Jeff's Reviews > In the Woods

In the Woods by Tana French
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Nov 23, 08

Read in November, 2008

My friend Gio used many expletives to describe what I can only imagine to be frustration with this novel. Actually, all Gio offered were expletives--sans nouns and verbs--so I, of course, was very intrigued. Basically, Tana French delivers a police procedural set in present day, economically successful Ireland. I liked the characters. The lead, in particular, is flawed and frustrating; psychologically unable to move forward even as the reader roots for his success. There's also a great character in Cassie, the lone female member of the murder division on the Irish Police Force. The crime to be solved is theatrically gruesome, which is, I imagine, what bothered Gio. French, however, is less interested in the whodunit than she is in developing psychologically complex leads. I'm not sure she entirely succeeds, but I was compelled to finish nonetheless.
1 like · likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read In the Woods.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-5 of 5) (5 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by jo (new) - rated it 1 star

jo did i inspire you with my enthusiastic remarks, jeff?

Jeff yes we can . . . I mean yes you did

message 3: by jo (new) - rated it 1 star

jo *** SPOILERS ***

no, it wasn't the gruesomeness. it was the fact that the protagonist's original trauma is a humongous red herring and, ultimately, remains unresolved, thus proving a useless and, yes, deeply frustrating narrative sidetracking; it was his extremely annoying personality, including all the bullshit (there i go again) he unexplainedly gets away with; it was the endless detours into should-have-been-edited-outland; and, finally, it was the fact that the novel is built for a sequel. that always gets on my nerves. it's bad enough in films, but in a work of fiction with literary pretense? nah.

glad you enjoyed it, though!

Jeff well yeah, Rob's childhood trauma proved to be a bit too tidy (as did the mirroring of Adam/Peter/Jaime with Rob/Cassie/Sam), narratively speaking, but I didn't mind that it was unresolved (I didn't find him annoying as much as I wanted him to let go of the past in some small way, which is what I think the novel circles around). As for a sequel I don't see what you obviously see, but I don't think I would pick up a second helping.

message 5: by jo (new) - rated it 1 star

jo for the sequel, i meant to solution to the kids' kidnapping, and more about rob's psychological torment.

you're so sweet jeff. it makes total sense that you'd identify somewhat with poor wee rob. :-)

back to top