Daniela's Reviews > The Fatal Shore: The Epic of Australia's Founding

The Fatal Shore by Robert Hughes
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7172284
's review
May 05, 12

Read from April 09 to May 04, 2012

I don't feel able to give a star rating to this book. It's a dense, intensely researched book that I found incredibly hard work. Robert Hughes deserves full credit for this labour of love; until he wrote The Fatal Shore , no one else had dared to look at Australia's convict history. However, this book has serious problems.

First of all, as a history, it is primarily narrative in its structure. This is always going to hinder the analytical strength of the book and I felt that there was too much wadding and not enough substance. In a book that's well over 600 pages if you include notes and references, that's exasperating. However, as the book swings between New South Wales, Van Dieman's Land, Norfolk Island, and occasionally branches out to what will become Victoria and Queensland, the attempt at a narrative becomes confused. Either tell the story or analyse the history objectively. Don't try to do both.

Second, someone seems to have omitted the key inclusions of maps and timelines. When you are looking at a complex history spanning decades, these are invaluable. Show us who was governor when, what was happening back in the UK, and what Australia's human geography looked like in comparison.

Third, women were glanced over so summarily in this book that it made me shudder. Female convicts were a significant minority and whilst Hughes does devote all of half a chapter to their treatment, he makes no further analysis into their lives or into the effects of their treatment on Australia's future. Emancipist and Settler women are not covered at all and governors' wives are given a cursory glance. At least one of these governors' wives was regarded as being a significant power behind the throne, but Hughes reduces her to a cartoon character. That's not good enough.

Finally, what about Western Australia? It gets mentioned in the final pages of this epic book. Perth might have been founded a few decades after Sydney, but Western Australia comprises about one third of Australia's landmass. It doesn't deserve to be forgotten.

For a book that was heralded as ground-breaking and is regarded as being the seminal work on Australia's convict past, it left me disappointed and I was relieved to finish it.
1 like · likeflag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Fatal Shore.
sign in »

Reading Progress

04/14/2012 page 145
21.0%
04/17/2012 page 260
38.0% "I really shouldn't have read the chapter detailing the survival of some runaway convicts by cannibalism when eating my lunch."
04/28/2012 page 410
60.0% "I really shouldn't have read the chapter detailing the survival of some runaway convicts by cannibalism when eating my lunch."
show 1 hidden update…

No comments have been added yet.