J's Reviews > The Blind Assassin
The Blind Assassin
by Margaret Atwood (Goodreads Author)
by Margaret Atwood (Goodreads Author)
I’ve spent the last few days listening to opera. Purcell’s Dido and Aeneas – LOUD. Well, not just listening. I sing. My children beg for someone to make it stop, but Margaret Atwood’s to blame.
When I am laid, am layyy-ed in earth… Remember meee. Reeemember meeee. But, ahhh-ahh-ah, forget my fate… Remember me. But, ah, forget my fate.
It started like this:
This is the life story of Iris Chase Griffen as she would tell it to her estranged granddaughter, conversational but in letter form. (Because they’re estranged. Pay attention please. This is the easy part.) In this first of three overlapping stories people are not always what they seem. At least Iris isn’t. There’s the persona of the complacent child, the granddaughter of…, the daughter of…, the wife of…, the sister of… and then there’s Iris herself. She’s wry. She made me laugh. There’s something else you should know about Iris though. The people around her tend to die dramatically. Murders? Suicides? She’s like the Greek goddess of the same name, sent to do the job of death and set souls free. Murder? Suicide? It’s hard to tell the difference.
Then there’s the story-within-a-story. Her sister Laura’s novel, also titled The Blind Assassin, follows the love affair of a married society woman and a pulp fiction writer on the run. Their meetings invariably include sex and a story. Yes, I know. You think that’s wonderful. So do I. The story he improvises for her is pure fantasy; an escape. Like their relationship, like sex, like death.
It’s also the story-within-a-story-within-a-story. Sci-fi packed with zombie women and spaceships and lizard men in flammable shorts, invented by the lovers and mirroring… what? Society? Themselves? An assassin made blind by unconscionable child labor is tasked with killing a sacrificial maiden made mute to silence her protests. The two, so abused, find solace in one another. They find love. The true identities of this inner story’s blind assassin and mute sacrifice seem obvious, but nothing is only what it appears on the surface. Hold on to that thought. In sorting the classical references and symbolism I begin to feel I’m following the spiral of a nautilus ever further in. I’m dizzy. The myth of Dido and Aeneas is central, with Iris to cut the golden cord binding Dido’s soul to her body. Or is she Dido, awaiting another Iris to do the same for her? And what of her sister’s novel? Is she the sacrificed maiden? Yes. Is she the assassin? Yes. Is she mute? Blinded? Yes and yes. Here the whole story spins back out for me. I can find a way to pin those labels on almost every character at some point in the book. The vertigo is back.
I ignored the quotes at the beginning of the book. I generally do. But look what I found when I went back and read them at the end. Three epigraphs, three themes: blinded children left to sing the songs of those that don’t survive, death as escape, the power of words. Three themes, three nested stories, three suicides, three love triangles… I’m reminded of the ancient symbol of three interlocking spirals. A triskele.
But maybe I’m reading too much into the book. Maybe it’s just a painting of a woman’s life. Two sisters surrounded by dark shadows of tragedy and the historic objectification of women, a love affair in bright colors to draw the eye away, the negative space of death to rest in. In short, life.
Turn the music back up, please. I feel an aria coming on.
When I am laid, am layyy-ed in earth… Remember meee. Reeemember meeee. But, ahhh-ahh-ah, forget my fate… Remember me. But, ah, forget my fate.
It started like this:
This is the life story of Iris Chase Griffen as she would tell it to her estranged granddaughter, conversational but in letter form. (Because they’re estranged. Pay attention please. This is the easy part.) In this first of three overlapping stories people are not always what they seem. At least Iris isn’t. There’s the persona of the complacent child, the granddaughter of…, the daughter of…, the wife of…, the sister of… and then there’s Iris herself. She’s wry. She made me laugh. There’s something else you should know about Iris though. The people around her tend to die dramatically. Murders? Suicides? She’s like the Greek goddess of the same name, sent to do the job of death and set souls free. Murder? Suicide? It’s hard to tell the difference.
Then there’s the story-within-a-story. Her sister Laura’s novel, also titled The Blind Assassin, follows the love affair of a married society woman and a pulp fiction writer on the run. Their meetings invariably include sex and a story. Yes, I know. You think that’s wonderful. So do I. The story he improvises for her is pure fantasy; an escape. Like their relationship, like sex, like death.
