Madeline's Reviews > Breakfast at Tiffany's

Breakfast at Tiffany's by Truman Capote

by
111921
's review
Aug 05, 08

bookshelves: the-list, the-movie-is-better

This is getting shelved under "The Movie is Better" but honestly, I can't decide which version I prefer. Because I am indecisive, let's make lists.

Reasons The Movie Is Better:
-Audrey Hepburn plays a considerably less racist and foul-mouthed Holly, which is nice. But let's be honest: Holly could spend the entire movie snorting crack off a sidewalk and Audrey Hepburn would make it the most elegant and classy crack-snorting anyone had ever seen.
-Holly actually sets foot inside Tiffany's, instead of just talking about it. Also she is actually seen eating breakfast outside the store, instead of just mentioning it offhandedly.
-The lines, "It's useful being top banana in the shock department" and "I don't want you to take me home until I'm very drunk. Very drunk indeed."
-A happy, schmoopy, formulaic romantic ending in the rain that never fails to win me over. And they come back for Cat.
-George Peppard.

Reasons The Book Is Better:
-Mag Wildwood, a mere caricature in the movie, gets more lines, personality, and scenes in the book.
-Holly is eighteen at the beginning of the story, which makes her instantly more of a badass teen slut, which I admired her for.
-Mr. Yunioshi actually has a sizable shred of dignity and is vital to the plot. This did wonders to undo the damage caused by the sight of a sweaty, overtanned, bucktoothed Mickey Rooney leaning over a banister and screeching, "Missa Gorightry! I musta plotest!"

*shudder* Is Mickey Rooney dead? If not, could someone please find him and kill him for thinking he could successfully imitate a Japanese man without turning into a walking stereotype? Thank you.

That's all I can think of at the moment. Bottom line: the book made me sad, and the movie does not.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Breakfast at Tiffany's.
sign in »

Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)

dateDown_arrow    newest »

message 1: by Manny (new)

Manny I don't think you need to kill Mickey Rooney. From the Wikipedia article:
Current work

Rooney appeared in television commercials for Garden State Life Insurance Company in 1999, alongside his wife Jan. In commercials shown in 2007, Rooney can be seen in the background washing imaginary dishes.

Rooney continues to work in film and tours with his wife in a multi-media live stage production called Let's Put On a Show! On May 26, 2007, he was grand marshal at the Garden Grove Strawberry Festival. Rooney made his British pantomime debut, playing Baron Hardup in Cinderella, at the Sunderland Empire Theatre over the 2007 Christmas period. He appeared on BBC Points West dressed in a pair of shorts and socks. He has played Baron Hardup in Cinderella at the Bristol Hippodrome from December 12, 2008 to January 8, 2009.
Sounds to me like a fate considerably worse than death...


message 2: by Madeline (new) - rated it 3 stars

Madeline Oh dear. Well, I guess I can forgive him then - sounds like he's been through enough.

Also, he guest starred on The Simpsons once, and as far as I'm concerned anyone who does that is pretty okay.


Squiggles{Kelly} I couldn't agree with you more. Especially the Audrey Hepburn crack-snorting part. So true. :P


message 4: by Tarbuckle (new)

Tarbuckle Great review, but just to scratch a pedantic itch: you don't snort crack, you smoke it. Always.


back to top