Estara's Reviews > And All the Stars

And All the Stars by Andrea K. Höst

by
3590834
's review
Sep 24, 12

bookshelves: ebook, read-in-2012, favorites
Recommended to Estara by: auto-buy author
Recommended for: everyone who likes the Touchstone trilogy ... well... everyone, really ^^
Read from September 21 to 23, 2012 — I own a copy, read count: 1

How to do a non-spoilery review of this? I think I'll have to save a real review until my next read - which won't be long from now - when the book is actually out and I can squee and discuss with more people, so here are some bookpushy highlights that hopefully don't give too much away:

I wrote this on the Booksmugglers On The Smuggler's Radar post this week (cleaned for spelling errors :P)

It’s teenage apocalypse without dystopia! It’s got humour, it’s got an action plot of breathlessness, it’s got multi-racial characters of all sexual persuasions (it’s even got a cross-dressing, suave, successful actor – who doesn’t look like, but whose vibe reminded *me* of Tim Curry as Franknfurter when he’s at his charismatic best). There’s love in the face of utter adversity, there’s sacrifice, there’s a Three Musketeers leitmotif.

BRILLIANT BOOK! If the world were fair it should catapult Andrea Höst into fans' minds as much as Code Name Verity did Elizabeth Wein this year.


That last bit was added because I cried three times after the big plot reveal in the last third of the book and it was well earned crying because the book really grabbed me by the jugular and shook me - which is why I enjoyed reading the epilogue especially. Otherwise the two books share great characterisation and female friendship, but everything else is different (so fellow CNV lovers, don't expect this to be a WW2 exploration of the awesomeness of female friendship - it's a sf exploration of the awesomeness of friendship in general, female friendship included)

This is an ensemble book - like the Touchstone Trilogy but more so, even though we have a clear main heroine. The people Madeleine meets become incredibly important to her AND all contribute to the story and everyone we share more than one scene with is their own person, even when they're fairly quiet.

This book is told from third person and is not a diary-entry book which makes the action and dialogue more prominent and more immediate. It's also somewhat a love-letter to Sydney.

And during the build-up I could NOT believe that the page amount of the book could ever lead to a satisfying conclusion and not feel cut-off, but the author really managed it for my money.

I've read all her published books and for my money, this is the tightest book she's written so far (bear in mind that I'm a reader for character and emotion so plot and action fine-tuning usually fly past me). It's unputdownable from at least the point that the core group get together for good till the end.

It would be a GREAT movie or TV series. The sf bits of the story hint at a consistent world of their own, but the focus is square on the group of friends in adversity. And it's an encouraging book with an ending of sweetness mixed with a deeply-felt dollop of bitter to remember.

ETA: And a very big thank you to Andrea Höst, who sent me this not only early, but in response to me making her aware of about 10 mistakes left in 800+ pages of Touchstone Trilogy (no longer, because she's incorporated the corrections by now) which I had sent without being asked, may I add. A class act all around!

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read And All the Stars.
sign in »

Quotes Estara Liked

Andrea K. Höst
“We would never have met," he explained, voice dropping to a husky note. "I would have gone about my life and not thought I was missing anything. You would have – you would have painted obsessively, all those transformative images, and I would be someone unimagined and unknown, and I cannot decide whether it would be trite to call that a tragedy or if I should resent you for making this – all this death – somehow bearable, tolerable for the tenuous joy I have gained. You steal my anger and leave me dazed."

He stopped, took a shaking breath, then laughed.

"I sound like Pan's understudy, failing to channel Shakespeare. There's no way to do more than guess what would have happened if Fisher Charteris and Madeleine Cost met one day in a world which had never feared dust, any more than we can be certain of surviving two years, or two days. I can't speak to what-ifs, but I know I will always be glad to have been here in this moment with you.”
Andrea K. Höst, And All the Stars


Reading Progress

09/21/2012 page 61
23.46% ""Half the world is dead, we just robbed four stores, and you're worried about liking a guy two years younger than you?"
"Priorities, I have them.""
09/23/2012 page 154
59.0% ""What are you writing?"
"Thank you note for the owners of the house," Noi said, frowning as she read it over. "Miss Manners totally needs to add a chapter on squatting during an apocalypse.[...]""
09/23/2012 page 155
59.0% "Fight. Always fight. No matter how impossible the odds, no matter who you've lost, how you've been hurt. If there doesn't seem to be a way out, look for one. If you seem to have come to an end, start afresh. Never, ever give up."

Comments (showing 1-19 of 19) (19 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Estara I am soo looking forward to this one ^^


message 2: by Li (new) - rated it 4 stars

Li Arrrghhhh... you have a copy! Love that quote. I'm really looking forward to hearing what you think.


Estara heeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

indeed! Andrea was so kind to send one to me when I made her aware of the few mistakes I had still found in the Touchstone Trilogy omnibus (very gracious reaction, as she hadn't asked for it).

Just finished it today.

Let me sum it up: you will love it. I'll be trying to write a spoiler-reduced review shortly.


message 4: by Li (new) - rated it 4 stars

Li That is all I needed to know :-) One more week...


Laura (Kyahgirl) thanks so much for the rec. this sounds really good!


message 6: by Estara (last edited Sep 23, 2012 12:07pm) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Estara Laura, I'm not sure whether this or the Touchstone Trilogy is my favourite read of hers, it's that good.


TheBookSmugglers I can't wait to read this.
(Ana)


Estara TheBookSmugglers wrote: "I can't wait to read this.
(Ana)"

1st reaction: Wowhooo!

2nd reaction: I believe you should convince Thea to try it, too! She might enjoy an apocalyptical book (and it really is that) which is NOT a dystopia and has an uplifting end even though the losses are faced and addressed and remembered.


message 9: by Darlynne (new) - added it

Darlynne Thanks for the reminder. I'm looking forward to reading.


Estara ^^ I'm looking forward to hearing your impression.


Rachel Brown Thanks for the rec!


message 12: by Estara (last edited Sep 24, 2012 03:56am) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Estara Rachel, if you read it I'd be very interested in your impressions, because as I told Sartorias I think a lot of the things you want to see in YA is in this book (not everything - the Aborigines may be in the background of some of the characters heritage, but they don't play a central role - she has a tiny short, Blue, where they do - but it is mixed racial, mixed sexual orientation without shaming, Bechdel Test passing, non dark-grim, NOT a young hero has to fight against the state, etc. ^^). That's why I thought you might like it ^^


Rachel Brown Sounds right up my alley.


message 14: by Estara (last edited Sep 24, 2012 12:47pm) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Estara I hope so ;-)


message 15: by Shveta (new) - added it

Shveta Thakrar Sounds awesome! Thanks for pointing it out. :)


Estara I hope you'll enjoy it if you try it, Shveta ^^


Estara And for any taste testers, I'm having an ebook giveaway until October 3rd here: http://www.goodreads.com/user_status/...


Laura (Kyahgirl) You are so generous! I bought it this morning so don't need to be entered. I'm really looking forward to this book. :-)


Estara Awww - maybe you could send your friends my giveaway's way, then. I do want to spread the fun ^^.


back to top