Julie's Reviews > Sacred Country
Sacred Country
by Rose Tremain, Julie Rubenstein
by Rose Tremain, Julie Rubenstein
Julie's review
bookshelves: british-isles-theme-setting, best-of-2012, read-2012, historical-fiction
Mar 26, 12
bookshelves: british-isles-theme-setting, best-of-2012, read-2012, historical-fiction
Read from March 12 to 18, 2012
Mary Ward stands shivering in a Suffolk, England field in February, 1952 and realizes she is meant to be a boy. She is just six years old. Within its opening pages Sacred Country promises to take you on a literary journey that will be long and painful. Rest assured, it will also be beautiful and transformative.
Although Mary and her quest for her physical identity are at the heart of Sacred Country, it is a book full of souls searching for emotional purchase. Mary's mother has a tenuous grip on sanity, losing her way at intervals and regaining her footing in a nearby mental hospital; Mary's father is in danger of losing the family farm and slips further into madness borne of anger and alcohol; her brother loses his dream of becoming an Olympic swimmer because he is too afraid to dive. A village friend, Walter, dreams of becoming a country-and-western singer, but must take over the family butcher shop when his father dies. It seems that there is nothing but heartbreak in gray and lifeless post-war Britain, that the future is alive in vibrant cities and on warm continents but in rural England the past rots in small and suspicious minds.
Yet Tremain offers enough light in the gloom that hope propels you forward. Mary's awkward courage as she stumbles through her transformation from Mary to Martin makes her so lovable. And she is surrounded by a small but formidable defense of friends and loved ones: her grandfather, who accepts her unconditionally; her beloved teacher who embraces her intellect and shelters her when home life becomes unbearable; the cricket-bat maker who believes in reincarnation; his maid (who becomes his lover, then his wife) and her daughter, Pearl, who breaks Mary's heart and helps it to heal.
Rose Tremain's writing is flawless. Although this is a narrative focused on character development, the plot moves steadily forward. Although there are numerous characters and several sub-plots, there is a sense of the whole within each part. Vivid details of time and place hold you firmly in each era, the characters evolving with their age, changing with the times. The characters' senses of humor and irony clear the air that could easily turn maudlin under the pen of a less-deft writer.
This is a book about transformation, about letting go of those who cannot change and embracing those who try. Sacred Country touched me profoundly with its humanity, its hope, its brutality and its intense love. It is rare that I close a book and cry at its end. This is a rare book, indeed.
Although Mary and her quest for her physical identity are at the heart of Sacred Country, it is a book full of souls searching for emotional purchase. Mary's mother has a tenuous grip on sanity, losing her way at intervals and regaining her footing in a nearby mental hospital; Mary's father is in danger of losing the family farm and slips further into madness borne of anger and alcohol; her brother loses his dream of becoming an Olympic swimmer because he is too afraid to dive. A village friend, Walter, dreams of becoming a country-and-western singer, but must take over the family butcher shop when his father dies. It seems that there is nothing but heartbreak in gray and lifeless post-war Britain, that the future is alive in vibrant cities and on warm continents but in rural England the past rots in small and suspicious minds.
Yet Tremain offers enough light in the gloom that hope propels you forward. Mary's awkward courage as she stumbles through her transformation from Mary to Martin makes her so lovable. And she is surrounded by a small but formidable defense of friends and loved ones: her grandfather, who accepts her unconditionally; her beloved teacher who embraces her intellect and shelters her when home life becomes unbearable; the cricket-bat maker who believes in reincarnation; his maid (who becomes his lover, then his wife) and her daughter, Pearl, who breaks Mary's heart and helps it to heal.
Rose Tremain's writing is flawless. Although this is a narrative focused on character development, the plot moves steadily forward. Although there are numerous characters and several sub-plots, there is a sense of the whole within each part. Vivid details of time and place hold you firmly in each era, the characters evolving with their age, changing with the times. The characters' senses of humor and irony clear the air that could easily turn maudlin under the pen of a less-deft writer.
