Paula's Reviews > Hope

Hope by Dennis Phillips
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Jun 29, 2012

liked it
bookshelves: fiction
Read from June 13 to 29, 2012

For at least half of this rather long novel (574 pp), I was entranced & would have given the book 5 stars. However, at some point 2/3 of the way in, I started to get bored. Structurally, at first, Hope interweaves several stories & at first the reader is pleasantly at sea, lost among the dreamer, the dream & the dreamt. There are two primary tales, each with doubles: the first takes place in 13th century Italy & involves the monk Father Guido Benedictus (our guide & benediction) & Chiara Masci,(clarity & perhaps charity) his sister-in-law (his brother Thomas married her sister). To complicate matters, the recently deceased pope was Chiara's brother & Guido & Thomas's childhood friend. Father Benedictus & Chiara are left on an uninhabited island where they eventually entertain or educate themselves with a tale they tell themselves wherein Thomas & his daughter Gemma are still alive on the island as well. We learn at some point that the story of Benedictus & Chiara is one written by the poet Joseph Spero (Prospero) himself exiled to an uninhabited island after having been arrested by agents of the Central Authority while in Scotland with a friend (Emerson!). Further in, Joseph's story switches to his self-imposed exile at a paradisaical house on the Big Island of Hawaii (one offered to him by a world-renowned musician friend Mendelssohn). He has run away to escape his obsession with what he sees as his betrayal by his friend, his abandonment by his married lover Carmen & thinly veiled threats to his well being by Carmen's ex-husband Roger. I was disappointed that Phillips dropped the Joseph Spero Robinson Crusoe narrative in favor of the Hawaii get away while keeping both versions of the medieval tale in play. I became bored with Joseph Spero, the escapee poet, his minutely described sex life with Carmen & later Elizabeth & his overall self-indulgence. (spoiled brat) I find many of the novels that are set in University English Departments or the world of publishing (an actual poetry publishing world is a bit hard to believe) just uninteresting. Although any milieu should be ripe for fiction, those two seem worn out to me. Read Hope for the dream & Father Benedictus while metaphorically kicking solipsistic Joseph Spero in the shins.
1 like · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Hope.
Sign In »

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

Three stars seems like a high rating for something that sounds as dull and unreadable as this does. I agree on the English Dept. setting, but even worse is the Cultural Studies world.
Heat & drought here mean gardening is time-consuming and exhausting. blah!

Paula My review came off a bit harsh. I actually liked the novel quite a bit, at least the first 2/3 of it.

back to top