Otis Chandler's Reviews > Outliers: The Story of Success

Outliers by Malcolm Gladwell
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Oct 05, 09

bookshelves: business, nonfiction, self-improvement
Read in September, 2009 — I own a copy

A great book and worth the read, but like many Gladwellian books, it can be summed up easily. The basic point is that there is no such thing as a true outlier. Success, it seems, is due primarily to hard work and circumstance - brains play little part.

Gladwell went through several (fascinating) examples proving his thesis - people such as Bill Gates, Joe Flom at Skadden, Oppenheimer, some failed genius named Chris Langan. All of them had two things in common: they spent over 10,000 hours doing what they did, and they had fortunate circumstances that let them get ahead of everyone else. Bill Gates was smart, but so were lots of other geeks. He had the advantage of being 16 when the computing age came about, and being possibly the only 16 year old in the country with access to a computer - and he spent all his time on it. By the time he hit college he had well over 10,000 hours of computer time and was arguably one of the foremost experts in the country.

One of my favorite bits was the music study on page 39 that compared musicians, and "couldn't find any 'naturals'" - the skill of each musician at comparable amounts of practice was equal. It's kind of validating to hear this, as many of us have this feeling that there are naturally smarter people out there than us. But apparently this isn't true - and I think my personal experience agrees with this. The harder you work, the better you can do.

One other big takeaway was how circumstance can change things. The hockey league study and elementary school studies were fascinating and relevant. Basically kids that are in the older third of their class (or hockey league) have a natural advantage when they're really little. They are the kids who make all-star, and get extra coaching, and because of that they practice more and thus do become better by the time they are older. I was held back in pre-school so I was one of the oldest in my class, and I definitely think it helped me. Hmmm now can I plan my kids to be born to be the oldest?

2 likes • Likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Outliers.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

08/23/2009 page 40
12.94% "Love the 10,000 hour rule."
08/28/2009 page 159
51.46% "Great story of the history of skadden"
09/14/2009 page 242
78.32% "Fascinating: kids who study over summer vacation get much further along than those who don't. Let's get rid of it!" 2 comments

Comments (showing 1-8 of 8) (8 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Miriam Isn't it fabulous!? I'll have to send you WHAT THE DOG SAW which is a great compilation of his New Yorker pieces.

message 2: by kareem (new)

kareem are you enjoying this? i'm a sucker for gladwell stories but heard mediocre things about outliers.

Otis Chandler I heard mediocre things about it too - so I was pleasantly surprised to find that I really like it.

message 4: by kareem (new)

kareem nice... it's useful and/or practical, not just delightfull spun gladwellian stories?

Otis Chandler Well it is Gladwellian to be sure, but also very interesting.

message 6: by Michael (new)

Michael Economy " I was held back in pre-school"

You failed preschool? :D

Otis Chandler I did. Couldn't finger-paint for the life of me.

message 8: by MissJessie (new)

MissJessie How do I get my kids to be the oldest?

1. Find out what the cut off date is for admission in the school system you plan for them to attend.

2. Plan accordingly........

I was 2 weeks too old and consequently always the oldest. A great advantage.

On the other hand, my brother started kindergarten at 4, so graduated at 16 and also did very well. So perhaps it isn't so advantageous after all.

back to top