the golden witch.'s Reviews > The Other Normals

The Other Normals by Ned Vizzini
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1101220
's review
Sep 25, 2012

really liked it
bookshelves: 2012, ebook, edelweiss, teenage-shennanigans, reviewed, for-review
Read from August 13 to September 24, 2012

3.5/5 stars.

This one was fun, but there's definitely a gender bias. But since there's so few YA lit for guys by guys, in this case, I think that's a good thing. "The Other Normals" is a tale of a tabletop RPG geek, coming of age, and trying to straddle both the worlds of being a child and being an adult - and being or going none of those things are easy. I think that the YA male audience is really going to hook into this one and relate a lot. Caution, there are a few spoilers in this review, so if you haven't read the book yet/don't want to be spoiled, tread carefully.

Vizzini manages to cram a lot into this one book - two worlds, a battle of good versus evil, and coming of age, to name a few. This isn't heavy reading, though - Vizzini has managed to make this one of the most lighthearted books on the matter of what it means to be a teenager today. And while there's some of the traditional tough stuff tropes thrown in to construct our MC Perry (divorce and bullying, to be specific), Perry is a pretty awesome MC who really manages to blossom and grow and by the book, by virtue of his character arc, is able to stand on his own two feet with pride, no longer fearing his peers. And that felt good to read.

What I kind of wanted more of was in the worldbuilding department of The World of the Other Normals - we're transported there and back multiple times, and while it's very rich in action and characters and generally a lot of fun, I just kind of wanted more. We do get important information on how the Other Normals' world matches our world, and the use of the multiverse/M-Theory to help explain that really kind of impressed me. I hadn't seen that coming. I also liked the idea of having "alternates" - your alternate self in the Other Normals' world or on Earth. I absolutely loved the sheer diversity in the amount of races in the world of the Other Normals - it just got so creative and original that I really kind of wanted to stand up and cheer. However, I think that the connections to Earth could have been more clearly laid out - with the explanation of how Earth/Other Normals' World works and with a certain character saying how the creators of C&C "got it all wrong", it was a bit too fuzzy for me. I wanted a more explicit explanation there, as well as more than just one map (though I'm glad we got one!) of that world, since it seemed to be built upon itself in layers (which was an awesome idea).

In terms of characters, I feel like Perry grew the most, and the rest grew through their alternates in the World of the Other Normals. I kind of wanted more in terms of how these other main cast characters (Sam, Jake, etc) were growing in the human world instead of the simple interactions/explanations we did get whenever Perry crossed over to either world. While I won't deny that this was an interesting way to grow characters, I still wanted more of a balance - it felt too much in the hands of the alternates, and while Vizzini really clearly lays out how alternates' behavior affect each other in either world, I wanted a clearer delineation of character growth in both worlds. You are not always your alternate, even if your alternate's behavior really heavily affects you. I also wanted on more on the female characters (Ada AND Anna) as I feel like they really got shortchanged in this book - though I will say that Ada did get more facetime than Anna did.

In terms of arcs, I think everything did flow fairly smoothly, though the transitions to the "changed" timeline each time Perry came back to Earth were, at points, a little clumsy. Sometimes parts of the plot felt very oversimplified, and there was a lack of tension - sometimes feeling like filler. However, the final fourth of the book really gave me the feeling that that's where Vizzini hit his stride, and everything really came together then. And that's always great to read.

Final verdict? There's not much YA lit on RPG geeks, so this was a really nice change of pace of reading for me. It's nice to see things written by dudes for dudes and giving them a bit of power in a largely female market. I really liked this one, though I wish it'd been a little bit better cleaned up. I'd still recommend it for those wanting to get out of the paranormal/contemporary rut that YA has gotten itself into because it really is a breath of fresh air in those areas. "The Other Normals" is out today from Balzer+Bray/HarperTeen in North America, so definitely be sure to check it out!

(posted to goodreads, shelfari, and birthofanewwitch.wordpress.com)
7 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Other Normals.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

09/23/2012 page 34
8.0%
09/24/2012 page 97
24.0% "Absolutely LOVING this one so far, guys. SO awesome and geeky. :D"

No comments have been added yet.