OK, I'm a sucker for an Ender story. I really liked this one; although, the original two are still the best. This basically takes the last few pages of Ender's Game and expands them into a full story. I liked seeing what happened in more detail at the end, just because I liked the story so much. However, I found more meaning and promise in the first two. If you like Ender and Valentine, you should be relatively happy.