rameau's Reviews > Mayojen testamentti

Mayojen testamentti by Steve Alten
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4884555
Well, wasn't that a disappointment.

Some time ago--probably a year or two back--I saw a paperback copy of this book in the bookshop. I glanced at the blurb and thought interesting, but put it back and decided to look it up in the library. Aren't I glad I did.

It wasn't the sketchy science that I found unpalatable. I'm too lazy to look up the real numbers but I can smell circular mathematical reasoning when I stumble on it. By nature I'm an easy sell. Just put some effort into the storytelling, make sure your basic facts are straight, and I'll suspend disbelief long enough to breeze through the book and won't notice a thing. Of course once someone else points out the failures I'll happily join in on the lambasting.

And by put some effort into the storytelling I mean, have the characters act like the rational, slightly cynical but impossibly curious scientists they're supposed to be. I've seen actual physicists act like children at the face of some new exiting data--I felt it--and I wasn't even in position to understand what was so damn intoxicating about it.

Dominique did not in any way fit the mould. Usually that would be a good thing to say about a character, but not when she's supposed to be an abuse survivor dealing with her past by becoming a clinical psychologist. I could have understood a moment or two of weakness at the face of an emotional dilemma, but I could not tolerate her bawling at every single turn. Psychology is different from physics or archeology, but she's gone through the school and the moves. Unless she's bought every single test and article she's written for her professors, her first plan of attack towards Mick's hallucinations would be to verify the facts from independent sources. She did not. Any academic should know better and that the author would brush it aside so makes me doubt his qualifications.

Then again, I know nothing about sport medicine.

But I do know a thing or two about story telling.

The mixing of first and third person limited narratives didn't work. Having finished the book I can appreciate what the author was trying to do with Julius' journal entries, but it did not work. The beginning was too slow and bogged down by the numerology-would-be-archeology and choosing Dominique as the main character from whose point of view to introduce the alternative world, did not work. Failures in her characterisation prevented me from connecting with the story. Once the focus was shifted to Mick and the actual thriller part was embraced, I could see why people could--some would--like this very much.

I've already mentioned characterisation failures, but I've said nothing about the villains. Borgia is the most interesting character of the lot and he has some kind of background to justify his actions. However Foletta, Raymond, Groznyi, and every other nameless halfwit doesn't. I've only taken few basic courses but reading about these characters made me sincerely wish that Alten would invest in a few psychology course books help him write human beings and how they interact with others. Then again, if my guess about the sequel is correct, he didn't need to. Not that I'm in a hurry to find out.

The fact that this book was written over a decade ago shows. With some things Alten gets very close to today's technology but other things made me shake my head. As always the human factor distances his view of status quo from the reality. People die, people cheat, people get elected to office.

Also, I'm not convinced by his chosen method of intimidation. Somehow failing economy and the possibilities it creates with new world order(s) seems scarier than a nuclear holocaust. After all, I doubt I'd have to live through the latter considering my geographical location so close to St. Petersburg.

One last note. This was the last book I expected to read a bad romance in. I have read enough actual romances for that, I don't need it in my science fiction.
2 likes · likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Mayojen testamentti.
sign in »

Reading Progress

06/15/2012 page 18
4.0% "Technology. I can tell this book was written over a decade ago although the story takes place later this year."
06/15/2012 page 27
6.0% "Foletta told Mick about her that morning?"
06/15/2012 page 34
8.0% "O ye, of little faith."
06/15/2012 page 46
11.0% "Doctor-patient confidentiality doesn't exist for the criminally insane?"
06/16/2012 page 71
17.0% "This sounds like mathematical circular reasoning to me. Either that or numerology rules!"
06/16/2012 page 75
18.0% "Just how long does it take for a radio transmission sent from Pluto to reach Earth? Somehow ten and half an hour doesn't seem long enough."
06/16/2012 page 96
22.0% "Taivaallisena magneettina? Miksei sitä voinut kutsua suoraan gravitaatiokaivoksi?"
06/16/2012 page 116
27.0% "She's an idiot."
06/16/2012 page 120
28.0% "Axis of evil."
06/16/2012 page 123
29.0% "Kim Jong-Ill is still alive in this."
06/16/2012 page 128
30.0% "Why isn't she fact checking these things by comparing the information to other known sources? And even if the facts would match, that doesn't mean Mick's conclusions are right.

I'm not convinced by Dom's and Mick's close connection."
06/16/2012 page 132
31.0% "Racists."
06/16/2012 page 155
36.0% "Do they still have film cameras in this?"
06/16/2012 page 183
43.0% "Merlin!"
06/16/2012 page 210
49.0% ""Iz ja veneen omistaja ottivat minut mukaan yhtenä viikonloppuna ja pitivät minulle pikakurssin."

"Kunhan eivät törmäyskurssia.""
06/16/2012 page 247
58.0% "A supersonic airplane in 2012? Dammit. Concorde is back and no one told me."
06/16/2012 page 263
61.0% "The only characters that make me feel anything are the villains. I loathe them. But that kind of makes me want to cheer for their win."
06/16/2012 page 263
61.0% "That explains Borgia's motives, not Mick's. I, mistakenly, thought you were smarter than that, Foletta."
06/16/2012 page 264
62.0% "Too stupid to live."
06/16/2012 page 266
62.0% "I'm confused. Is he against fusion research on principle or just the fusion bombs?"
06/17/2012 page 316
74.0% "What the everloving fuck?"
06/18/2012 page 356
83.0% "W.T.F."
06/18/2012 page 376
88.0% "Every time these characters say "I love you" I roll my eyes. I'm currently suffering from excessive eye rolling induced headache."

No comments have been added yet.