new. Ofcourse many books, for better or worse, introduce no new creatures beyond the familiar territory of mythical beasts and beings, and Eragon is no exception.
The reason I give it an average rating is because the story is interesting enough to follow through. Whether it be witches, ghosts, or dragons, all pre-conceived notions, writers must still...more I am not going to go into how this book is or is not better or different than the movie. Frankly, I don't want to get into it.
Basically, I read this on a friend's suggestion. Usually I stray away from the 'young adult' section, if only the reputation (perhaps an innacurate one) of churning out chliche fantasy novels that seem to be more suited towards making a quick prophet than creating a work of artistry. In many ways, Eragon does not stray from the common concept of dragons, elves, and magic, as do many fantasy novels. At the time I read it, I became engrossed with, although it is, quite plainly, nothing that new. Ofcourse many books, for better or worse, introduce no new creatures beyond the familiar territory of mythical beasts and beings, and Eragon is no exception.
The reason I give it an average rating is because the story is interesting enough to follow through. Whether it be witches, ghosts, or dragons, all pre-conceived notions, writers must still create their own laws and worlds in wich these beings must reside, and Paolini has done so with much care. Although it may still not be far off his predecessors' trails, he has created a believable world along with it's residents.
As this is only the first of three, I can't very well review this book's plot as a whole. On it's own, it lacks a deffinitive beggining, middle, and end. The climax did not reach as far as it could have and more development of characters and notions would be needed. However, if you look at it as only the beggining of a larger story, it seems to fit perfectly. After reading the second book, I must say that the word 'trilogy' fits these perfectly. Not a series of stories concerning the same character(s), nor seperate journeys joining to form a single quest. It is a single story that just happens to be of a length, more conveniently spread through-out three installments. As the third book is not yet available at the time I wright this, I cannot say if the plot ammounts to as much as it seems or if Paolini will pull off something extrordinarily different.
I can however say, after reading the second book, that the writer is improving, as he is still not fully developed, and, if properly nertuered, will become something much greater. As a first work, I'd say that he has potential, but it has not been fully realized. He is still young and can reach greater heights. This is proven by the pure progress he has made between the first and second books. In my opinion, the second book is better. Ofcourse, as being the middle of a story, ofcourse it will be, by default, more exciting as it reaches it's climax.
In closing, I wouldn't hesitate in reccomending this book to the reader hoping to be introduced into the world of fantasy books. However, for the hard core fantasy fan, I think this series is a bit too predictable. It is the norm among fantasy tales, although I cannot compare how it stands ount against them in other respects. This is not a book that will pull at you to continue reading it after you set it down, but is entertaining none the less, although I'm sure many would disagree to what extent. ...less

Like this review? yes (1 person liked it) flag

comments (showing 1-3 of 3)

newest »

date

message 1: by Duke689

10/08/2007 08:02PM

oooooo...
thanks for da pictures....
ramai ker akravatorians yg maen mende nih..??