Bryn Hammond's Reviews > Fathers and Crows

Fathers and Crows by William T. Vollmann

by
7224461
's review
Oct 15, 12

bookshelves: imagined-fiction
Read from August 10 to October 14, 2012

A documentary-novel on contacts between Savages and French (with English and Dutch) in Canada. It has an exhaustive feel, as if he's put in every contact - whether or not you'd pick them for a novel. He does dives into people's heads for a page here and there, but otherwise, these figures from the Jesuit records seem to be written with an external or objective hand... a bit like a closely-observed documentary, more than a novel. Canada itself, savage Canada, is as real as if filmed, and I, who skip description unless of people, never did. He keeps to two sentences at a time anyhow, as I'd have description, except when a metaphor for human mood or airier things - and his can be that.

There's merry torture - the Indian Nations' art and practice with each other, before they get to Jesuits. In spite of the culture clashes, the Black Crows and the Savages are often strikingly alike. Sorry to those concerned. The Savages have a Feast of the Dead, gruesome to French eyes, tenderly significant to themselves. The Jesuits' baptism - which they only perform on the nearly-dead, to prevent the wickedness of backsliding - has them hover over those at last gasp with a ghastly persistence, and to Savage eyes they are very unhealthily obsessed with death.

Given how rude they are by each other's standards of courtesy and decency, it's a wonder either understands an utterance from the other side. But the book ends with Canadians, who can now be neither - every Canadian has both, in his/her history, inside.

I wrote a lot in status updates. See them.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Fathers and Crows.
sign in »

Reading Progress

08/10/2012 page 39
4.0% "'it plodded and slouched across the cobblestones like a drunken king walking on his hands' 'her sleep was translucent like a sheet of dried seal-guts' '(I beg you not to think that the pages which already lie behind you are but fallen leaves of meaninglessness in an interminable forest of digressions... For already Savages, priests and harlots have slipped through our fingers, and it seems that we but grasp water..)'"
08/10/2012 page 72
7.0% "'..still more backtracking... you may if you desire simply turn to the last page of my book to gobble the denouement, although I must warn you that none of the people there have been introduced yet. - Still with me?' Don't worry, Mr. Vollman, I'm entranced. From the acknowledgements: 'My books don't tend to make much money...' That's a shame. Never mind."
08/11/2012 page 114
12.0% "at this stage it documents contacts, fictionalises the people, but with quotes and drawings and heavy use of source material, like both fic and non-fic. Anecdotes in titled sections a paragraph or three pages in size, easy to bite off."
08/20/2012 page 303
31.0% "Jesuits - fathers and crows: 'a cannonball came whistling toward Frere du Thet, who suddenly comprehended that death was going to strike him; death would nail him to himself so that he must become a Cross; and he exploded and died -
But he was not a martyr. Poor Frere du Thet!' 'the poor priest, drenched and salt-crusted like a crow in a salty rain'..I didn't expect to like Ignatius Loyola but I challenge you not to"
08/28/2012 page 400
40.0% "I may be odd in the head but I like the cartoon violence he does now and then. The Hiroquois meet an arquebus: 'and for return fire the Hiroquois shot greater than a puncheon's worth of blood from their exploding hearts...' Black humour, or a deadpan insensibility in ape of the participants themselves: two of his strategies for how to write about violence."
09/27/2012 page 526
53.0% "The last 120 pages is notes and glossaries, so my percentage is better than this"
10/05/2012 page 700
70.0% "Major. But stomach-turning lately. The 2nd half of this is much more like a novel than the 1st half. He has an odd documentary style. It has its power. And it has a physicality - it situates you there."

No comments have been added yet.