This is a book about transformation, about letting go of those who cannot change and embracing those who try. Sacred Country touched me profoundly with its humanity, its hope, its brutality and its intense love. It is rare that I close a book and cry at its end. This is a rare book, indeed.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Sacred Country.
sign in »
Reading Progress
| 03/15/2012 | page 110 |
|
33.0% | "A book I can sink my brain into. Thus far beautiful and heartbreaking, with Tremain's powerful, wondrous prose." |
Comments (showing 1-14 of 14) (14 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jeanette
(new)
Mar 12, 2012 07:54pm
Why did I think you'd already read this? Maybe it was I that tried to read it. Middle age -- gotta love it.
reply
|
flag
*
This is the oldest entry on my to-read shelf! From the summer of 2008, when I joined Goodreads. I'm getting sick of seeing it come up- I'm trying to work through these old entries- they're either gonna be read this year or deleted!
It was a different Tremain book I was thinking of, The Way I Found Her, which I gave up on and you didn't rate very highly. I can't remember why I didn't try this one. Either subject matter or present tense writing. I don't think I have any to-reads from when I first joined. I figure if something has been there for awhile and I haven't sought it out yet, I must have lost interest.
Oh, that was a bit of a stinker, wasn't it (The Way I Found Her)?! I regularly cull my To-Read shelf- like you, I weigh past and current enthusiasms- but there are some I know/believe will be worth the read. Most are older books or books I own, so getting my hands on a copy isn't an issue. Unfortunately, these seem to get shoved aside for library deliveries from my holds request inventory and languish, nearly forgotten. I'm not sure why I've kept the Tremain all this time, but so far, so good!
When I see that I don't have any library requests coming up for delivery, I sneak in something from my own shelves or an old TBR. Virgo: systematic is thy middle name. :D
Of course, I received word today of a waiting book that I am SO keen to read: The Submission. But I'll leave it at the library until the weekend - give this one a fair shake.
Now that I review other Tremain novels I've read, it was Trespass I found pretty awful. The Way I Found Her...I remember loving the writing but struggling through the somnolent plot. So far, this is up there with The Road Home and The Colour.
I rarely put books I own on my to-read shelf here. They stare at me from the bookcase, so I don't need to be reminded of them. I do remember how you disliked Trespass. The Way I Found Her got on my nerves pretty early on. But My first Tremain was The Colour, so I was expecting much better.
Re The Submission, I'm interested in your opinions. When I finished that book, I wrote my review straight from the heart because I knew other early reviewers would pick it apart and analyze it. And they did.
The Colour was the first Tremain I read- knocked my socks off. I've read several others. She has an astonishing range- style, era, theme - even those I didn't care for still impressed me- she's an extraordinary WRITER, if not always the best storyteller. But her, like The Colour and The Road Home, she nails both.
Putting together a "long plane ride, jet lag for sure" reading list and will add this. I loved The "Road Home". Must check out "The Colour".
Maureen wrote: "Putting together a "long plane ride, jet lag for sure" reading list and will add this. I loved The "Road Home". Must check out "The Colour"."Mo- this is just me, but I prefer light-hearted stuff when I travel. It's totally up to your preferences, but Sacred Country is pretty ponderous and heavy stuff. Even The Colour is quietly intense and moody. What else are you thinking of taking?
Two very ponderous and heavy things! :-) I don't mind heavy but ponderous may not be good when stuffed in a flying sardine can.... These have been in the running:"Forgotten Country"
http://www.chapters.indigo.ca/books/F...
"Dogs at the Perimeter"
http://www.chapters.indigo.ca/books/D...
"Breaking Night"
http://www.chapters.indigo.ca/books/B...
They are all pretty heavy-lol! I don't travel until the end of May....any light hearted recs? I just read one that I was going to take..."How it All Began" by Penelope Lively. Pretty good...would have been a good plane book but it came in for me at the library so I went for it.
Allie read "The Book Thief" on the plane to Egypt with Ron-no way could I have read that in public as I was a blubbering mess at the end-as was Allie!
So serious!!! You're supposed to be having FUN on holiday, not thinking :)What about The Ex-Pats : http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/12/boo...
The Snow Child :
http://www.washingtonpost.com/enterta...
Arcadia http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/19/boo...
Caveat- I haven't read any of these!

