Emma Deplores Goodreads Censorship's Reviews > Ali and Nino: A Love Story

Ali and Nino by Kurban Said
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Apr 14, 2012

liked it
bookshelves: historical-fiction, azerbaijan, world-books-challenge, 3-stars-and-a-half, read-in-translation
Read from March 31 to April 01, 2012

This book was an unusual reading experience in a way I can’t quite put my finger on. It’s an engaging story, and accessible; the narrator, Ali, is candid about his thoughts and feelings. At the same time, I never lost sight of the fact that it comes from across a wide gap in time and culture.

Ali and Nino is set mostly in Baku, Azerbaijan, around the start of World War I. The two young people of the title--Ali Khan Shirvanshir, a Shi’ite Muslim of Iranian descent, and Nino Kipiani, a Georgian Christian--are in love, but the cultural divide complicates their relationship. Meanwhile, political upheaval threatens whatever happiness they’re able to find.

For the first part of the book, I thought the cultural and historical detail was more interesting than the plot, but the plot gets better as it goes and the last third is the most memorable. I especially liked the part dealing with the brief existence of the Republic of Azerbaijan. Ali and Nino’s relationship was also more interesting than I expected: rather than repeating the common boy-meets-girl plotline in which the characters fall in love, the book starts with them in love as of Chapter 1 and then looks the more difficult question of making that relationship work.

There’s definitely orientalism here--when the author’s biography is entitled The Orientalist, I guess that should come as no surprise. It’s not orientalist in the sense of being unable to look past the weirdness of an Asian society to its humanity and complexity--there is a diverse set of Muslim characters and who are individuals--but it certainly revels in the exotic and bizarre and sometimes backward aspects of “Asia” (one indicator that this is not a recent book is the use of “Asia” to refer to the Muslim world). There’s a sense of complicity with the reader in showing us all this weirdness; for instance, Nino denies the existence of Ali’s family’s eunuch servant to English diplomats for the sake of European social acceptability, but we the readers meet this character in all of his exotic glory. And some of the East-meets-West type scenes, like the car chase involving a car and a horse (you can guess who has the car and who the horse), feel a little over the top.

Graman’s translation is overall quite readable, but consistently uses archaic spellings (even though the translation itself only came out in 1970). At times I did wonder about its faithfulness: would Muslims really have referred to themselves as “Mohammedans,” even 100 years ago?

This sounds like a lot of criticism, but it is a fairly good book, set in a little-known part of the world but dealing with issues that are still timely today. One can tell it isn’t a recent book--there’s a lot of name-dropping that must have been familiar at the time but is quite obscure today--but the characters’ motivations are understandable and their story interesting. I’d recommend this book to those who are looking to branch out in their reading.
2 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Ali and Nino.
Sign In »

Comments <span class="smallText"> (showing 1-8 of 8) </span> <span class="smallText">(8 new)</span>

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tamara (new)

Tamara Oooh. I haven't read this, but I have read the mindbogglingly bizarre and utterly fascinating biography of the author, ("The Orientalist", by, er, Tom...something.) His real name, suffice to say, is not Kurban Said.

Emma Deplores Goodreads Censorship Wow, and here I just thought it was cool that somebody had set a book in Azerbaijan! That looks like a biography worth reading.

message 4: by Tamara (new)

Tamara It totally is! It's just filled with amazingly odd stuff and very well written. I have read many, many, many much duller and more tediously realistic fantasy novels.

message 5: by Tamara (new)

Tamara I got this out of the library as well...

Emma Deplores Goodreads Censorship It's good so far (about 80 pages in). I am sort of wondering though whether it's one of those books that's meant to attract Western readers with its exoticism. Where was the author from? (Summary of my edition's author bio: "WTF? We're confused.")

message 7: by Tamara (new)

Tamara ...maybe? IIRC, he did actually grow up in Baku, his family were Ukrainian jews, and he spent a lot of his life in Germany and the US, and had a lifelong orientalist fixation, having grown up with something of a foot in either camp. It's all very psychological, I suppose. (Personally, I'm a ukrainian jew who grew up in the middle east, has a bit of an orientalist fixation and yet mostly consumes decidedly western culture, and for fucks sake, i've never felt any of this angst about the whole thing. I kind of ended up rolling my eyes at Kurban Said/Lev Nussbaums poor tortured soul and dreadful lack of sense of belonging by the end of the biography.)

Emma Deplores Goodreads Censorship Authors do seem to have a tendency to angst over things that other people just take in stride. I think being overly sensitive helps them in their writing.

back to top