Nate D's Reviews > The Stone Door

The Stone Door by Leonora Carrington

by
406701
's review
Jan 09, 13

bookshelves: surrealism, read-in-2012, favorites, previously-unreviewed
Recommended to Nate D by: the scent of cinnamon and wool and dust
Recommended for: those striking a path oblique to history
Read from May 01 to 02, 2012, read count: 2

All stories are true.

Chronological, linear time is an invention, a convenience. History is simultaneous and instantaneous. Events unfold exist in parallel at every era and culminate in an event outside of perceived history itself, at a point existing exactly next to our idea of the progression of time. At this point, the divided male and female impulses of the universe are united, and the existing order will be overturned. All that is known will be destroyed. In destruction, only in destruction, renewal.
"Sweet chaos, [...] and out of the chaos a new chaotic order never before dreamed by man."

Seemingly distilled from centuries of gnostic, alchemical, and occult theory and tempered in the fires of lived experience, The Stone Door reads like the potent merging of fairy tale and heretical hermetic codex. It has the power and conviction of myth, the portentous personal imagery of surrealism, and a diamond-pure conceptual heart, flecked with incantatory insight and philosophical depth. It is an anarchic statement of refusal and the guide-stones of escape.

Leonora Carrington is the finest surrealist writer I know of, wise and iconoclastic and mordantly funny, and this is her best book. I don't generally hold to a lot of occult theology and whatnot, but here she's assembled something strange and personal and momentous from these esoteric materials. And despite its significance, this has the deft narrative elegance of storytelling in its purest forms (myths, fairytales -- which have always been significant, after all). It is uncanny, gripping, perfect.



Previously, I'd only read this in a shortened novella form that Carrington prepared in 1988 for publication in The Seventh Horse And Other Tales, but this, finally, is the complete original, unpublished since '77, with an additional fifty pages*. Perhaps Carrington viewed these bits as inessential later, but as a curious (obsessed) reader, they're an incredible addition. The truncated version maintains the obscure gestalt of the story, but the original allows far more development, a much more complete picture.

Context: in 1940 or so, while in Spain attempting to secure asylum for Max Ernst as the Nazis swept into France, Carrington suffered a breakdown that resulted in some months at a psychiatric hospital. As she was discharged, her family dispatched a servant to retrieve her to England, but instead she slipped away to America via the Mexican embassy in Lisbon. After some time in New York City and the expat surrealist scene there (Breton was there at the time), she completed her original arrangement, which involved moving to Mexico and marriage to ambassador, poet, and friend of Picasso's, Renato Leduc. Then, adrift in an unfamiliar country in the mid 1940s, she wrote her first novel.

She's here in the pages, bored and and despairing in a stifling marriage in Mexico city. It seems like the bits of journal here, even with their symbolic and arcane asides, are probably a relatively accurate impression of sensations and conditions under which this novel was composed.
For centuries, they dressed up love for easy digestion as a fat little boy with wings, pale blue bows, and anemic-looking flowers. behind this bland decoration Love snarled its rictus through the ages. With shrieks of adoration, it flung itself on human breasts, “to crush you, to suck your life away. I cannot drag my own weight over the crust of the earth, so you must carry me on your back so that in time you will be crippled with my weight.” These words are in every heart in the mating season.



Within the novel, though, the seeker's desperation leads her not to write, but much further afield, into the secret trajectories along which the universe is arranged, and by which it may be broken. In particular, we're first introduced to a certain house out of time, in which a trio of scientist-mystics have entered into a conflict whose ripples will organize much of the rest of the story. These ripples radiate in all directions, striking in and out of the entire panorama of history.

I alluded to this idea of non-linear time before, which informs not only the plot, but the elegant structure of the book, as events brush against eachother across ages and vast distances to push the action cohesively to its climax. This aspect, handled in a completely unique manner to anything else I've encountered, was one of the most notable reductions in the novella version: the novella is the story of two timelines rushing to meet eachother in a third, whereas the novel gives a sensation of a much denser network of interconnections.

Sometimes, when you search for something and finally find it, it is disappointment in light of the search. This book is not such a case. Instead, it is a fulfillment of every potential.

*The novella is about 68 pages, this is 118. Even considering that the type is slightly larger here, there's at least 50% more story that had been cut, with new episodes, characters, expansion of motifs.



(re-read January 2013: some details are clarified, others cast into new doubt. Always a favorite. I've also been looking up all the references I can run down, particularly dense in the diary sections, if anyone is curious.)

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Stone Door.
sign in »

Reading Progress

05/01/2012 page 36
31.0% "All stories are true."

Comments (showing 1-13 of 13) (13 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Moira (new) - added it

Moira Russell Beautiful review.


message 2: by Mike (new) - added it

Mike Puma I'm sold. Wonderful review.


message 3: by Nate D (last edited May 02, 2012 04:49pm) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nate D Thanks! I can't recommend this enough. An incredibly strange book but extraordinarily lucid for that, and with a real sense of conviction. It's really like nothing else I've read, even among Carrington's stories.


message 4: by Miriam (new)

Miriam The Hearing Trumpet is excellent as well. Now I kind of wish I'd read this first as it sounds like there might be some progression of themes.


Nate D Yeah, I love that one as well! This almost feels more developed in a way, though written first -- if the Hearing Trumpet is about historical Isis cults and the restoration of the divine feminine, this is more holistic and more cosmic in its implications -- the remaking of the universe in the merging of its divided male and female halves. Writing that out, it's hard to actually express Carrington's ability to tell this as convincing myth rather than crank cult theology, but she totally pulls it off.


message 6: by Miriam (new)

Miriam I was going to read House of Fear before this one, unless you would recommend otherwise?


message 7: by Emilie (new) - added it

Emilie this is beautiful, nate. i'm drawn to the combination of the personal and the mythic. i've never read carrington, but i love her visual art.


Nate D Miriam, you should really read anything of hers you can get your hands on, which unfortunately isn't always easy. My favorties of her shorter stories are in the Seventh Horse, though, if you chance upon that one.

Emilie, I'd say she's as good a writer as a painter, a rare thing given how fantastic her paintings are.


message 9: by Curtis (new) - added it

Curtis Ackie Thanks for this, I've read The Hearing Trumpet, and really want to get my hands on a copy of this, which is proving difficult. One thing though, I'm pretty sure the third picture up there is by Remedios Varo.


Nate D Aha, you are correct. Thanks, and apologies for sloppy google image searching. (I just took that painting out, perhaps to replace it later.)


message 11: by Curtis (new) - added it

Curtis Ackie No problem, this one is gorgeous, if you like: http://poutingbear.tumblr.com/post/10...

Oh, and if you have any tips on how to get my hands on a copy of The Stone Door, I'm all ears!


Nate D Thanks, indeed an excellent one.

As for the book, I just stalked it on half.com until a copy appeared at a reasonable rate. Not the in the best of conditions, but thoroughly worth it. I usually set up automatic alerts on the more elusive books.


message 13: by Curtis (new) - added it

Curtis Ackie Cheers, I may just do that.


back to top