Juhina's Reviews > Broken

Broken by A.E. Rought
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4311208
's review
Jan 15, 13

bookshelves: ebook, review-books, netgalley
Read from December 21, 2012 to January 05, 2013

I am very well acquainted with Mary Shelly's Frankenstein novel. It was a requirement reading that I resisted at the beginning but then devoured. So to say I was excited to read a modern retelling of it is accurate. The synopsis doesn't even tell you much other than hinting on who Frankenstein's creation is and who he was reconstructed from. However I was both impressed by the direction the plot took but also disappointed by how the plot itself was handled. I might not be making much sense but to say it simply, Broken had potential, but towards the end my disappointment took over.

The story revolves around Emma Gentry and the loss of her boyfriend Daniel. Emma really mourns him to the point that she spends everyday after school at the cemetery where she wished Daniel was buried (his parents cremated him). However, Alex Franks comes along and confuses Emma. I liked that she didn't feel guilty about liking someone else but she still remembers Daniel whenever she is with Alex because somehow Alex knows things about her that only Daniel knew. I found that to be a bit creepy and added to the mystery of the novel. However then the romance blooms and the cheesy texts between them that I would rather have not read were written. We also encounter Alex's dad who is supposedly a doctor but I would rather suffer through any sickness than go to him. We also have Daniel's best friend who can't seem to stop harassing Emma, because they are not seniors but kids who show their feelings towards each other by being mean *rolls eyes*. I honestly couldn't stand the dad, the best friend and the cheesy romance, but I did like Alex, Emma, and her best friend.

A pet peeve of mine whenever I read a novel is the amount of detail an author puts in describing inanimate objects. I just tend to skip these unimportant paragraphs that take me away from the novel. The problem is that Broken had a lot of those; I wanted more dialogue but got more repetitive contemplation and worry from Emma. The mystery gets unraveled way too late in the story and by then I have honestly lost my interest and just wanted the story to end. The mystery was well planned but the execution took some of the enjoyment level out of it.
3 likes · likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Broken.
sign in »

Reading Progress

12/28/2012 page 20
5.0% 1 comment
show 4 hidden updates…

Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Sam (last edited Jan 15, 2013 08:46AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Sam The mystery surrounding Alex wasn't really a mystery... I wish it hadn't been treated as such for so long throughout this. I felt like nothing significant happened at all. Sorry it didn't work for you either. But great review!


Juhina Sam wrote: "The mystery surrounding Alex wasn't really a mystery... I wish it hadn't been treated as such for so long throughout this. I felt like nothing significant happened at all. Sorry it didn't work for ..."

I get what you mean, but at the beginning i thought it was a bit creepy and wanted to find out how the daniel/alex situation thing works out.

but yea, not that great


message 3: by Sam (new) - rated it 2 stars

Sam Oh yes, at the beginning it worked well. I agree with that! But like you said, it wasn't addressed until far too late. Which made a lot of the middle completely unnecessary for me...


Juhina Sam wrote: "Oh yes, at the beginning it worked well. I agree with that! But like you said, it wasn't addressed until far too late. Which made a lot of the middle completely unnecessary for me..."

ugh yes, i know, and it was a rather long book too!!


back to top