** spoiler alert **
OK, this was going so good for me that I thought I was going to declare it the read of the summer. And then the last 75 pages of the book it came to a screeching halt! The murder, what? I was not even sure what happened it was not described well and I thought Cathy had done it what? MUCH confusion and not a satisfying ending. I also found it 99% unlikely that John could truly have been the father, come on. Other than that it was a great read. I loved, loved the characters and the story. Just wish it could have ended different, not happy necessarily, just different.