It’s also the story-within-a-story-within-a-story. Sci-fi packed with zombie women and spaceships and lizard men in flammable shorts, invented by the lovers and mirroring… what? Society? Themselves? An assassin made blind by unconscionable child labor is tasked with killing a sacrificial maiden made mute to silence her protests. The two, so abused, find solace in one another. They find love. The true identities of this inner story’s blind assassin and mute sacrifice seem obvious, but nothing is only what it appears on the surface. Hold on to that thought. In sorting the classical references and symbolism I begin to feel I’m following the spiral of a nautilus ever further in. I’m dizzy. The myth of Dido and Aeneas is central, with Iris to cut the golden cord binding Dido’s soul to her body. Or is she Dido, awaiting another Iris to do the same for her? And what of her sister’s novel? Is she the sacrificed maiden? Yes. Is she the assassin? Yes. Is she mute? Blinded? Yes and yes. Here the whole story spins back out for me. I can find a way to pin those labels on almost every character at some point in the book. The vertigo is back.
I ignored the quotes at the beginning of the book. I generally do. But look what I found when I went back and read them at the end. Three epigraphs, three themes: blinded children left to sing the songs of those that don’t survive, death as escape, the power of words. Three themes, three nested stories, three suicides, three love triangles… I’m reminded of the ancient symbol of three interlocking spirals. A triskele.
But maybe I’m reading too much into the book. Maybe it’s just a painting of a woman’s life. Two sisters surrounded by dark shadows of tragedy and the historic objectification of women, a love affair in bright colors to draw the eye away, the negative space of death to rest in. In short, life.
Turn the music back up, please. I feel an aria coming on.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Blind Assassin.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-19 of 19) (19 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Kim
(new)
Jul 09, 2009 12:06pm
I'm not exactly sure what I just read, but I liked it. :)
reply
|
flag
*
I haven't read any Atwood! I own The Handmaid's Tale and The Robber Bride (shout out to Amanda, who gave it to me!), but the time hasn't ever seemed right. Someday...
This review was great, by the way!
This review was great, by the way!
Your review took my back to my Purcell days. Now I shall be singing all the way to the store and back.When in the proper frame of gloom, try these too:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DRt9T_...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-YUTk...
The second one is from the ballad of baby doe. She is supposed to jump into the matchless mine after the song but in reality Baby Doe died penniless and alone, found later frozen under some newspapers.
Ah, grief.
This is my favorite singer of When I am Laid in Earth, as she is much clearer and accurate than even my usual favorite Leontyne Price. Emma Kirkby.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tAnQQ4...
I love Purcell, especially his trumpet works. Loud is good,but in my case the preference is for Don Giovanni or the B-minor Mass. For gloom, I prefer Mozart's Requiem. Very nice review.
"But maybe I’m reading too much into the book."You aren't -- this is Atwood at her finest. Brilliant review. Thank you for it...I must go back and re-read this.
Lovely review, but I thought the outer shell of story in this book was its weakest point - I so wanted more of the sci-fi, the fictional world.It was also appallingly edited. The last 150 pages not even properly proofread - constantly tripping over the physical text is so annoying. I also thought it needed to be tighter - but this is the problem with really famous writers...who's going to tell them that?
If I was Margaret Atwood I would have KILLED the publisher. (I read it in hardback - perhaps later editions corrected the proofing fault).
Eric_W wrote: "I love Purcell, especially his trumpet works. Loud is good,but in my case the preference is for Don Giovanni or the B-minor Mass. For gloom, I prefer Mozart's Requiem. Very nice review."Purcell has some stinkers. I had to sing Thrice Happy Lovers once and it was crap on a stick. Glazed. But Music for a While is lovely.
Mozart's Lacrimosa is a fave.
Jen wrote: "Eric_W wrote: "I love Purcell, especially his trumpet works. Loud is good,but in my case the preference is for Don Giovanni or the B-minor Mass. For gloom, I prefer Mozart's Requiem. Very nice revi..."If you are not familiar with the Faure Requiem, run, I mean run, and get a copy or download from Amazon as an MP3, or better yet I'll send you a copy.
Thanks, everyone!I didn't notice the poor proofreading Anna mentioned so maybe it was cleaned up for the paperback. I agree though; it's distracting to have to think about the text itself.
I like Mozart. I don't know why, Choupette. Sentimental, I guess. He's the only composer whose house I've been to.
You just don't understand, Choupette. When I was 10 (in the midst of a prolonged illness), I would often listen to the piano concertos on endless repeat...






