Andrew Benedict-Nelson's Reviews > The Dreams Our Stuff is Made Of: How Science Fiction Conquered the World

The Dreams Our Stuff is Made Of by Thomas M. Disch
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Apr 12, 09

Read in April, 2009

Really 3.5 stars. I don't know if I've ever read a critical work on science fiction before, so that in itself is refreshing. At first I thought Disch would just be another fanboy set out to prove that SF is Important with a capital I. Instead, he merely takes it seriously, treating it as a real literary genre while also acknowledging its limitations (for example, he explores the real implications of the old joke about the golden age of science fiction being 15).

I was impressed by his efforts to find a literary pedigree for SF that doesn't over-reach; he comes to the conclusion that the true ancestor of the genre is Edgar Allan Poe, which makes one think about the genre in a different way. He also does a good job of parsing the political meanings in various SF books and films without reducing them to allegories. But a few chapters seemed dated (the book is a little over 10 years old now) or disappointing. I was left cold by his analysis of "SF as religion" because it seemed entirely negative -- to me, it seems as if the wonder evoked by SF has to be a part of any plausible religion.

That lack of wonder would in fact be my main beef with Disch. Though I know it is a feeling he must surely share -- he's the guy who wrote The Brave Little Toaster, after all -- it doesn't seem like an analytical lens he employed in this volume. Therefore, certain writers who to me seem essential, like Ray Bradbury, are discussed as having achieved their successes through a perpetual adolescence. There is some truth to this, but simply because much of Bradbury's work forces us to adopt a childlike perspective doesn't mean he doesn't have anything interesting to say.

Overall, this is a book I enjoyed and learned a lot from, but I'm not sure it helped me better understand what I like about SF and what I don't.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Dreams Our Stuff is Made Of.
sign in »

No comments have been added yet.