Collin's Reviews > A Feast for Crows

A Feast for Crows by George R.R. Martin
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
243560
's review
Feb 29, 08

bookshelves: fantasysci-fi
Recommended for: Completists
Read in October, 2006

I feel like giving this book 3 stars is being harsh to my man, George Martin, but I'm trying to separate the truly great books in this series from the merely good ones.

Bottom line: fans of the series waited too long for this and therefore were in a position of being impossible to please once this finally came out. This coupled with the facts that numerous spoiler chapters had been available online for years and that George cut his original manuscript in 2 to produce this and the subsequent (as of now, published) volume serves to diminish the stature of "A Feast For Crows" in the context of the whole series.

Still, as its been said elsewhere, Bad George is still better than Excellent Crap. Since I am a completist I was going to love this book no matter what, and I do, but to the more casual fan this will definitely seem like a weak effort, and I think there's justice to this point of view.

The writing here feels uneven to me -- so much time in the real world has passed that I feel like George's writing style has actually changed here. His characters begin using terms that they never used before in the preceeding books ("nuncle" and "coz", in particular). There's also an egregious amount of "not giving a groat" here. I'd hate to be a groat merchant in Westeros at this point. What the hell IS a groat?

The interesting point of view structure of the previous books has been salted with an overabundance of "prologue" chapters that break with the structural traditions that George has already established. Enough with the Prologues! We're under siege here! Just give us one and hold on to some of that story telling goodness -- we already know you rule.

For fans, I think the Brienne chapters feel like wasted time, though Martin tells us that there were stories that needed to be told in "Feast" lest the whole tale would suffer (and I can only presume he includes the 'Brienne' bits in that proclamation). I will reserve judgment here and wait to see.

Also, the fact that only half the POVs (points of view) are represented in "Feast" leaves many fans cold. For myself, I needed me some more Tyrion and I didn't get it here.

I believe once the remaining books are published, the profile of this book may improve. But this is clearly well-seasoned asparagus next to "A Storm of Swords'" filet mignon.
78 likes · likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Feast for Crows.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-8 of 8) (8 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Anniewin Agreed! I MISS TYRION! And Anya...


Ashley Phillips The "giving half a groat" saying pops up so much! And I do feel like this wasn't up to par with the other books. I am reading them all one after another right now and after the amazing ending of Storm of Swords, it's going by so slowly even though I'm over half-way through...


message 3: by Stacie (new) - added it

Stacie groat - HISTORICAL - any of the various medieval European coins, in particular an English silver coin worth four old pence, issued between 1351 and 1662


Adanna I am currently reading this, and I will agree that I am disappointed in this particular book thus far. But it will not deter me from finishing and from loving the entire series!


message 5: by Heather (new) - added it

Heather "But this is clearly well-seasoned asparagus next to 'A Storm of Swords' filet mignon." I don't think that could have been said any better. Great review!


Jeremy "A Storm of Swords" might be my all-time favorite novel ever. I suppose it would be hard to follow up what I would classify as damn near perfect, but I agree with you. It's could have been a better book.


message 7: by Cristina (new) - added it

Cristina Sacarea Very accurate review, couldn't have said it better myself.


Bitsy Griffin I'm having a hard time getting through this one. Missing Tyrion. Not enough Jon. Although I do like reading Jaime and Brienne. Cersie is such a bore. Hoping the next book gets back up to par. Knowing I'll need all this info later is keeping me going.


back to top