Another win for Scott Snyder, much better than whatever the hell Grant Morrison was doing. Some of the best Batman writing in years. Snyder is clearly the man, & the right guy for this character right now.
-more self contained story than Black Mirror. Tighter, no offshoots or distractions.
-brings the detective element of his character to the forefront
-dark, as Batman should be. Some people might be tired of him being obsessed, paranoid, unreachable, etc - but that is who he is. Damaged.
-new villain, & a good one! Ones? Anyway, a welcome addition, with a realistic, intimidating henchman/henchmen. Talon is a badass, & a legitimate threat.
-uses Batman history & weaves in new history convincingly
-very much feels like it could be in Nolan universe, even with Nightwing/Robin. But I don't think this Batman is yelling all the damn time.
-art not as quite as good as Black Mirror, at least to me. But then I'm nuts about Francavilla's stuff. Capullo's Bruce Wayne is waaaayyyy too pretty (as are a lot of people not wearing masks).
-a bit of a deus ex machina in the final reveal, that I cannot mention without spoilers. Not sure why it happens, how Batman knows - or why it matters, though it kind of fits.
-upside down pages, which I thought was deliberate at first, as it fit the story at that point in time (coincidentally), but its just a misprint
... despite that nitpicking, entirely worth reading. Be aware, if you're not reading the issues, this is a cliffhanger - & you'll want to see where it goes - in other words, they got the job done.