Renee's Reviews > The Shack: Where Tragedy Confronts Eternity

The Shack by Wm. Paul Young

by
91455
's review
Dec 31, 09

Read in November, 2008

Pure drivel. This book read like a Betty Crocker recipe gone bad: take one all-American Jesus lovin’/fearing family, add one unexplainable tragedy, mix with equal parts anger , guilt and sadness , bake for three weeks and get a bitter man who has turned his back on God. Alias, no need to give up, because God writes our hero a personalized note, and tells him to meet him in “the shack” (the place of his daughter’s murder), funny thing is, god is a black woman cooking pancakes in the kitchen who says “you can me god, Yahweh or just plain ol’ Jessie, I answer to all three”. Yes, I said pancakes….I could go on, but it’s just too easy. The lesson of power of forgiveness was demonstrated well, but no better than the Hallmark card I bought my boss when I spilled a whole bottle of red wine on his new suit…..

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Shack.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-34 of 34) (34 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Karima (new)

Karima You know.....I love a scathing review!


message 2: by Cm (new)

Cm Great review. I could not have said it better myself! I wasn't able to get past the halfway mark in this book because the GAG factor was just too overwhelming.


message 3: by Pam (new)

Pam I just started trying to read this book today, and I simply can't bear it. I find it a little frightening that so many people think it's so amazing. I came here mostly to see if I can find out what it's about without strugglign through all that drivel and excessively flowery description, but also to find the few other people who went, "wha?" at all the hoopla, ack!


Michele Perfect review! I'm stuck at the midway point and can't seem to force myself to return to finish it.


message 5: by Rose (new) - rated it 1 star

Rose I totally agree, couldn't get past page 40, absolutely horrible little book.
I think it's geared for a certain audience base.


Eric I have suffered several great sorrows in my life and this book really helped me face those awful times and deal with them, and face God again. I give it 5 stars just for that.


message 7: by Cm (last edited Feb 15, 2009 10:27am) (new)

Cm Eric wrote: "I have suffered several great sorrows in my life and this book really helped me face those awful times and deal with them, and face God again. I give it 5 stars just for that."

Hi Eric, I'm glad to hear this book helped you. I couldn't relate to the book at all. However, I can appreciate the author's efforts more after recently seeing him on Good Morning America. I think this book was his catharsis and the intention behind it was to help others come to grips with the difficult periods in their lives. I'm happy to hear you are at peace now and wish you the best in life.


message 8: by [deleted user] (new)

Indeed


Peter Steele Excuse me Renee. The word is "DRIVEL"


message 10: by Renee (new) - rated it 1 star

Renee Peter wrote: "Excuse me Renee. The word is "DRIVEL" "
Thanks Peter; I appreciate the edit. Happy New Year to you!



Peter Steele

Renee wrote: "Peter wrote: "Excuse me Renee. The word is "DRIVEL" "
Thanks Peter; I appreciate the edit. Happy New Year to you!
"


And to you and yours! I am a forgiving editor :-)




message 12: by Mick (new) - rated it 2 stars

Mick Great review! And superb analysis!


April I could not have said it better myself!!


Paula Davis-Olson I think you have a closed mind perspective. I got way more out of this book than my Betty Crocker book!


message 15: by Lori (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lori Rose I think this book is amazing because it really gives an eye opener to the possibilites on how we would feel if something like this would happen. We would doubt God, who wouldnt. I had a hard time getting through it as well but i hate not to finish a book. I agree with Paula, i got a lot out of it as well. it makes you think. Especailly if you have children.


message 16: by [deleted user] (last edited Jun 27, 2010 02:20pm) (new)

Well put! The whole premise angered me, and the description of the persons of the Holy Trinity was condescending and insulting to my intelligence. However, my sister told me that this book changed her life. Go figure.


message 17: by U.L. (last edited Nov 04, 2010 11:10pm) (new) - rated it 1 star

U.L. Harper This is horrible writing. My girlfriend was crying because of how much it effected her and people in the office I work in said this book was simply fantastic. I'm just saying that the first 30 or so pages is friggin horrible. Some of the description reads like a text book and at this point most of the scenes are one demensional. Boring, seriously.


Margaret Perhaps the idea of God's love is what draws people to this book, to have it illustrated for them. However, the book gave me the creeps, there is something that feels like the undermining of our faith .. like telling people it's ok to be churchless, in fact that it might be preferable. And something else that I can't quite put my finger on. I'm all for the love of God, but sometimes this is the way true Christianity can be undermined.


message 19: by Savion (new)

Savion If your a true Christan you should not be reading and judging books and no not all people have to go to church to love god or whoever you have faith in.

Because you know what that is?
Idol Warship at it's core and also a small fee -_-.


message 20: by Renee (new) - rated it 1 star

Renee Savion wrote: "If your a true Christan you should not be reading and judging books and no not all people have to go to church to love god or whoever you have faith in.

Because you know what that is?
Idol Warshi..."

Thanks for taking the time to write Savion; my review is just my opinion, nothing more, nothing less! Have a good day. Renee


message 21: by U.L. (new) - rated it 1 star

U.L. Harper I'm going to say it one more time. The authorship in this book is bad in the first 30 pages. Maybe it's better after that, but it simply doesn't read well and therefore it's hard to follow. Nothing more than that.


message 22: by Fabia (new) - rated it 1 star

Fabia I totally agree


message 23: by Will (new) - rated it 5 stars

Will Robinson I diaagree:-(. I feel Mr. Young was trying to steer us away from our own philosophies about God. Simply put in the shack we get a picture of God in three persons. Jesus, holy spirit, God(love). Remember God is not a flesh human being but a spirit


Phyllis I agree -- The Shack is a boring and insulting book.


Rachel It has its ups and downs


Aleshia Robinson I'd like to introduce you to Alcatraz, a deeply troubled, teenage, tattoo artist on a spiritual quest to find God. www.lovegodandtattoos.com


message 27: by Lara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lara Thanks Aleshia! I'm going to add them to my "to read" list & check em out!!


message 28: by Vickie (new)

Vickie Porter I read the book mad I thought it was a page turner! I couldn't put it down. I think that God appeared as a woman because the father of the little girl who got murdered wouldn't talk to God. So by showing his self as a person in the flesh He was able to gain his trust and God was able to minister to him. It wasn't until the man's heart started changing that he was to see it was God. Then had a change of heart and was sorry he had slipped away from God in the first place. God lead him to the place his child was murdered so he could have some peace with in himself instead of hate.


message 29: by Amber (new)

Amber I am usually not too critical of books that are fiction especially if it has a good message. But this one... I have to agree with your review was a recipe gone bad. :/


message 30: by Brenda (new)

Brenda Diederich JD wrote: "If your a true Christan you should not be reading and judging books and no not all people have to go to church to love god or whoever you have faith in.

Because you know what that is?
Idol Warshi..."


Did you mean Idle Worship?!


Sharon Li "pure drivel" is the perfect way to describe this book!


message 32: by Michelle (new) - added it

Michelle ? Lies Not a good way to describe a book 2 a Christian like me


message 33: by Wilhemina (new) - added it

Wilhemina I thought I was the only one who did NOT like this book. I had high hopes, but I too feel it read like a Betty Crocker recipe gone bad, good analogy.


message 34: by Michelle (new) - added it

Michelle wat????????? i like da book. but i have no problem with u not liking it


back to top