Marita's Reviews > The Coming of the Whirlpool

The Coming of the Whirlpool by Andrew McGahan

by
1479815
's review
Apr 19, 12

Read from April 11 to 19, 2012

Dow is born to be a woodcutter, being the eldest son, but finds his excitement quickly dulled once he begins his apprenticeship. But then he climbs to the headland on the edge of the forest and views the ocean for the first time. He is memsmerised - even more so when he sights great ships in the distance. But what use is a passion for the sea when you live in a village on the egde of the forest? And, what's more, where would such a notion come from?

Andrew McGahan has written a pleasing new world where these questions pose very difficult problems for Dow. Difficult, but not impossible. And even when it seems he will be able to follow a life which at least aproximates his heart's desire, unthoughtof barriers arise. New Island is his home. It was once a strong naval community, but has generations hence lost the ight to pursue a life on the seas. Now the people work to provide tribute to the Ship Kings - the nation that has ruled the seas since the Great War, generations ago. A life at sea is in fact forbidden to New Islanders.

The travails of Dow provide for an original and engaging story. I did find that the middle section of the novel spent too long on too few incidents, yet by the end I was immediately hoping that McGahan's publishers would get that second volume out quick smart.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Coming of the Whirlpool.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-6 of 6) (6 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

Trisha whipping through those Short List titles, miss. good to see.


Marita Trying - started with 2 of 6, now on to 4th. But we split them so there are two for after the hols! Love the list by the way - humour, fantasy, historical, romance, realism - no horror? Or is there some of that in Whirlpool?


Trisha Not a lot of horror options there to be honest. Where are you slotting 'straight line to my heart'?


Marita Not up to it yet - realism & romance?


Marita Not up to it yet - realism & romance?


Trisha It's actually quite funny. Maybe the generic term, 'contemporary'? See what you think anyway...


back to top