Material Witness is one of a series of mysteries set in an Amish community. The mystery and story line were well done. There was good suspense and action after the opening setting. The quilting theme was nicely woven into the story, providing the reader with an insight into the craft, art, and valuation of Amish work.

I was disappointed in one minor aspects of the book. The main character, Carrie's emotional reactions were a bit forced and didn't feel authentic. She was frightened one moment and in the next breath she claimed to be angry, although no action came of either emotion.

What I felt was an overwhelming success in the story was the portrayal of deeply held and lived values of the Amish people. Vannetta Chapman portrayed the heart of people who truly live the Christian law of love even for enemies, as well as real neighborly caring for and sharing in each other's needs, joys, and sorrows.