Kirstine's Reviews > V for Vendetta
V for Vendetta
by Alan Moore, David Lloyd
by Alan Moore, David Lloyd
I've loved the movie version of this ever since I first saw it, and it always made me sad how Alan Moore apparently didn't approve of it. I see now why he might have been disappointed, but I was not (this is perhaps helped by the fact that I didn't write the comic). I still love the movie, but there is no doubt the graphic novel is somewhat superior.
It just... It's a work of utter brilliance. And intelligence and insight into humanity. Sure some of the 'predictions' haven't come true or were flawed back when it was written, but the heart of it, the core of it, is so strikingly true and profound. It will change your life.
V is one of my all-time favourite characters. A man, nay, an ideal, someone who believes in all the things I hold most dear; freedom, justice, love. And when they became corrupted: anarchy. Sweet, reckless anarchy. V is someone who is willing to fight for these things, completely unapologetically (and I mean that, he is NOT sorry for killing a few people who are in his way), and I admire that.
Plus it's interesting! You don't meet people like that in the real world.
The art is beautiful as well, a bit raw and edgy, and wonderfully detailed. And the story itself is, of course, fantastic. Sometimes the words struck me the hardest, sometimes the art, sometimes both combined. In any case, there are parts of this that will knock you sideways and have you fumbling a bit in the dark, as your ideas and beliefs crumble around you - or perhaps you'll recognize the liberation you've once felt yourself. The sudden knowledge that all you must do is stand up and say no; you're free.
Do as I did, and borrow it from your local library or a friend or buy it (as I will later), but get your hands on it. NOW.
I absolutely recommend this to everyone.
It just... It's a work of utter brilliance. And intelligence and insight into humanity. Sure some of the 'predictions' haven't come true or were flawed back when it was written, but the heart of it, the core of it, is so strikingly true and profound. It will change your life.
V is one of my all-time favourite characters. A man, nay, an ideal, someone who believes in all the things I hold most dear; freedom, justice, love. And when they became corrupted: anarchy. Sweet, reckless anarchy. V is someone who is willing to fight for these things, completely unapologetically (and I mean that, he is NOT sorry for killing a few people who are in his way), and I admire that.
Plus it's interesting! You don't meet people like that in the real world.
The art is beautiful as well, a bit raw and edgy, and wonderfully detailed. And the story itself is, of course, fantastic. Sometimes the words struck me the hardest, sometimes the art, sometimes both combined. In any case, there are parts of this that will knock you sideways and have you fumbling a bit in the dark, as your ideas and beliefs crumble around you - or perhaps you'll recognize the liberation you've once felt yourself. The sudden knowledge that all you must do is stand up and say no; you're free.
Do as I did, and borrow it from your local library or a friend or buy it (as I will later), but get your hands on it. NOW.
I absolutely recommend this to everyone.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read V for Vendetta.
sign in »
Comments (showing 1-10 of 10) (10 new)
date
newest »
newest »
You must!They kept most of it, but they did change one key thing: The novel is relies heavily on the idea of anarchy, something that isn't in the movie at all.
Alan Moore says "It was about fascism, it was about anarchy, it was about England", and he is right, those things are important to the novel, and not to the movie.
But there are still things I believe the movie got right. They might have left out anarchy (a shame, because V has this fabulous conversation with a statue of Lady Justice about him and her and Anarchy), but they did manage to capture, what I think is the essence of the novel (sorry Alan Moore), namely to free yourself - and fight for your right to think (and decide) for yourself.
Oh, right on. I hear Moore has hated every adaptation of his work, so at least this one got the heart of it right. Perhaps they left the anarchy bit out to make the film easier to swallow for a general audience? I hear there is a scene with the police detective fueled by LSD as well? Too bad that wasn't left in.I suppose I should read this now and see for myself ha. Great review by the way!
Loved the movie and the book. Actually this is the book of the month discussion at our group right now. Anyway I like the way where the book or the movie makes you think about deep things. For me it made me think whether V is a rebel freedom fighter or a terrorist. I guess it would depend on which viewpoint you perceive him from... Kantian or Utilitarian. As far as Alan Moore not liking the movie, he never loved any of the movies made from his written material because he says he doesn't own them and that he probably didn't agree the movie interpretation of his written material.
I'd say read the graphic novel first and then, if you want, watch the movie. I loved both, but reading it won't be the same after you've watched it, and the novel really deserves to be enjoyed in its own right, without influence from the movie.
Totally agree with your review, very well put Kirstine.BTW, I see you haven't added Watchmento your list?
Ooops, Andrea, that's a mistake! I was planning on reading it back when I also read V for Vendetta, but then my library didn't have it, so I must have forgotten again. This was a good reminder! I'm definitely reading that as well.
I want to try the comic book, especially considering the collector's edition which comes with the mask, and while I think I have no qualms with the story, is the art really good? I downloaded a pdf once to see what it looked like and it wasn't all that, though maybe that was some old edition. Is there recoloring in this one?


I must!
How much of Moore's message did the film version alter?