Nichole ~~The Grey Lady~~'s Reviews > The Iron Wyrm Affair
The Iron Wyrm Affair (Bannon & Clare, #1)
by Lilith Saintcrow (Goodreads Author)
by Lilith Saintcrow (Goodreads Author)
I love Steampunk, so was excited to receive this copy for review. Reading the back copy, this seemed like the perfect book for me. The alternate history and the setting attracted me to this. This book had a lot of intriguing elements to it. I loved the concept of a "forensic sorceress". Some of her descriptions were very well done. Emma Bannon was a great strong female character.
But somewhere along the line it just all fell flat to me. I have been noticing that as Steampunk is becoming more popular the quality is beginning to suffer. This seems like a prime example. Authors are seeming so focused on the world building that either the plot or the characters suffer. With this book in particular, I had a real hard time warming up to any of the characters. Even Emma, who was clearly the best developed. I found the world building awkward and confusing at times. I had a real hard time caring about the plot or what was going on. In the end I had zero emotional investment in the book and just kept wanting it to be over.
A few pet peeves: everyone in this book kept getting pale. I understand this as a way for writers to show reactions, but seriously how realistic is that? I personally have rarely seen this in real life and in this book everyone is going pale everytime something mildly shocking happens.
One of the biggest pet peeves for me is when an alternate world is created and they change names just a little bit. London vs Londinium. Victoria vs Victrix. For some reason this really irritates me. It just seems pointless. I know your in London, I get that it is an alternate world. Don't try and invent a different name that sounds kind of the same. I can handle a different reality and it take place in a town called London. It seems insulting and ridiculous to the reader.
I guess I didn't have a lot of nice things to say about this book. It was a big disappointment and I won't be looking into the next installment
But somewhere along the line it just all fell flat to me. I have been noticing that as Steampunk is becoming more popular the quality is beginning to suffer. This seems like a prime example. Authors are seeming so focused on the world building that either the plot or the characters suffer. With this book in particular, I had a real hard time warming up to any of the characters. Even Emma, who was clearly the best developed. I found the world building awkward and confusing at times. I had a real hard time caring about the plot or what was going on. In the end I had zero emotional investment in the book and just kept wanting it to be over.
A few pet peeves: everyone in this book kept getting pale. I understand this as a way for writers to show reactions, but seriously how realistic is that? I personally have rarely seen this in real life and in this book everyone is going pale everytime something mildly shocking happens.
One of the biggest pet peeves for me is when an alternate world is created and they change names just a little bit. London vs Londinium. Victoria vs Victrix. For some reason this really irritates me. It just seems pointless. I know your in London, I get that it is an alternate world. Don't try and invent a different name that sounds kind of the same. I can handle a different reality and it take place in a town called London. It seems insulting and ridiculous to the reader.
I guess I didn't have a lot of nice things to say about this book. It was a big disappointment and I won't be looking into the next installment
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Iron Wyrm Affair.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 07/31/2012 | "Received an advanced review copy off of librarything.com. So excited cause I love Steampunk!" | |||
| 08/04/2012 | "I am struggling a bit with this one. It's been hard to get into." |
Comments (showing 1-8 of 8) (8 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Spuddie
(new)
Aug 06, 2012 05:26am
Have you read any of Cherie Priest's Clockwork Century series? It was my first venture into "steampunk" per se (if you don't count Jules Verne, LOL) and I really loved it!
reply
|
flag
*
Indeed! I just listened to Dreadnought last month and it also was awesome. I am not sure if all the books in the series feature the same characters, or if they're sort of loosely-tied-together stand-alones. Dreadnought featured the characters from Boneshaker only very peripherally at the end. But I've got the next three on my wish list and library list.
I hope to read more of the series. Do you use fictfact? I started using it to keep track of my series and realized that I considered myself to be "actively" reading about 130. Sheesh. No wonder I am so far behind on all of them! Anyway, Cherie Priest is a real good introduction to steampunk. Its becoming harder to find good ones.
Yes I am on FictFact, but I don't use it much. I have at least 130 series or more...most likely more. The one thing I don't like about it is it won't let you keep track of series you started and stopped reading for whatever reason. You have to "follow" them, or else they get removed from your list. I would like somewhere to keep track of those I tried and didn't like also...so I don't try them again by mistake. LOL
I need fictfact to keep track of everything for me. I love how I can put if I have read it or not. fantasic fiction is awesome to tell me the order, but I need help figuring out what I have and havent read. I agree though...I wish they had an "abandoned" series. Cause there are a few I have hanging out on my list that I really dont think I will be reading more of, but I dont quite want to unfollow them.
I actually have a *really really long* Word document where I keep track of what I've read in which series and what's up next. I do most of the editing on the document itself but I print a copy maybe twice a year and keep it on my bedside table--I keep notes on it about series I want to try, put big X's through ones I suddenly decide I can't stand anymore, etc. Very satisfying. LOL
